Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Poly over shellac

Posts

Poly over shellac

#1

Poly over shellac

james runchey

I'm in the process of finishing a new walnut end table. I brushed on two coats of orange shellac and now the wife tells me she wants poly on the top for greater water resistance. I understand that the shellac has wax in it and poly won't adhere properly. Would a coat of dewaxed white shellac seal out the wax?

Re: Poly over shellac

#2

Re: Poly over shellac

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Test adhesion. It may do fine.

Coat shellac on test piece. scuff sand at 360 or 400. Coat with varnish. Cure several days. With a sharp blade make cross hatching pattern about 1/8" apart. Apply tape and peel. Look to see how many squares lift.

Re: Poly over shellac

#3

Somewhat

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

but the 100% burn-in quality of shellac will likely pull some wax to the surface and give you adhesion issues in spots. If possible, the new shellac should be applied by spraying several thin layers that will dry fast without much chance of substantially redissolving the base film. Do NOT hand apply or "work" the surface mechanically which will tend to pull the wax content to the top. Unless impractical, I'd give the top an alcohol bath to remove as much of the waxy finish as possible, then reseal with dewaxed shellac, followed by the top coat of her choice.

Just a note, while poly is a much more durable surface than shellac, shellac is just as water resistant as poly, if not more so, and is simplicity itself to repair down the road. For a table surface, the poly has the advantage of being resistant to cleaning chemicals, especially ammoniated cleaners such as Windex, that will attack a shellac film.

Re: Poly over shellac

#4

Re: Poly over shellac

Pete in Holland MI

My can of Zinsser amber shellac recommends not to overcoat with poly. You would need to use shellac sanding sealer, which is de-waxed.

Re: Poly over shellac

#5

disagree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"shellac is just as water resistant as poly, if not more so,"

Put a drop of water on your shellac finish and see what happens after a while. Nothing will happen if you let water stand on a urethane varnish for hours or maybe days. But that is not the main event for dining table. Here abrasion and heat are the main worries and maybe alcohol, but not in our house. Urethane varnish will pass the stringent assaults of the kitchen cabinetry testing. There is no finish that will stand up to the food, heat, solvents, abrasion, cleaning etc than the most durable urethane varnishes. Nothing beats it for a table top.

Apply it thinned so it flows out. In the end let it cure, then rub out to whatever gloss pleases you. The result Is a glass smooth surface.

Re: Poly over shellac

#6

Re: Poly over shellac

Dick Coers

Good advice so far. Shellac is easy to strip off, just cover with denatured alcohol, let it sit a minute or two, then wipe it off.

Re: Poly over shellac

#7

Re: disagreement

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

a. He's talking about an end table, not kitchen cabinets.

b. I've had (2-coat) oil poly fail on window trim as the result of condensation where dewaxed shellac (2-coat/3lb) did just fine. The poly became much harder, but then seemed to split with wood expansion and turned cloudy where the softer shellac appears to have more "give". Poly was a real pain to get off completely so that I could refinish the sill.

c. On a heavy-use surface like a dining table, I would not advocate shellac as a final finish. As I've shown here before, two applications of dewaxed shellac as sanding sealer and base coat, covered by 3 coats of waterborne poly is my go-to finish in that situation. My son's QSWO table done so is holding up very well after the past year and a half despite the daily assaults of a couple of 1 and 3 yr. olds.

PS: Rub out a dining table to high gloss if you like but don't complain when most anything that touches it leaves a scratch or mark of some sort.

Re: Poly over shellac

#8

Clint Searl

Strip it

Clint Searl

Strip it completely and finish with poly alone. It's self "sealing."

Re: Poly over shellac

#9

Re: Strip it

jcousins

i agree to strip it -

but i often use a 1# cut of de-waxed shellac as a sealer coat (maybe 2 applications) under a final poly finish. it helps in not raising the grain as much when putting on the poly.

jerry

Re: Poly over shellac

#10

Re: disagree

TomD

It can be great, but it isn't always the look people want. There are other finishes that are fine on tables. I use maloof finish, and watco, with no problem. There is even a Marine watco. Durability of finish is partly a cultural thing, can you train people to respect a finish, or should one need to.

On Shelac, it can be made more durable. Apparently you can add a small amount of drying oil, and it will significantly improve durability, but not to poly levels. I think drying walnut oil has been mentioned.

Re: Poly over shellac

#11

Re: disagree

TomD

By durability in this case I really meant water resistance.

Re: Poly over shellac

#12

Re: Poly over shellac

james runchey

Since this is an end table which will have very little use, I've decided to just stick with the shellac and repair/refinish if the need arises. Thanks for all your replies.

