Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Loosing control over my work,

Posts

Loosing control over my work,

#1

Loosing control over my work,

Keith Newton

The Island I designed and have been working on is nearing completion, but it not coming out as well as I was hoping. The interior designer that the home owner has hired probably doesn't even know what Bubinga is, and wants to stain out all the red, which will probably kill any chatoyance. I would have satisfied his color scheme by using Poplar. Argggg.

Nobody notified me that the stone counter top was coming a few days ago. I had made a cardboard template for the bar-top, which was positioned where the stone should go, but the installers ripped it off, then bonded the stone top over 2" forward of where it should go, throwing out the balance for my eye. I thought I was going to barf when I went in and saw it.

I've spoken with the nice fellow who came out and measured, but wasn't around for the install. He is reluctant to even make an effort to try to move it. If it breaks, he says he'll have to order more stone, but not at his expense, and I damn sure don't want it to be mine.

I signed and dated it over a month ago, but now am thinking about trying to remove it. I'm sure there is nothing other than a blade that will release the silicone that bonds it on. I'm thinking I'll grind all the set out of my longest reciprocating saw blade to try fillet it off.

It is probably not healthy to get too passionate about one's work, and this vent doesn't seem to have helped. I was looking forward to sharing photos of this piece, but I may not now.

OK, Rant off,,,,,,, I hope you all have a great weekend.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#2

Adam of Oakland

Re: Loosing control over my work,

Adam of Oakland

Oh man, Keith that sucks, bigtime. staining the bubinga gave me bad chills just thinking about it...maybe you should switch it out for poplar. "folgers crystals" trick, sort of :-)

I know you were looking forward to posting photos of work done well, but it can be very instructive to new guys like myself to see things when they go pear-shaped. I'd be very curious to see how it turns out, esp. with the understanding that the mistakes were not under your watch!

Thanks!

Adam of Oakland

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#3

Re: Loosing control over my work,

William Duffield

For taking adhesive off, I've found nothing that works better than the Fein Multi-Master putty knife. It's official name is "2-11/16" Rigid Scraper Blade." Of course, there are now knock-offs of the MultiMaster that are a lot less expensive.

You have every right to be angry about incompetence. It probably wouldn't be efficacious, in time or money, to sue the installer, but couldn't you get the homeowner to do so, or at least threaten to withhold final payment? Didn't the "nice guy" hire the baboons, and doesn't he have some control over the quality of their work?

You might try showing the homeowner a finished sample of the bubinga and a sample of the stained abomination next to it, and let the homeowner tell the decorator what she wants.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#4

exploring ideas,

Keith Newton

I just Googled melt point for silicone rubber, and found 540º F. I thought it was higher than that, but was thinking about using a hot wire to try cutting the stone loose.

I've got a really big powerstat/ transformer that will heat a nichrome wire red hot. I'm not sure how hot that will be, or if contact with the stone will draw the heat away too fast, but seems worth a try.

Before I bother with the hot wire though, I have got two different wires that I will try tying a handle onto each end, then have two people try sawing through the silicone, while gently lifting the end behind the cut.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#5

well well, Things are looking up.

Keith Newton

When I left there, they weren't acting willing to even try. But I just got a call informing me that they had gotten it loose, and will be able to move it back.

My weekend is looking much brighter now.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#6

Re: well well, Things are looking up.

William Duffield

That's great! Just out of curiosity, you might ask them what they used to get it loose.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#7

Re: well well, Things are looking up.

John K Jordan

I got depressed when reading the first of this, a little better now. (BTW, nichrome wire melts at 2550F but might get pretty soft way before that)

Maybe you can talk the designer into leaving the bubinga as is for a while and see if it "speaks" to him or some other archi/art talk. (I told my architect son someone should write a handbook on the terms that community uses. Tongue-in-cheek, but it would be useful as well as funny.

I too would like to see the pictures, good or bad. If bad, at least others could see what you don't like about what they did.

JKJ

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#8

Was the designer not

Brian Roberts

involved from the beginning?

If involved from the start was there not a design and acceptance agreement?

