the chemistry is amiss
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I read the reference you provided. I did not know Russ nor his background. I can say that there is little about the chemistry described that is accurate. However, that doesn't matter in the end. If the finish he proposes works for your application that is all that is important.
For what it is worth, I make my own wax from Carnauba and solvent. I had always used xylene for the solvent. Someone told me to use turpentine because it was better. Wrong! I waxed some drawers in a chest of drawers with it and it smelled of turpentine months later. It took nearly that long for the wax to dry, the result being sticky drawers, not smoothly sliding ones. Hence, I am not surprised that the proposed wipe on varnish smells for a while.
All these home brew finishes are trying to achieve the goal of easy application. And their inventors all believe that they can come up with a formula better than the finishing companies. I remain skeptical that any of these home made mixes of oil, solvent and varnish perform better than a commercial wipe on like Waterlox, or the General finishes product or the Minwax product. They will by their nature be less abrasion resistant (softer). (Fine woodworking had a recent report on varnishes comparing all the important properties. )
The commercial wipe ons are not simply varnish diluted with oil to make them flow easier. They are in fact formulated from low viscosity resins, which flow easily, and then crosslink to a durable film. The result is a more durable film than a simple mix or oil and varnish.