Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Urban logging

Posts

Re: Urban logging

#2

Awesome!

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

And I don't mean "awesome" the way a teenager says it. I mean it in the true sense of the word. Climbing the tree is scary enough, but working a chainsaw up there is terrifying! Fascinating to watch them work.

Re: Urban logging

#4

What do you think about their prices?

Gary Smyth

Urban hardwoods.com Visited their site to look at their furniture using reclaimed wood similar to what is shown on the video. I'm not familiar with custom furniture prices but jeez. For sure they have real investment in securing the the wood, but for the style and their price I'd like to read other opinions as to realistic value. Example:

$6900 + 1850 for base

Re: Urban logging

#5

Re: What do you think about their prices?

Dick Coers

That looks like a two board top. $7000 for a finished two board slab seems very high to me.

Re: Urban logging

#6

Their Market

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is for people who either don't know any better or have enough money that it tends to loose it's meaning vis-a-vis real "value"

Re: Urban logging

#7

You're missing the

mdclor

point. This is the price for bragging rights. This table was made from the biggest, tallest....... and now it resides in MY trophy room. :D

Re: Urban logging

#8

Re: Awesome!

Tom Dunlap

I remember the first crane removal I did.

There is no way to explain the feeling of seeing a butt cut go UP when I finished the cut! Up until that moment all trunks fell DOWN! Pretty weird feeling.

More and more arborists are using cranes and knucklebooms for urban trees.

Unfortunately, a few are using them with no understanding of the crane lift charts. This leads to tipped cranes and property damage or loss of life.

Re: Urban logging

#9

I rode the ball…

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

Of the dozens of tower projects I worked on in the '70s, '80s, and '90s, three of them involved a crane—same guy each time. As I started climbing the tower he'd ask, “want to ride the ball?”. Each time I'd decline.

Finally on the last one—the tower was 90'—I relented. I climbed on and by the time we got about 15' in the air I knew I'd made a mistake. No argument, it was totally worth it. We were on a significant hill about 45 miles west of the Loop, it was a Fall morning with as much color as Northern Illinois can put together, and the view toward the city was magnificent.

The crane operator was really good, and he spotted me right at the 90' level where I needed to be in such a way that I literally stepped off, onto the tower. By the time I got myself situated where I needed to be and belted in, he had dropped the ball, ground crew had hooked on the antenna, and when I turned to signal I was ready for it, and everyone pointed behind me. It was right there, just above my head, ready for attachment.

Mock me if you will, but I can totally relate to this project, including the cutting. I've never cut that high, but I have plenty of chainsaw experience, including falling good sized wood, so it's not hard to identify with it.

Rod

Re: Urban logging

#10

I'm reminded....

John in NM

Of my HS art teacher. While showing slides of some famous post modern finger painter, one of the kids says "man, I could have done that!" And the teacher replied "Yes, but you didn't".

Though the price seems high, only those making similar things and selling them successfully are in a position to judge whether the prices are too high. Not being one of those making and selling furniture, I do agree that its pretty steep. When I was working for a custom shop, I would estimate that about half the cost was in marketing - showroom, sales time, design time, etc.

Re: Urban logging

#11

Clint Searl

Re: What do you think about their prices?

Clint Searl

Prices aside, I take issue with their designs, namely the bases, which are void of aesthetic content, IMO. The beautiful slabs making up the tops deserve more than some bent steel flats to rest on. For what is offered, the prices are exorbitant

Re: Urban logging

#12

One of my favorite places in

Rich Pearson in Mill Creek, WA

Seattle to visit. Fortunately my wife's hair salon is in downtown so I get about 2 hours of browsing once every 6-8 weeks at Urban Hardwoods and at the Northwest Woodworkers Gallery about 3 doors down the block.

The slabs they have reclaimed are beautiful, truly works of art in their own right.The tables are pricy, but they have found their market niche and many high tech boardrooms and conference rooms in the area have been enhanced.

When in Seattle, these are 2 "do not miss" stops for wood workers.

Bibs are required so the drool doesn't mess with the art work! (LOL!)

Re: Urban logging

#13

Re: I rode the ball…

Bill White

The Charlie Daniels of the chain saw. The crane operator ain't no slouch either.

I got a nose bleed just watchin'.

Bill

Re: Urban logging

#14

Ellis Walentine

Not realistic

Ellis Walentine

I'm a firm believer in "what the market will bear," as opposed to a more calculated value. I don't know their overhead, but that price can't reflect fair value. The market will sort them out quickly. And the piece is unattractive to boot.

Ellis

Re: Urban logging

#15

Re: Not realistic

Barry Irby

I agree with Ellis. The whole time I watched the video I was wondering what they were going to do with the wood. I was hoping it was not going to the dump or chipper. I was glad to see they were sawing it and using it, but that table did not do it justice.

There is/was a cypress tree about 20 miles from here that was supposedly 1200 years old. (Big Mama) It died. They decided to leave it there and let it rot. Return to nature. Really? That's the best you could think of? Couldn't somebody saw it and use the wood for something more worthwhile?