Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Turpentine Odor

Posts

Turpentine Odor

#1

Turpentine Odor

Matt W

I used the "homebrew" mixture recommended here on WoodCentral by Russ Fairfield: http://www.woodcentral.com/russ/finish7.shtml. I used it on a duck call turned from maple burl. I soaked the call in the mixture for 24 hours and then after wiping off the excess, hung it to dry. The call has been hanging now for about 2 months and yet the odor of turpentine remains to the point that one doesn't want to put the call to ones mouth to blow it.

Has anyone else had this issue and if so, any suggestions on how to remedy it? Thanks much in advance. By the way, in case anyone is wondering, I love the look that this finish produced and really want to continue using it if I can figure out the turpentine odor issue.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#2

Re: Turpentine Odor

Howard Acheson

If you want to use turpentine, you will have to put up with the odor. Turpentine has a very strong, long lasting odor.

You would be much better off to use mineral spirits as your thinner. It has less odor and the odor should be mostly gone within a couple of weeks. As a thinner mineral spirits is as good as turpentine.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#3

Re: Turpentine Odor

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Take a deep breath as it might help your cough. Pure gum turps is not a poison, in fact, turpentine preparations (turpenhydrate) has been used as cough remedy for several centuries.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#5

agree again...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...just get over the aversion to the smell. Personally, I like the odor. Imagine you are blowing on a pine knot.

Turpentine is so old school. There was a time before petroleum refining that it was all we had for a hydrocarbon solvent. But the only difference in hydrocarbon solvents is their boiling point and cost. Now days if you want a rapid evaporating solvent use naptha, Less volatile use mineral spirits. If cost is no object use turpentine.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#6

Agree on all points....

John in NM

Especially liking the odor of turp :D

Re: Turpentine Odor

#7

Re: Turpentine Odor

R. Payne

Turpentine contains lots of toxic components. If you can still smell it, keep it in a well ventilated place and use protective gear around it.

Just because something has been used in the past as medicine doesn't mean it is safe to be exposed to, at one time radium water was thought to be good to drink, until people's jaws started falling off.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#8

Re: Turpentine Odor

fredhargis

I use a turpentine mixture on my workbench surfaces, and find the odor goes away after 3-4 days. I'm wondering if you exposed it to moving air for a day or two if that would help. Someone else suggested replacing the turp with MS; that's what I intend to do when I mix my next batch.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#9

Re: Turpentine Odor

Matt W

Good suggestions on here, thanks guys. I intentionally used the turpentine instead of the mineral spirits because the turpentine becomes past of the finish whereas the mineral spirits evaporates out. I guess the odor becomes part of the finish also... Perhaps I'll try the mineral spirits next time and see what happens.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Turpentine Odor

Jesper, Denmark

Matt, I also favor the real turpentine, as it is a better solvent than most of the synthetics from coal or oil. You can accelerate the odor removal by putting the item somewhere warm for a few days.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#11

Re: Turpentine Odor

Matt W

Thanks Jesper, I'll give that a try. I too much prefer the turpentine and agree that it's the preferred choice. Thanks again.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#12

Re: Turpentine Odor

John in NM

I've had cans of turp that were really pungent, and the smell lasts and lasts.... others were nice and piney and didn't really hang around long. Won't do you much good at this point (though Jesper's suggestion will), but it might be worth trying a different can for next time.

Best turp I've got is a can of Standard Brands from about 1960 or so that was left unopened in the garage of a house my parents bought. Stuff is wonderfully clean with a very light pine-ish odor.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#13

Baloney

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"because the turpentine becomes past(part) of the finish "

Unlikely and if it did so what. What desirable property could it impart beyond softening the resin that is the varnish part?

Companies spend great effort to make a varnish with desirable properties. Then someone decides to dilute the varnish with stuff, and because they invented the new mixture it must be better.

I would think that a good spar varnish would be as good as it gets for a duck call finish. Or, if it doesn't stay wet go the gun stock route and finish with linseed or Tung oil....many coats until it stops absorbing any more. I can't think of anything useful the additional solvent does in either case.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#14

Re: Baloney

Matt W

When I indicated that the turpentine becomes part of the finish, I'm simply quoting what Mr. Fairfield indicated in his finishing secrets article posted here on WoodCentral and to which I provided a link to in my first post on this topic. I have no solid basis to claim that it does or does not become part of the finish, although from the one time that I tried it, the result is impressive; except for the odor. I've used spar thinned with mineral spirits in the past and the end result was not as nice as with the turpentine. This leads me to believe that the oils or whatever it is in turpentine, does in fact become part of the finish, but don't take my word for it, try it. As for me, I'll keep experimenting with the turpentine.

Thanks for all the good advice on here. I'll see how it turns out.

Re: Turpentine Odor

#15

the chemistry is amiss

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I read the reference you provided. I did not know Russ nor his background. I can say that there is little about the chemistry described that is accurate. However, that doesn't matter in the end. If the finish he proposes works for your application that is all that is important.

For what it is worth, I make my own wax from Carnauba and solvent. I had always used xylene for the solvent. Someone told me to use turpentine because it was better. Wrong! I waxed some drawers in a chest of drawers with it and it smelled of turpentine months later. It took nearly that long for the wax to dry, the result being sticky drawers, not smoothly sliding ones. Hence, I am not surprised that the proposed wipe on varnish smells for a while.

All these home brew finishes are trying to achieve the goal of easy application. And their inventors all believe that they can come up with a formula better than the finishing companies. I remain skeptical that any of these home made mixes of oil, solvent and varnish perform better than a commercial wipe on like Waterlox, or the General finishes product or the Minwax product. They will by their nature be less abrasion resistant (softer). (Fine woodworking had a recent report on varnishes comparing all the important properties. )

The commercial wipe ons are not simply varnish diluted with oil to make them flow easier. They are in fact formulated from low viscosity resins, which flow easily, and then crosslink to a durable film. The result is a more durable film than a simple mix or oil and varnish.