Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT Rant - Parts Dept.

Posts

OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#1

OT Rant - Parts Dept.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Part of my HVAC system is a small condensate pump that takes care of both the A/C drains and the winter humidifiers' excess. These pumps are simple with a float-operated micro switch and a check valve.

The pump commences cycling about once every minute or so for maybe 2 seconds, rather than pumping for about a minute that it usually takes to pump the half-gallon pan dry.

New pump is $45.

The problem is the little micro switch, a simple SPST 0/| unit, usually a $2 item, and easily replaced.

So I call the company, confirm my analysis with the tech and get forwarded to their parts "store".

"Yes, sir, we have that part. Switch is $14.95 plus $6.45 shipping."

I'm tempted to ask the guy if he sells a lot of them, but there's no use getting snarky with a mere employee who doesn't set prices.

Hmmm, $21 for a switch or $45 for a whole new pump, decisions, decisions . . .

Think I'll be looking for a different brand of pump!

Rant Off.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#2

ebd

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

ebd

I would as well. Shipping & handling should be included in the price so you know what you are paying. Simple replacement parts should be at cost +20-30%.

A recent order (not going to ID the company) for a screw replacement for a screw chuck was $9. Ouch - BUT the shipping was $8. Are you kidding??? Put it into a bubble envelope and USPS will deliver for far, far less than that.

I think S&H has become a positive cash flow stream that is semi-hidden.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#3

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

Larry

Mark Try going to surpluscenter.com they may have micro switches and as I remember they are fairly cheap. I bought some things from them and they worked OK. Larry

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#4

What is your time...

Paul in NJ

and gas worth driving somewhere to buy the part. We all bellyache about the price of shipping (including me), but I think it is cheaper than driving somewhere local if you can even find what you want locally. Everyone has overhead that is reflected in stocking and selling that part. The cost of shipping helps pay that overhead.

regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#5

I Expected shipping

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

but $15 for a $2 part is out of reason, and bespeaks a purpose to drive new sales rather than supporting existing units.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#6

Thanks, Larry

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Tried them and several others but nothing to fit. Not giving up though. ;)

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#7

Lucky to get them at all

Jesse Cloud

Most woodworking tool manufacturers seem to totally blow off any responsibility for stocking parts. I've given up trying to get anything from Delta/PorterCable/DeWalt. Bosch too for that matter.

I know that there are websites that specialize in finding odd parts, but its a real time sink to wade through those.

I'm actually thinking about downsizing my shop as I seem to be spending as much time maintaining tools as using them.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#8

Less than $25, it's a deal

Dick Coers

I have a switch going bad on a combination machine. They want $379.00 for that. Still haven't ordered it, can't get over the sticker shock!

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#9

Re: Less than a deal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Like the scruffy guy in the 4-color Pinto who shows up on your doorstep and turns out to be your 3rd cousin, twice removed, on your Mother's side, who's been wandering in the Bayou for the last 42 years and now seeks pitch his tent and his three wives in your back yard until . . . It's "relative."

When the price of a minor part gets to cost 50% of the price of the entire product, the situation is out of balance, especially when similar parts (but not exact matches) cost 1/8th of the asking price.

I was born at night, but not last night :\

Good luck with your switch, Dick.

Would that I could pull a Tim Allen.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#10

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

john lucas

Mark Back when I worked for Xerox we had parts that had huge mark ups. A foam roller about 12" long and 1" in diameter was something like $22. I was told a lot of the price was simply for stocking all the spare parts.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#11

Inventory

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is always a serious portion of costs, and parts can be viewed as "non-performing" or dead assets. The whole "just-in-time" idea was to reduce that cost. But customer service is a major sales driver, so soaking a homeowner on a $2 item is just not good policy. This happens when bean counters control the sales department.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#12

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Yep, replacement parts are high, some of this is justified, some is not. Prior to my retirement I worked for a manufacturing company that produced a lot of OEM automotive controls and switches. Typical markup (when purchased at a dealer or auto parts store) was at least 1000% - 10 times the wholesale price to the Automobile manufacture. However they did pack the part in a cardboard box :>).

