Those things have always annoyed the heck out of me. But then, I have always lived in mid-20's bungalows with lath + plaster, and only Superman could see clearly through that stuff. Stud finder performance was laughable.
Now - a condo with plain-ol' sheetrock. Gotta do some closet rods, etc - nothing out in plain view, so I am not opposed to the "drill-move 1/2"-drill-move 1/2" " method to locate the studs. That's how I did it behind kitchen cabinets in the bungalow. They ever take those down and look at the wall, they will think I was drunk. Not that they would necessarily be wrong, but still............
At the same time, I'd give it a shot again, if there is an inexpensive Big Box / A'zon Prime model that works - I will consider it a one-time disposable tool, so keep that in mind with your suggestions, please.
Then slide them around on the wall until they stick on a nail or screw. WAY BETTER than a stud finder. When I saw the tip in Fine Homebuilding, the guy used a piece of string and taped it to the magnet so it would swing on the wall. You don't need expensive big magnets, I use some 3/8 diameter from Harbor Freight.
I'm with Dick on this. They make a little gadget that is like a compass. Little plastic case with a magnet inside that is free to swivel. That worked well enough, but the magnet on a string is as good or better. I have an ancient electronic one and it works but not all that well. Recently I decided to buy a new one thinking the technology must have improved in thirty years. I read the reviews on Amazon and they were so bad I decided to save the money.
Remember where drywallers put the nails. At the center seam about four feet off the floor, Assuming your local guys run the drywall horizontally. And then on about every other stud half way to the ceiling and floor. Another place to look is along the upper face of the base board. In fact, if you look hard you might be able to see the dimples for the nails on the base board.
Kent, you should take a look at Franklin Professional Stud finder,it is the most accurate stud finder I have ever used, very easy to use, just place it on wall and it shows where the studs are located, there's no sliding necessary.it shows the full thickness of the studs .
Last week, I watched a couple of steel fabricators trying to locate a stud with a digital finder. After they had drilled about 5 holes in a finished wall, I offered to help. I have several finders, but I don't find any of them to be any better, or as good as my ear. I found a stud on the first try.?
Several things help. A big framing hammer is bad, even a standard 16 oz is a bit heavy, so start with a 12 oz or less. If you don't have a small hammer, holding a screwdriver by the blade, tapping with handle works good.
I like to hold s sheet of paper against the wall, pushing it firmly, while doing light quick taps. You can't assume that the drywall is always drawn firmly up against the stud, so pushing it against it assures that it is, whether a fastener is near or not. The paper keeps the hammer from leaving marks, and the lighter object gets it to resonate in a range easy for the ear to pick up. If you are pushing against the wall, while traversing with quick light taps, it will sound more solid when you are over a stud.
Of course, understanding how framers typically lay out a wall helps to guess where it might be to begin with. If it is just a short wall, Teeing off a longer wall, the stud will probably be about 15.5"out of the corner from the drywall, or 16" from the plate line.
I wouldn't be able to feel the edge of the stud versus the center. Hats off to you if you can tell the difference! I was always a nervous wreck when I went into someone else's house and tried to find studs. First I worried about a row of little holes in their wall, second I worried about my work falling off the wall if I caught just the edge of a stud. I guess that's why I had a million dollar liability policy. Well that and commercial installation insisted!
You don't need to find the edge with your hammer, just a point where you're pretty sure there's a stud. Then, drive a finish nail in and if you're on the stud, use the same hole and angle it in both sideways directions to establish where the edge of the stud is.
I should add that this works pretty well on drywall, not so much on plastered walls.
I use stud finders they work fine. Most problems come from zeroing over a stud or other area of build up then moving over the wall and they don't work properly because you are searching for density having zeroed for max density to start with. So with that kind of finder, try setting to a few different spots on the wall.
The magnet trick is obviously not new. That is what stud finders used to be. They were a little compass like thing that had a pointer in them. Probably a compass would work... I store my rare earths on the walls, saves of destroyed cards and media. Keeps them away from kids.
If you use the magnet trick you are finding screws/nails not studs. If all was well, you should have the seam dead centered over the stud, and the fasteners just a little to each side of center, so you need to visualize that orientation for best results.
Of course if you are finding for a door frame, or such, you can just find any inboard area, and cut out until you find the stud.
If you sight down a wall, you should be able to spot the muds on the main seams as high points of the general waviness that is a drywall job. Of course if they hung 20 foot sheets horizontally that may not work.
Remember that studs are not the only things you will find in a wall, there may also be electrical, plumbing, etc... The better stud finders spot these also. Magnets won't find that stuff. Not sure how one finds pex.
If you take the coverplate off a receptacle, and the box it's in is not a remodel box, the stud is on one side or the other. All you have to do is probe between the box and the drywall with a thin blade. Personally, I just knock on the wall with my knuckle on either side of the box. The sound will be a little higher pitched over the stud and sound more hollow between studs.
You can also look down the wall, looking for changes in the texture between the drywall mud and paper, or look for nail/screw pops or slight indentations where they were underfilled.
I haven't used a stud finder in years (never had a good battery when I went to use them), but even the $30 jobs worked fine, especially on drywall. For plaster, I had one with a "Deep Scan Mode" that worked well enough.