Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Sand paper for sharpening metal question

Posts

Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#1

Sand paper for sharpening metal question

Barry Irby

I posted a few weeks ago about making friends with my hand plane. Concluded it needs to be sharp, really sharp. Tried gluing sheets of sand paper to a glass shelf I just happen to have. Used it to sharpen my old beater chisels I take to the job site. worked well, but the sand paper died quickly. I used some Harbor Freight junk I had. Enough of a test run to see that this would work well with better sand paper. Started with about 100 grit and went in five steps to 1500.

So, what do I buy for sandpaper or abrasive sheets and where do I get it? Aluminum oxide? Emory cloth?

Still have not gotten to the plane...Life gets in the way.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#2

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question *LINK*

mdclor

Good morning, Barry, you can get some of the higher grits locally in automotive type stores. I recently bought some from Lee Valley. HTH


LV 3M Micro-Abrasives

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#3

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

John McGaw

For the initial stages of sharpening beat up tools blue zirconia abrasive is wonderful. I use a 1" blue zirconia belt on a little benchtop belt sander for reshaping turning tools and have been using the same belt for years -- it just doesn't seem to wear even when working with fancy composite steel. For the finer grits you will probably have to go to old-school emery paper (or cloth) since the blue stuff doesn't seem to come in very fine grits (or at least I haven't been able to find any).

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#4

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

BrianMonumentCO

Try some of the paper that is found in the ddry wall section of HD.

Also I have found that a drop or two of oil on the paper helps when polishing metal.

I used this tactic when doing a lot of polishing as a gunsmith.

There is a company (whose name I have forgotten for the moment) who sells tools and they sell strip emery cloth in different widths. You might also try Brownells, but I think they only go up to 2 inches.

For metal work , I have found emery cloth or paper to work better than sand paper.

But the upper grits in large sheet format has worked for me on sanding metal objects such as actions and barrels.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#5

That company is MSC


Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#6

everything you need to know....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.......can be found in the Articles Section of WoodCentral in the discussion of this topic written by Spencer Hochstetler and myself.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

Clint Searl

I haven't bought any for years, but wet/dry silicon carbide paper is what I've always used. Wet and self-adhered to a heavy glass plate. My view is that going past 600 is an affectation of marginally improved sharpness, not worth the ROI. Strop instead.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#8

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Barry

Sandpaper ends up being expensive as it needs to renewed frequently. And it is often at inconvenient times that you run out of 2000 or 2500 grits.

Consider a more durable set of stones, whether oil, water or ceramic. You would need three: 1000, 5000/6000, and 10000. You could get away with just the first two.

Example: Shapton Pro 1000, 5000, 8000 ceramic waterstones

No doubt many here could offer detailed advice should you show an interest in going down this path.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#9

not the best choice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the coarse grits it is too brittle, crushes easily with tool steels and suffers short life. Aluminum oxide or zirconia are better choices in the coarser grits, like larger than 800. Any technical service department at an abrasive company will confirm this fact.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#10

yes but....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Abrasive sheets are as effective as anything and a greatly less expensive place to start. People that experience short life are not using the correct abrasive composition and/or not using the proper sequence of particle sizes (see our article in the Article section). The average person on this side of the Forum has no need to sharpen to 2000 grit, though this particle size is readily available from any auto body shop supplier.

Our club once stocked 80 to 2000 grit PSA packed strips appropriately spaced particle sizes. $10 would buy a lot of sharpening.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#11

Clint Searl

Not my experience


Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#12

the reason small grits are lacking

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Though someone below disagreed with this fact, when abrading hard steels like we used in blades, the toughness of the particle is critical and the larger the particle the more toughness becomes critical. The zirconia- alumina particle (blue stuff) is tougher than most so it is most useful in the coarser particles sizes. In the intermediate grits, for example 400, the less expensive aluminum oxide is good enough so the market for the more expensive zirconia composition is lacking. In the fine grit sizes silicon carbide is tough enough and it can be efficiently crushed to yield these fine particles.

There must be some surface fracture of the zirconia particle to generate new cutting surfaces. I was told that in the smaller particle sizes there would not be enough pressure to create these new surfaces on the tough zirconia particle, another reason we find this composition only in larger grit sizes. In any case it sure does last a long time for abrading metal.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#13

Hardware store?

John in NM

I used to buy SiC up to about 2000 grit at the local Ace Hardware.

SiC will dull quickly, due to the way the crystal cleaves. When using it as loose grit this is an advantage as the grit stays sharp but becomes more fine. On paper it's likely just dull. Unless you have a reasonably priced local source of wet/dry Alox or zirconia however, its not worth worrying about.

I've never like sharpening on paper, so I wouldn't recommend ordering anything special until you've decided to stick with the method or not. Others may disagree of course, there are more ways to sharpen than probably any other task in woodworking, and we all consider our own method to be the one and only.

