Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Posts

Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#1

Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I just purchased a Festool CT26E vacuum cleaner after my Fein Dustex bit the dust. Pricy, but it has many features I like. That is not the issue here.

I spent some time thinking over how I could hook up the Dust Deputy. I have the original Deluxe version that comes with two buckets. I use one bucket as a bracket.

What Oneida have done is create an airtight box that fits like a sustainer onto the top of the machine - the Ultimate Dust Deputy. It is very expensive locally - $500. Others have attempted to build their own version by converting a sustainer. It is a lot of work to make it air tight, and I imagined how difficult it would be to empty each time.

I decided to go in a different direction. It occurred to me that I could use a Sustainer as a base for a bucket. That is, bolt a bucket to a narrow sustainer, which would fit to the top of the CT26E. I have one from a C12 drill/driver.


The hose connecting the inlet of the vac and the outlet of the DD is wire reinforced plastic/vinyl - just a 2" version of the hosing that is used for the dust extractor and machinery.

All of a sudden reading about static build up with the Dust Deputy, and that it can fry motors and circuit boards. I have used the DD for a number of years and never experienced static shocks. How would I know this is occurring? The Fein requires a new circuit board - could this have been due to static electricity? There was no warning.

How big an issue is this, and what can be done with the original system to ensure all is safe?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#2

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Rick Christopherson

The problem comes up only if you are using conductive (anti-static) hoses. If everything is conductive except for the DD, then static will build up in the upstream side until it reaches a large enough charge to jump the gap across the DD. This impulse discharges into the vac.

If everything is non-conductive (non-anti-static), then the charge will also build up, but it won't discharge with a large spike into the vac.

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#3

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The problem comes up only if you are using conductive (anti-static) hoses. If everything is conductive except for the DD, then static will build up in the upstream side until it reaches a large enough charge to jump the gap across the DD. This impulse discharges into the vac.

If everything is non-conductive (non-anti-static), then the charge will also build up, but it won't discharge with a large spike into the vac.

Thanks for the reply, Rick.

Translate a little for me: "static will build up in the upstream side". Where is that - the hose from the DD to the tool, the hose from the DD to the vac ... ??

"The problem comes up only if you are using conductive (anti-static) hoses.". Does that mean that one does not use antistatic hoses to avoid static? That does not sound right.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#4

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Rick Christopherson

I know on the surface it doesn't make sense, but if you think deep enough it does.

Conductive hoses are good. However, when you put a non-conductive break in the middle of them (the dust deputy), then they become bad.

If you have a freeway with a steady flow of cars, the exit ramp (the CT vac) can handle the steady flow of cars exiting (conductive hoses).

If you have a freeway that's at a complete standstill (non-conductive hoses), the exit can still hand the traffic because there won't be any cars exiting.

But if you have a freeway with a drawbridge in the middle, the exit will get inundated when the drawbridge closes and the cars can suddenly move.

It is the sudden spike in traffic (static) that zaps the electronics.

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#5

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

AZ in Colorado Springs

Not wanting to hijack this thread, but I have a related question. I use a rockler vortec and rigid shop vac with my rigid planer. I usually get a few small tingles during operation and the debris shows signs of static when I empty the vortec. But when I just vacuum the shop and empty the vortec, no static. What's going on?

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#6

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Barry Irby

Static electricity is such a common occurrence with shop vacs it is amazing to me they are not designed to get hammered and not be damaged.

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#7

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It is an interesting observation.

Most of my hand work is done with handtools (I have a combo jointer/thicknesser and a bandsaw, but these are connected to a dust extractor). My hand planes and chisels leave debris, and the vac will "sweep" these up without an issue. I assume that the shavings are large and will create less friction than the chips and dust from a router or sander. I do not do much sanding (fingers of one hand over the past few years), but I do hook up a router for, for example, morticing. This is the danger area, I am assuming. I've not experienced any static to date, but perhaps I do too little to notice.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#8

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

William Duffield

Oneida makes another version of their Dust Deputy specifically designed for Festool CT vacs. It's dust bin attaches directly to the Systainer latches on top of the vacs. Also, it will accept a liner in the dust bin to make it easier and neater to empty it.

https://www.festoolproducts.com/Oneida-AXD000009-Ultimate-Dust-Deputy-p/axd000009.htm?gclid=CMus9Or4g8kCFdgGgQodIagDxw

The photo also shows a vacuum line that keeps the liner bag inflated if the hose gets clogged. I don't remember the details of the grounding strip that is inside the dust bin, but I know they at least used to supply one that could be connected to the CT. I note that their product description now says the vortex's plastic is conductive, but that's probably not your model. You would need to make a metallic connection between the CT and the inside of the DD, and also between the DD and Festool's anti-static hose connected to the sander. The connection to the CD would be a lot easier if you also used a Festool anti-static hose between the DD and the CT. (Festool's anti-static hoses are green; their non-anti-static hoses are white.)

A disclaimer" I don't use the Dust Deputy, and the climate here is so humid that I never have static build-up problems with my CT-26 or CT-Mini even when using a non-anti-static hose.