If the designer came on later then the owner must have relegated decision power to him/her?

Good learning experience....if more than a little maddening.

Did you and the owner share a design "vision"?

Best of luck.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#9

Thanks all, The situation,,,

Keith Newton

My friend, the building contractor, ask me to help with numerous aspects of the house, including all the cabinets. He had drawn the plans for the kitchen, but before I got around to the island one day, over pizza, the owner expressed a lack of excitement over his island plan. They bounced a few ideas off one another, then they both looked across at me and ask if I had any ideas. I responded that I had visualized a good portion of the concept, but would need to work on it, then gave a brief description.

They both liked the concept, and encouraged me to proceed. Sometimes I get the impression that some clients have a hard time looking at a front and side elevation and plan view, then merging them in their head, so I will make a model, which I posted earlier. When she saw it, she responded with a string of superlatives, so I started looking for the best options for wood choice.

I've had the Bubinga veneer for about ten years, and was able to find some nice 12/4 genuine mahogany at one of my local suppliers. The Mahogany already has some red tones, but can be stained plenty of shades that would compliment the Bubinga.

She hired the interior designer after I had the island built. I suppose he chose the floor color and wall paint, and probably fabrics. I have not even seen him yet, but the floors are all very dark coffee brown, and the walls are gray. He proclaimed that the wood couldn't have any red tone. I think the only way to get rid of the red would be to stain it about as dark as the floor, which just breaks my heart. This is some really special wood, left over from a corporate jet interior, and probably cost them over $50 per square foot spliced and laid up as three ply. Although I got it very cheap.

I'm still fighting to prevent them from ruining it, so wish me luck.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#10

Re: Thanks all, The situation,,,

Yonak

Keith, I feel really bad about the misuse of your wood. Clearly, another, less valuable wood should have been used from the start or another designer with other ideas or the same designer with other ideas. ..But, if it doesn't look right, it doesn't look right, and the customer will have to live in the house.

If that's the case, either the floor will have to be taken up and replaced or the color of the cabinets will have to be changed. It's a real shame. I just hope the customer gets to make their own decision rather than be bullied by the designer.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#11

whenever I meet this person,

Keith Newton

I'm going to ask him what is the most expensive fabric he has ever chosen for a project, and did he think he could improve it by dying it? Ha

That is about how crazy this seems to me.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#12

Re: whenever I meet this person,

Brian Holcombe

There is a good chance that he is not familiar with how to treat exotic hardwoods and precious material.

I'd have that conversation with the interior design and the homeowner. Not in the interest of stepping on toes, but just to enlighten. He may be thinking stained "cherry wood", and then upon realizing what bubinga is he may change his opinion.

The 'no red tones' thing has been around for a while, interior designers want to separate their work from builder grade stained red everything in areas where it is prevalent.

Their tends to be a lack of consideration for real cherry (not stained!), bubinga, rosewood, ect. It's also somewhat uncommon to see these materials used in the builder-grade world.

There are ALOT of misconceptions amongst consumers, so taking a few moments to clarify points about something precious is important.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#13

Re: Was the designer not

TomD

Tell the designer you need a signed letter from him requesting the change, since it will affect the commercial value of wood (specified in the letter), and you are not going to be responsible for the damage. The letter needs to be specific. Doesn't need to make him look bad, but has to cover not just the change, but the potential downfall. Also, if the owners approved a sample, that should be documented.

As far as the install of the stone, that might be the kind of thing you need to be there for, like having final cut in a film.

At the end of the day, people who represent small parts of the vision need to keep their input in perspective. I have seen many corporate employees as well as crafts people who have a sacred cow they stand up for no mater what. Your woodwork could be the centerpiece of the whole project, but if the colour actually is wrong for the overall effect, keeping the colour because some wood nuts like it is not the way forward. And holding onto the past just hurts you, nobody else cares. Or should. And it isn't a decision you are paid to make.

Re: Loosing control over my work,

#14

Don't cast pearls in front of swine..

Mark Nowicki

.. unless you are charging diamond prices.

I hope the customer paid the full value for the bubinga.

Painting it is a just a change order. Cha-ching.