So get a few grits at the hardware store, stick it to the glass with water since even good paper won't last, and then decide if you like the results or not. If yes, look into papers that will last longer.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#14

Rhynowet

John K Jordan

>what do I buy for sandpaper or abrasive sheets

I've used many kinds of wet/dry sandpaper and I have found NOTHING better than Rhynowet. I bought a supply a long time ago from Highland Hardware but a Google search give suppliers, for example:

http://www.supergrit.com/products/RedlineRedFlexSheets

This is my favorite paper for woodturning in grits 600 and finer as well as flattening, polishing, and sharpening when stuck to a granite surface plate (I don't glue, just put a bit of water underneath.)

It is flexible and does not crack even when folded and creased, and no detectable particles come off with use. Although flexible, this sandpaper is stiffer than some which makes it far better to sand fine turning details. For woodturning I cut it into 1"x3" strips.

If I can't get more when I run out I'll probably give up woodturning and take up basket weaving or go live in a monastery.

JKJ

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#15

Not my experience either

R. Payne

Zirconia seems to be near the top, emery and silicon carbide in the middle, aluminium oxide a couple steps down and while I like garnet for wood it comes at the bottom for metal.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#16

question for the skeptics

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Have you seen any(or many) silicon carbide metal sanding belts or disks for sale in 100 grit? By contrast, aluminum oxide belts and disks are the norm. I hope you are not judging the efficacy of the aluminum oxide particle for cutting steel where this particle is bonded to paper designed for sanding wood. In this case the bond is rapidly wearing out, not the abrasive particle.

Silicon carbide is used in the fine grits for wood finishing because it crushes in use. The result is a uniform scratch pattern. The particles are either cutting in their original size or they fracture to doodle dust and don't cut.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#17

Clint Searl

Re: question for the skeptics

Clint Searl

The performance of any of the papers on wood is irrelevant to the topic.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#18

Not really

John in NM

The behavior of the grit will be similar regardless of the material being sanded, it will just happen more slowly with wood than with metal.

That said, I'll use the coarser SiC papers on steel when needed because they are cheap and readily available, which zirconia is not. If I were doing production work with belt sanders and steel it would be a whole different story, but for the odd sheet or two I don't find it worth tracking down fancy grit paper.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#19

Re: question for the skeptics

R. Payne

I don't buy paper cheap enough for the bond to give out Loose grit floating around on the work is terrible and I throw away paper without using it if I find a brand or batch that the bond fails.

I can use SiC paper on metal for longer than AlOx with neither losing grit.

Personal experience, your mileage may vary, results may vary and all that.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#20

Re: question for the skeptics

R. Payne

A thought occurs to me. I am using sandpaper after files when I use it on metal and almost always by hand. Hand sanding is different from using a powered sander (heat generation, pressure and speed), that may be why I see better results and longer lasting paper using SiC over AlOx. After all, I did some looking and the published numbers do support what you say, but I imaging those numbers were gathered using powered methods.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#21

Re: question for the skeptics

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"those numbers were gathered using powered methods. " is suspect you are correct. What silicon carbide can't stand is pressure, for pressure will fracture the particle. I am not supposing you exert much pressure on the particle hand sanding.

Silicon carbide has pointy particles so it gets after something like wood or finish, if smoothing a finish. It typically fails by crushing rather than rounding off the pointies as is the case for aluminum oxide.

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#22

Re: Scary Sharp

TomD

Scary Sharp was the moniker this method was "sold" under. Mike Dunbar was the most prominent exponent, so you might be able to search up info from him. i don't doubt the info mentioned by Bill is more technical, but in the alternative there is no knowing whose products will be the most available to you.

I used sandpaper extensively as a presenter as it was quick and no mess compared to ponds and water. I mostly use a few grits of SC glued to hard ply, and for finishing I used I think it was the second finsest paper LV sells for the purpose.

Real sanding sharpening is still the industry standard under power, but I guess that is not the subject here.

Once I got onto the sandpaper method it also became my preferred method in the winter. In that regard diamonds, as also advocated here, are my preferred portable/dry method today, I would not set up for sandpaper, but sandpaper works without specialized cast iron plates. I get by OK with 14000 diamonds alone, I think it is. But my tools start out sharp. And if I need to go to "11" I have many options. Three scraps are sandpaper are all you need.

http://www.finewoodworking.com/how-to/article/an-edge-with-waterstones-oilstones-sandpaper.aspx

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#23

Re: yes but....

Brian Holcombe

Start with sandpaper and a glass plate....end up with natural stones, diamond plates, ceramic whetstones, Arkansas stones, a granite reference plate and a good microscope.

:D :D :D

Re: Sand paper for sharpening metal question

#24

Re: yes but....

TomD

Is that all? :)