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#9

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks William.

I am aware of the new DD. Unfortunately, it is not available in Oz. I have instead just purchased this version, which is manufactured in the UK ..

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/121320651132

This is made with carbon, which the anti static ingredient. I have also added an anti static connecting hose along with anti static couplers.

It all seems overkill (and excessively expensive), especially when I have not actually experienced static before.

I am interested to know whether there is a difference in the creation of static when one just sweeps up larger plane shavings vs sucking up tiny dust or router chips?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#10

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

William Duffield

Reading the Wikipedia article on static electricity, I think it says that the size of the particles does not affect the static charge.

It seems that the static discharge may be more likely to ignite the smaller particles created by a sander, because they have a larger surface area to mass ratio. This could possibly lead to an explosion, but I have read arguments that this is not a cause for concern on dust collection tubes that are 4" diameter or smaller. I never did the math myself, so I cannot comment on the veracity of the study.

Air and particles moving through a dust collection system will also build up a static charge on the outside of the system, and this can lead to a static discharge outside the system. This spark can ignite flammable vapors in a shop that is acculating VOCs in concentrations above the LEL.

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#11

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

I rarely use a ROS (my Festool is about 20 years old, and dates to when it was called a "Festo"). Consequently, it is not a multitude of fine dust that I am concerned about most of the time. I doubt that I should ever be in a situation where there might be an explosion! The VC is paired with a router, where the use is mainly in multiple mortices. Occasionally excavating dovetail waste. Here the amount of waste removal is far less. I prefer to do my builds with hand tools. Probably the VC gets used most in sweeping up, and collecting the dust and shavings from hand planes.

So, if the size of the particles does not contribute to static, is their a threshold in terms of duration of use that does?

It seems to me that the environment of the shop plays a big part, with dry air a major contributor. Yet here in ultra dry (and hot) Perth, I have not experienced the tingling of static ever. I am curious how many others have experienced static with their VCs, and whether this issue has been blown out of proportion?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#12

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

William Duffield

I'm looking for the exposé that put the rumors and fearmongering to rest, but it appears it has been deleted from the web. In the meantime, here are some others:

http://www.thewoodnerd.com/articles/dustExplosion.html

Here is one by Rick Christopherson. I'm not sure why he didn't sight it in his response, but he offers an explanation.

http://www.waterfront-woods.com/Articles/Electricity/static.htm

I really regret having brought this up, because now we will have all the nut cases in the tin foil hats crawling out from under the woodwork.

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#13

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

Thanks again.

This talk of explosions is not what I had in mind when I raised the issue of static. What I was more concerned about was the possibility of static damaging the motor of the new Festool vac if I did not use anti-static hoses and/or used a plastic Dust Deputy.

Associated with this, I plan to make a new storage bin for a cyclone, and would like to know whether to use a galvanised steel or a plastic/PVC bin?

Would it make any difference at all, or should I avoid one type specifically?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#14

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Dust is a huge problem in grain elevators, and OSHA monitors those levels constantly. I once asked the regional director of OSHA what a safe level of dust would be because there are huge fines involved. His response was that there is no safe level of dust.

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#15

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

mdclor

Bruce, he may have been exaggerating to make his point or he may have been referring to the respiratory issues. However, I once had so much dust in the air in my shop that it set off the smoke detector. I didn't get blown up but my handkerchief told me about it for a couple days afterward. haha

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#16

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

Barry Irby

I used to have a Sears/Craftsman 32 gallon shop vac. (The opposite end of the spectrum from the one we are discussing here.) When I was building we had a patio door fall over and break. Two pieces of glass about 3' by 6'8" burst into abut a million pieces. I vacced them up. It was a painful process. Lots of static zaps. Really powerful zaps.

Often when I plan wood with my Dewalt lunch box planer I let the hose from the DC rest against my leg. I get zapped by that, but not nearly as powerful as the zaps from the glass bits.

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

#17

Re: Festool CT26E and Dust Deputy ... and static

William Duffield

I haven't analyzed the circuitry or other engineering parameters of the Festool, much less older Festo, CT* controls, and I don't have experience in Festool's repair facilities, so I'm not much help. Anecdotally, I have noticed that the number of complaints of failures of CT* controls seem to have decreased to the vanishing point of late. I use both of mine with anti-static and non-anti-static hoses, connected to Rotex sanders and Domino plate joiners, and have not encountered any more switch failures or explosions or even zaps using the non-anti-static hose. Specifically zero, none, nada, zilch. However, if there is such a thing as "opposite" when measuring climates, I think ours fit the definition. Around here, water actually falls out of the sky**, in several different forms, including freezing fog. There is no "dry season." Sometimes I walk into the shop in the morning, and it appears to have rained inside, but only on the metal parts. Maybe you could ask Marc Spagnuolo or Paul-Marcel St-Onje? They both have lots of Festools, live in Arizona, and like to share what they know about woodworking.

* Clean-Tec, Festool brand for dust collectors

**and sometimes enough pollen or elm and linden samaras to make a windshield opaque, and even fish.