As I said some of this is justified as the dealers have several $1000 in inventory for many years and probably end up selling well over half of their spare part inventory way below their cost after it became obsolete.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#13

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

Barry Irby

I just had what might be the opposite experience. I loaned my son a dress belt. (Then kind that holds up your pants, not powers a saw blade.) He brings it back with a screw missing. Who knew a belt had screws? Two tiny set screws, one gone. About an 1/8" in diameter and a 1/4" long with a slot. No idea what the threads were. Walked into Fastenal with a sheepish grin and asked for help. It was a slow day and the guy spent a long time rummaging around, opening packages, testing one after another. Finally found one that woudl work, then spent a while finding the tool to tighten it with. It was a No. 4 set screw. Easy enough if you knew that, but I didn't. I tried to pay him, but he gave it to me. I know the set screw was probably worth about a nickel, maybe a dime, but I woudl have happily paid five bucks for the effort. Might not have been offended at ten bucks. I don't buy a lot of stuff from Fastenal, but I will buy more.

I have been on your side of this more than once.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#14

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

You could probably find a replacement switch on Amazon or Ebay for a couple bucks.

If you have an appliance parts/repair place near you, they'd likely have a usable switch, too - and for a lot less than the price you were quoted.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#15

Have Victim

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

switch in the car in case I happen to see such a place in travels :D

Have replaced the unit with a different brand, so no "need it now" pressure. If it gets fixed, it'll suit as a spare. For now, it can gather dust in that special corner of the shop for a while.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#16

Re: What is your time...

TomD

"The cost of shipping helps pay that overhead."

That isn't helping me feel better about it. I think in many cases high shipping comes down to poor sourcing at the senders and, and having good information about what their shipping costs. The prior is amateur hour, and the latter is good cost accounting. But just padding out your price doesn't impress me.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#17

Re: Lucky to get them at all

TomD

Yeah, I imagine when they went offshore they just figured beep-it. As it turns out the local place that does the same deal as Grizzly but in Canada, is really good about providing parts. So maybe buying a little closer to the producer helps.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#18

Re: Less than a deal

TomD

Did we hear what the shipping on the main part will cost? Heck, I can now buy motors direct from China free shipping, same price as the US price. I don't know how the US keeps up.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#19

Re: Walking the talk

TomD

I think part of the problem is that a lot of us still have ideas based what is good or bad for business from a time when repeat business was still a factor, when in reality there is virtually no chance we will buy from the same supplier again. I wonder who the brands are I seriously intend to buy from again in 5 years. I think I will give Ford a chance, LV, Paul components. I am sure there are others, but right off the top of my head, not many. Now over the next year, there are a lot of guys on ebay, I might hit up again, but they probably won't be around in a few more years.

In fact, some of the companies I have the greatest loyalty to are dead and gone and I am picking up second hand.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#20

"I don't know how the US keeps up"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It doesn't, but we're really great at complaining about it.

quoted shipping was 6.95 on a part weighing 3/4oz.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#21

Why should the printer companies have all the fun?

John in NM

Only a matter of time before other industries figured out the "sell product cheap and charge out the wazoo for consumables" model.... of course I wouldn't call that switch a consumable, but that is probably why I'm relatively poor :D

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#22

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

Brian Holcombe

They're likely pricing it to encourage you to replace the pump. The line of thinking for a typical customer may be along the lines of 'other parts are getting worn, I'll simply replace the pump rather than risk replacing parts that cost so much'.

I am probably guilty of that exact line of reasoning, I replaced my condensate pump last year without even a seconds worth of diagnostics. The pump was a POS and so it was nice to get a much better unit.

Re: OT Rant - Parts Dept.

#23

You only need one corner (?)

Chuck Nickerson

of your garage to hold the "someday" projects? You're a better man than I.