Anybody tried using a big floor buffer with a sanding screen on it to remove the original finish. The old finish is in bad shape, probably fifty percent of it missing. the bare part of the flooring is pretty dirty. Somehow can't imagine screening it will be enough. Anybody got experience?
I've done my oak floors twice.....once with the rental sander from Lowe's (part of the Varathane system) and once from Home Depot. Neither was a drum sander. Both worked fine for me but then my floors weren't in awful shape, those units are really for removing the finish and light surface sanding, not for removing serious amounts of wood. IIRC, screening is what you'd do if you're just laying down another layer of finish, not sanding down to bare wood.
I would say the question has more to do with the shape your floors are in. If they're bad, a drum sander is probably the way to go.