Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Steel City bandsaw switch

Posts

Steel City bandsaw switch

#1

Steel City bandsaw switch

Johanna Johanson

My bandsaw suddenly quit - I think it is the switch since it ran just fine then a few minutes later when I tried to turn it back on it would not start.

I found various paddle switches online that are for a 2hp 230 volt application. I think the Woodstock D4159 looks pretty much the same as the existing switch. Can anyone tell me if that is the correct replacement?

Here are the specs printed on the switch:

KJD17B IP55

18A(AC-1)/15A(AC-3)

Ue=250V~5E4

Uc=220-240V~

16(12A)250V~5E4

2HP 220-240V~

16A 22-0240V~

There is a simple wiring diagram showing the 4 connectors - 2 IN marked 13 and 23, and 2 Out marked 14 and 24.

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#2

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

John K Jordan

Did you test the switch? I would hate to buy a switch without being sure the switch is the problem. If you have a meter you can use the ohm (or continuity) setting to check for continuity between both sides of the switch after disconnecting it from the circuit. (Be sure to check all connections first - with the power off - to see if anything has come loose. I also wiggle them with the power on but am careful not to die.)

220v switches (and often 110v) are usually DPST (double throw single pole) where the connectors down one side make and break one side of the circuit, same for the other side. You can use a DPDT switch with six terminals as a replacement and just ignore extra two. If you are getting good continuity on both sides when flipping the switch the problem might be elsewhere.

If the switch is bad, it might be possible to fix it. I repaired two from lathes, one just a week or so ago. In both of these cases fine sawdust had worked its way inside and kept the contacts from closing properly. On the latest, the girl had just been using the lathe, turned it off, then it wouldn't turn on.

For both of these, I simply removed the switches, disassembled, cleaned them out, lubed as necessary, and reassembled. Most of this type of switch snaps together and can be taken apart easily once you figure out how. (If the switch is put together with rivets I have to be pretty desperate before I work on it.)

As I wrote elsewhere, the biggest problem is keeping up with how the parts go inside and to keep from dropping small ball bearings or springs into the shavings on the shop floor!

Once I fix a switch like this I like to seal it better with something like plastic, tape, etc to keep out future sawdust.

A switch can also fail is ways that it cannot easily be repaired, for example when a part breaks or if the contacts are burned. If the latter, I would want to investigate further and possibly use a replacement switch with a higher rating. Note that you can ALWAYS use a switch that is rated higher. Also, I prefer to look at the amperage rating instead of HP since some HP ratings are bogus.

When a switch failed on one of my drill presses, I took it to a local electric motor repair shop and found one that was close. It was a different size but I made a little plate to fit out of plastic.

JKJ

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#3

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

Johanna Johanson

Thanks, John. I don't have electrical test equipment because I am really nervous about messing with electricity!

A new switch is less than $20. I'm pretty sure it is the switch - there is no resistance when I press the "On" button. From what I have seen around the web, that indicates that the switch is bad. It is a sealed unit, so I cannot open it.

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#4

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

Jerry Roberts

I agree with John. I had a somewhat similar problem with my unisaw a few years ago. I just knew something was seriously wrong when it failed to start. Checked everything I could think of then blew out the motor, switch and everything I could see with my air compressor. It fixed it. Not saying your problem is the same but Id check the simple things first. Good luck.

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#5

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

john lucas

Check an interlocks. Im not familiar with the Steel City but many bigger bandsaws have interlock switches on the Brake and the doors. If anyone of them doesn't close you have an open circuit to the switch. Ideally find someone who knows how to use a multimeter they can check these. If not just open and close the doors several times. Same with the Brake if it has one. Sometimes you can short across the switches if you can find them. If all of them are working then it quite probably could be the switch.

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#6

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

Mike Farinella

Why not call Steel City?

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#7

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

Johanna Johanson

Steel City is no longer in business - sadly.

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#8

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

Johanna Johanson

Thanks, I'll try opening and closing doors and using the brake.

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#9

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

Walt

"I'm pretty sure it is the switch - there is no resistance when I press the "On" button."

That does sound like something mechanical broke in the switch. If you or someone you know were more comfortable around sparky things you could jumper the wires going to and from the switch. Unplug first, of course. If the saw runs when the cord is plugged in, it proves conclusively that the switch is the problem.

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#10

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

Johanna Johanson

Yep - my electrician came by and confirmed it is the switch. Now I just have to be sure I order a replacement switch that will fit the opening. . .

I love my electrician - he did not charge me at all for checking out that switch - and he spent at least 20 minutes checking it out!

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#11

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

Walt

You might look at Grizzly's switches.

http://www.grizzly.com/catalog/2015/main/?p=287.

I wouldn't be surprised if Steel City and Grizzly had some parts in common.

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

#12

Re: Steel City bandsaw switch

Johanna

I found exactly the right switch on Amazon. When I emailed Steel City, I eventually got an answer from a person with Nordis - they wanted $25 dollars for it. The one I got from Amazon cost $14.83!

If anyone else needs a switch for the 18" Steel City bandsaw, the one from Amazon is Woodstock D4159.