Joiner-Planer
Jorge
I am thinking of getting a joiner planer, with a small foot print around 13" capacity.
If you have one, I would love to hear what make and how you like it
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Joiner-Planer
Jorge
I am thinking of getting a joiner planer, with a small foot print around 13" capacity.
If you have one, I would love to hear what make and how you like it
Re: Joiner-Planer
John McGaw
I have a Robland all-in-one machine which combines their sliding-table saw/shaper with their jointer/planer/slot-mortiser. The jointer/planer works just fine for everything I've tried over the years. The only downside is the changeover time which does force you to think about your workflow more than separate machines would. No real downside other than that and, with my ridiculously tiny shop, there really wasn't any other way to go.
Re: Joiner-Planer
Chuck Kettler
Hitachi P12RA. Added extensions to the jointer which were OK for awhile. Then went with an 8" jointer. Planer is fine as long as you take small increments. Kinda loud though with a universal motor. Mine has lasted 20+ years.
Re: Joiner-Planer
Walt
Jet JJP-12 here (straight knives). It does what I bought it to do, the changeover aspect is not as bad as some make it out to be. It does help to plan ahead a little. The jointer tables are 55", not as long as some long bed dedicated jointers. Going by the rule of thumb that max practical jointing length is 1.5X -2X bed length, 82" - 110" is plenty for my purposes. The planer portion doesn't have bed rollers nor chip breaker, like a 4 post planer. I don't notice the lack of either.
There is one potential issue planing. You can't leave the planer depth of cut set when switching to the jointer mode. If you need 4 pieces, plane 4 pieces, move the planer bed to joint then mess one piece up, you may have to make a few passes to get the thickness of the new piece to match the others. A digital readout of some sort is a big help there. If you're able to leave a planer set it's easier/quicker to match earlier pieces.
Re: Joiner-Planer
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I've heard good reports about the Jet, but also that they went through a short period of out-of-parallel beds (here in Oz). If you go down the used path, then check this out. New ones appear to be fine.
I have a Hammer A3-31, which is 12" wide. This has spiral blades (after straight blades in separate machines, especially the thicknesser, the absence of noise is a delight). I love this machine! It is silent and smooth. Change overs are easy for a combination machine, but still require planning workflow. There is a digital readout, which is super accurate, and one can return to make a new piece to a prior dimension. It is a pricy machine, and so the cheaper Jet is worth a look.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Joiner-Planer
Hank Knight
I had a little Inca 570 jointer planer for 25 years. I built a lot of stuff with it, from my workbench, a desk for my daughter and several book cases to mention just a few. I loved that machine. I have a small basement shop and the Inca's small footprint was perfect and it gave me 10" of jointing and planing capacity.
Several years ago I had the opportunity to upgrade my Inca with a Hammer A3-31 12" jointer planer. It is a much heavier, more solid and powerful machine than my Inca with a little more capacity. It has been a wonderful upgrade. I really like it, although I still have a warm place in my heart for the Inca.
I would love to have a big 12" "old iron" jointer and a 15" planer, but I will never have the room for those machines. Meanwhile, I am very happy and satisfied with my combo machine. It does everything I need and does it very well. The only thing I would change is that I would love to replace my straight blade cutter-head with a spiral Byrd Shelix or similar.
Re: Joiner-Planer
Jorge
John,
I hear really good things about the Robland, but I don't need all those capabilities, These days I am basically a production turner, but I still have a warm spot in my hearth for flat work. I have a table saw, and need a band saw and want a joiner planer, I could do a lot of work with that set up with less money invested.
Re: Joiner-Planer
Jesse Cloud
This is very anecdotal, but a couple of years ago I took a course in woodworking machine maintenance at a local community college. The instructor invited us to bring in machines that had problems or new machines that needed to be set up.
Three students brought in new jointer/planer combo machines. The grizzly took six hours to set up, due to a few issues, another brand I don't remember took about an hour, the Jet took thirty minutes, but that was all testing for errors. Turns out the Jet was well calibrated right out of the box.
Interesting enough, all three machines looked incredibly similar, like they came off the same line. Main observable difference was in color and switches. Clearly they had different specs for quality.
I looked at the Grizzly site to see whether they still had the same model, and the combo machine was labeled "Replaces Gxxxx, not yet in stock" so maybe they have stood up to the issues...
Derek, Hank
Jorge
A quiet machine!
I would love that. I will look into that Hammer A3-31
Thank you!