Re: Poly over shellac

#14

Re: Poly over shellac

fredhargis

There is an easier solution: top coat with an alkyd resin varnish instead of a urethane formula. The problem with adhesion between urethane and waxy shellac is due to the urethane resins, they inhibit adhesion; that's why scuff sanding between coats is usually recommended. But with an alkyd resin formula you don't have to worry. the downside is they are getting harder to find since we woodworkers have been brainwashed into thinking "poly" is the finish of choice. The 2 that may be the easiest find are Pratt and Lambert 38 (MY favorite) and SW Fast Dry Oil Varnish. The P&L is a soya oil/ alkyd formula and has a very light color (not as much amber) nor does it yellow over time as much. The SW is a linseed oil/alkyd formula. Both are top notch, durable products. They also have (to my eyes) a nicer look than urathane varnishes. (Just my opinion.) At least around me, the P&L is almost impossible to find, but the Sherwin Williams product is easily obtained.

Re: Poly over shellac

#15

Kent B

It ain't that hard...

Kent B

Sorry - late to the party.

In the future, buy dewaxed orange flakes.

For now - get the Zinnser Seal Coat - a 2# cut of extra pale dewaxed. Turn it into a 1# cut. Put a couple light coats as a sealer on top of the waxy orange, and you are good to go with the poly. The seal coats won't change the color.

FWIW - I only have dewaxed shellac, because I never know what I might use it for. Waxy has its place, but I never really get into those situations. The downside - gotta buy flakes in many cases, which I actually prefer - shelf life in a fridge or freezer is a very, very long time - I haven't hit it yet, and my garnet is 6 - 7 years old.

Re: Poly over shellac

#16

A Heads Up

Hank Knight

Seal Coat has a pretty long shelf life. I have some that's still good after over 2 years. Here's the heads up: the shellac outlasts the can. Something in the shellac works on the solder joints in the metal can and causes them to leak after a while. After cleaning up a couple of messes, I've started decanting my Seal Coat into a glass jar, preferably a dark colored one, and adding glass marbles to bring the liquid level near the top of the jar. Stored on a cool, dark shelf this way, Seal Coat lasts a long time.

Re: Poly over shellac

#17

Question

John Pappas

Why do you feel the need to fill the jar with marbles? Shellac is not going to be affected by oxygen in the jar the way that varnish/poly are. Or is there something here that I don't know about?

Re: Poly over shellac

#18

Re: Question

Hank Knight

Hi, John. I think it's something I don't know about. The marbles are a hangover from the way I store other finishes. May not be neccessary with shellac. The glass jar works well, though.

Re: Poly over shellac

#19

Not just Seal Coat......

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I've had the same thing happen with old cans of Zinsser BIN. Not sure what it is, but the shellac in both products can cause the can to leak after prolonged storage.

Re: Poly over shellac

#20

Re: Rusty Cans

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Premixed Shellac is dissolved in (mostly) ethanol. Ethanol of the grade used has a certain amount of water in its structure, and it is hydroscopic (attracts water vapor out of the air) so as time goes on, that shellac mixed in the steel can will tend to cause the can's bottom seals to corrode because the water, being heavier than ethanol and not compatible with the shellac resin, will sink to the bottom of the can. Decanting into glass will stop the leaks although a metal cap on the jar will degrade after a while.

You can slow down the esterification (process that degrades the shellac resin) if you keep it in the fridge. I keep my mixed shellac in the fridge next to my C-A glue which has held up for 4 years now with no loss of effectiveness. I mix shellac for use but never keep the leftover longer than 6 months if it will be used under a waterborne finish.

Re: Poly over shellac

#21

Keeping Your Martini DRY

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

While I've not tried it with mixed shellac, there is a way to drastically reduce the amount of water in the DNA we use to mix it.

Most all ethanol contains between 6 and 12% water when it's first distilled. Ethanol plants that supply ethanol for fuel use molecular filters to remove enough water to meet specs for fuel grade.

The stuff we buy at the paint store is of a lesser grade and has a higher amount of water in the mix. In 2011 a prof at a mid-west university discovered that pearled tapioca (the pudding mix) not only does a great job of soaking the water out of the alcohol, but also can be reused by straining it out of the "dried" alcohol and then spreading the pearls out to dry for later reuse.

If you've ever noticed that your first coat of shellac may tend to pucker or raise the grain on raw wood, what you're seeing is the effect of your shellac's water content.

What really "dry" shellac? Put some tapioca pearls in a jar and add 20% more DNA than you plan to use. Cap and let it sit for a day, gently shaken (not stirred) once in a while. When you're ready to mix, pour the alcohol/tapioca into a fine sieve. Use the liquid to mix your shellac. Lastly, run your dissolved shellac through a coffee filter before use. You will be pleased at the crystal clarity of the shellac you get.

Re: Poly over shellac

#22

Re: Keeping Your Martini DRY

Barry Irby

And the tapioca is delicious. A little milk, a little agave, a little residual ethanol, now you got yourself a pudding.

Re: Poly over shellac

#23

Ahhh . .Nah

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Dry methanol will waste you in that form as well.

Just for grins, maybe someone could try the tapioca thing on some SeatCoat to see if it will take out water without also taking up the resin.