Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Demilune-smoothing the skirt

Posts

Demilune-smoothing the skirt

#1

Demilune-smoothing the skirt

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

PIC 1


If the profile is carefully band sawed it becomes a trivial task to fair the arc. When I was planning my first bow front chest of drawers I fretted over how I would smooth the arc of the drawer front and keep it all in the same plane for veneering. “It’s easily planed smooth” said Steve Hamilton of the Mack Headley and Sons shop. I had never before experienced an occasion where I would report “plane” and “easy” in the same sentence. But I respected Steve’s record of practical advice and proceeded. Even with my beginner plane skills it was indeed easy, and quick to boot.

When building bow fronts a short plane is the weapon of choice for removing the band saw teeth marks. The lines made by the teeth become depth gauges for the planing. These “depth gauges” are critical to keeping the surface of the arc in one plane, and not like a potato chip. With short strokes of the plane one makes them disappear uniformly across the surface of the arc. When they are gone the smoothing is done, and if they disappeared uniformly, top to bottom, the result will be a surface that will be square across the arc. That is to say, if one was to set the arc on a flat surface the face of the arc would be perpendicular to this surface all around the arc, an essential requirement for a bow front drawer or table skirt. Alternatively a file or coarse sand paper can be used but these approaches are slower and more risky of rounding the surface. I do lightly sand the planed result with coarse paper on a stiff block, being careful not to round the edges.

Re: Demilune-smoothing the skirt

#2

Ellis Walentine

Good advice, Bill

Ellis Walentine

The important thing, of course, is the depth adjustment of your plane iron, which will be very shallow or even non-existent depending on the radius of the convex curve you're planing.

Nice plane, by the way. What's the pitch?

Ellis

Re: Demilune-smoothing the skirt

#3

comments on the plane and planing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The important thing, of course, is the depth adjustment of your plane iron, which will be very shallow or even non-existent depending on the radius of the convex curve you're planing."

I failed to mention that the plane is skewed a bit to the band saw "ridges". It seems to go better than way. In fact the depth of cut is greater than I might have had for flat surface planing, because in the beginning one is just planing off the tops of the ridges.. I see where you are coming from, namely that the radius of what is being planed would curve up into the plane mouth. But in fact it would take an arc with much smaller radius to be a factor, or so it seemed to be. Like all planing, one just tries it and adjusts to a satisfactory result.

"Nice plane, by the way. What's the pitch?" It is an ordinary #4 LN that I rarely use, but it seemed right for this job. At one time when we had the lumber business we had a LN account where I could get LN stuff wholesale. What you all paid a dollar for, LN profitably could sell to a distributer for fifty cents and us for 65 cents. I stocked up on what might be needed and it turned out some of it wasn't (needed). LN changed their marketing and we lost the account, but I hold no grudges. I suspect that now they sell less but make as much or more by capturing more of the retail price.

My go-to plane is a refurbished Stanely #5 with a Hock blade and a very tight cap iron. I have come to the conclusion that the plane mouth is irrelevant once the cap iron is set up optimally. I leave mouths wide op now days, so mouth condition on a used plane is unimportant. If customers were knowledgeable someone could have a good business buying up used Stanley planes, putting them in guaranteed working order and reselling for half a new plane price.