Re: Joiner-Planer
Jorge
Jesse,
Good to know about the Jet, if the Hammer A3-31 is out of reach I will look at the Jet
Thank you
Re: Joiner-Planer
TomD
I have the inca jointer planer, currently the planer function is down and I have been trying to sell it as the jointer only, though it looks like something that can be fixed. This is my third Inca, and I only bought it in a set because I wanted a base that came with another machine. If I had the space I would always have an Inca around, they are both a serious machine for very accurate work, and light enough to move to the jobsite.
The advantage for me was having machines that jointed and planed to the same width. The disadvantage is switching, which obviously some machines do better than others. In theory one can run all of one kind of work, and then switch over to the other. In practice one sometimes needs to switch with every cut.
Re: Joiner-Planer *LINK*
John McGaw
I probably didn't state things clearly in my reply. When Robland made their machine they combined two different multi-function machines into one behemoth. The jointer/planer was (and so far as I know still is) available separately and the slot mortiser that goes onto it was (is?) an option. Take a look at this:
Robland jointer/planer
Thanks John!
Re: Joiner-Planer
JohnM in Mid Michigan
I have the Rojek MSP 310M 12" combo machine that is made in Czech Republic, and marketed in the US by Rojek USA (http://www.rojekusa.com). Have been using it for about 7 or 8 years. Quite convenient as there is essentially no changeover at all, just move the chip extractor hood. I lust for a spiral indexed cutter head, but can't quite justify it's expense. When I was shopping, this unit, among the european machines, seemed to offer the best value and feature set.
Re: Joiner-Planer
Walt
"I've heard good reports about the Jet, but also that they went through a short period of out-of-parallel beds (here in Oz). If you go down the used path, then check this out. New ones appear to be fine."
That's good to know, Derek. Some people have reported an issues with that and has scared others off, assuming it was a widespread problem.
Re: Joiner-Planer
Jorge
Thanks John, good to know, Rojek is a new one to me.
Mini-max
Tom Sontag - St. Louis
I have a Minimax machine and would buy it again (although that spiral head Hammer sounds sweet). Mine impressed my neighbor enough that he bought one too, and he has an enviable Hammer table saw. Perhaps minimax is cheaper than the Hammer?
Re: Joiner-Planer
JohnM in Mid Michigan
Let me know if you have specific questions about the Rojek as it is not commonly referenced here on WC.
I second Derek's entry on A3-31 **pic**
Adam of Oakland
I got the Hammer A3-31 this summer. I never had a jointer to compare it to (other than what I can do with a jack plane -- such good practice, by the way!), and my planer is/was a lunchbox style Ridgid model that has 3 knives. Works fine, but sooo loud.
The Hammer is a joy to use because it's quiet and powerful. Changeover is OK. I try to plan ahead if i'm doing a lot of jointing/planing to first do the jointing, and then switch over to planing. There is about a minute of time spent going from one mode to another. jointer to planer mode:
1) loosening the jointer fence and moving it inboard (so that it does not interfere with where theplaner beds want to rest)
2) lifting the planer beds out of the way, .
3) flipping the dust collection hood over and reconnecting the elbow to my pickup.
4) I also have to remember to lower the planer bed to about 6" in order to clear the dust collection hood when switching back to planing mode.
The fence needs to be adjusted whenever switching back to planing mode to make sure it is square, but I've found that this is not too big a deal, and once the hand tightening adjusters are set, they hold pretty well.
I love this machine. It is the most costly machine in my shop by several fold (my other stationary machines are Grizzly), but i also feel that for this operation, I didn't want something that would be frustrating to use.
The segmented cutterhead is quiet. My dust collector is louder by far.
Dust collection needs to be thought through with this guy. You want to make sure it's easy to move from one mode to another without stumbling over a dust hose. I routed 4" ABS from a rafter across my shop and have flex conduit going to the machine with a 90 deg elbow. So far, I'm very happy with how this performs, and i'm just using a harbor freight collector for the impeller. See planer to the right of the shop here:

Re: I second Derek's entry on A3-31 **pic**
Jorge
Adam,
Thanks for the endorsement.
What a nice shop! spacious and beautiful light!
Re: Joiner-Planer
Jorge
Thanks John,
Where did you buy it? I am in the middle of home repairs, so have not done more searching.
Re: Mini-max
Jorge
Thanks Tom,
There is one in this town, I will ask owner to show it to me.
Another pic of the A3-31 ..
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
.. to ogle over.

I would kill for the space Adam has. My machinery is crammed into one quarter of a double garage, as the remainder is focussed on handtools.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Joiner-Planer
JohnM in Mid Michigan
I got mine direct from http://www.rojekusa.com via an eBay posting, which I do not think they do on a regular basis, but you might check.
Thank you!