Doing a little remodeling at the river house and when we opened up the walls and ceiling in a powder room, we uncovered a boo-boo from the past with a nail gun. I have no idea how long ago this occurred, and am not even sure it pierced the pipe all the way in. It's never leaked so far, but my gut tells me Murphy's law is hiding around the corner. Replacing the fitting is not an option due to the location. I'm wondering if I pull the nail, is there any permanent way to seal that hole? Epoxy perhaps? Anybody ever deal with something similar?
since this drain has no pressure, there are several options. Epoxy as you suggested, silicon sealant, or pressure self adhesion tape (Gorilla is one brand).
1. leave it as is unless it leaks; it'll be self sealed until the rail rusts out in 4-5 more decades
2. Since this is not a pressurized drain, pull the nail, rough up and clean the surface, and fill the hole with 100% silicone caulk leaving a "mushroom cap" on the outside.
3. Cut out both the L and the Y and remake the entire assembly counting on adding 1 or 2 slip couplings and (perhaps) a Fernco.
I'd go for a stainless steel sheet metal screw but I'd avoid one that is excessively long to eliminate the chance of stuff hanging up on the protrusion inside. The screw should be thick enough to deform the plastic just a bit to ensure a good seal but not so thick as to cause excessive stress. A gob of silicone over the screw head certainly couldn't hurt.
Lots of good suggestions here, but this would be my first choice. Only caveat I would suggest is a short stainless steel screw. Probably wouldn't matter since it's in the vertical part of the drain, but I don't like introducing anything for "media" to snag upon.
I have this stuff for irrigation pipe and have occasion to put screws in it. The screw must go in easily. If not the plastic will crack. If you feel you are forcing the screw then drill a larger pilot hole.
Any Idea how long its been there? Since no rusty drool has appeared on the surface, I suspect it has not penetrated the inner surface. You could just leave it alone and I certainly would if it were in a location I could inspect once or twice a year.
Do you recognize the nail or actually know how long it is?
Many years ago when I was building one of my guys drilling into a stack with a large spade bit. Just the pilot or tip of the bit hit the pipe. It was ABS pipe. The plumber dabbed it with the glue and pronounced it good.
In your case I woudl tug gently on the nail and pull it out if it cam out easily. If not, I might cut it off flush with the surface and cover it with PVC glue. If it came out I would dab the hole with PVC glue or put a little plug as others have suggested.
And, If I wanted to be sure and never worry about it again I would cut up a Fernco Or No-Hub fitting and put a Band-aid over the boo-boo.
A friend had some oddball Ferco style couplings until yesterday that may have been perfect to cannibalize. They were for attaching something like cement pipe to cast iron. He got a case of them at a freight auction. They did not sell so he saved the stainless part for scrap and tossed the rubber. The rubber had an off set in it that may have been perfect for you. If you contact me today, I may be able to rescue one of them and send it to you, but they may be in the trash.
Had a similar problem with both hot and cold water lines (PEX) during a gut rehab of the plumbing in my father-in-law's vacation home. My son and brother-in-law did the bulk of the work and we're not sure who nailed the paneling back up and thought a stud was there. Got both lines twice and since they were pressurized, they leaked. Pulled the paneling, cut the sections out and replaced them. PEX does make it easier than copper.
I would avoid using any calking or adhesive except PVC / CPVC cement. I have successfully made a "paste" using shavings (PVC sawdust) dissolved in PVC cement before, to fill large gaps in PVC piping. Make your paste then apply a coat of PVC cement in the hole and pack it with the paste. It will dissolve and become part of the pipe ~ making a permanent fix that will actually hold pressure (which is more than you need).
(I was a licensed / bonded Indiana Contractor Plumber for a few years).
If you want to use epoxy, either prime it first with the primer and cement that goes with this pipe. Or lightly haze it with a propane torch (dull the natural color do not burn), either will improve the bond that epoxy makes to the pipe by a substantial margin, the cement is more effective. I normally haze it with a torch since any plumbing pipe cement I keep around is invariably dried up by the time I try to use it again. Once you do that, you can apply epoxy to the pipe and if you have any fiberglass or denim, you can use that to.