Just before my move I bought a used table saw. I now have the shop up and running and need to make some table saw inserts. I've tried hard to improve all my dust collection at each machine. What I'm wondering is how to improve the dust collection through the table saw inserts. I typically only had one hole in the back for your finger to lift them out. What I'm wonder is if I drill a bunch of small holes in the front around the blade will it pick up more of the dust that tends to come over the blade.
My mini max bandsaw has many holes in the blade insert and they work wonderfully which is why I'm asking.
I've heard that logic before and I think it is good, except perhaps for the case of a skimming cut where the insert is not covered on one side.
I've thought a lot about the same problem of getting more air flow past the blade. It seems sketchy to me to rely on the leaks around the cranks to get enough airflow through the cabinet.
I'm toying with a design which directs a horizontal stream of air from a tube mounted close to the blade just under the top of the table, the air drawn from the outside by negative pressure inside the cabinet, perhaps aided by an opposing smaller dia duct on the other side of the blade, wyed off the 6" duct to the TS. Haven't tried it yet. I want to first see if adding the Excalibur overarm helps with the airflow.
I put DC into my shop about ten years ago and i have a old Delta Contractors saw. I decided not to seal the cabinet. Installed a sort of Cereal Box shaped plenum/shroud around the blade with a four inch port at the bottom. The top of the box is angled and there is a removable cover that allows for changing the blade and angling the cut. It rides with the arbor and closes down to about a half inch slot. I gets about 98% of the dust from below the table. It also pulls off nearly all that would ride the blade up and over. The difference between OFF and ON is obvious and huge. Does not work as well on the skimming cut.
I put the blast gate to the front so it is near the switch. The gate turns on the DC. Putting it close tot eh saw switch was a good idea.
And, like JKJ, I am thinking of some way to blow or suck the chips out of the teeth or gullets while they are inside the box before they come back around and dump the dust on top. Actually had not thought of sucking the dust out. Was thinking of using the air compressor and a nozzle, that involved bring the air compressor into the act. Hmmm?
John, Would holes in the throat plate put enough suction on the work piece to make it difficult to slide it across the blade? Just wondering?
My mini max bandsaw has many holes in the blade insert and they work wonderfully which is why I'm asking.
I don't think it would work like you want because on the Mini Max (or any bandsaw) the teeth are cutting and taking the dust down versus a circular blade that's throwing the dust up as it cuts through the stock.
The holes in the MM are effective too because the dust collection is closer to the source versus the space of the cabinet beneath a cabinet style tablesaw.
Barry has a good thought about possibly sucking on the wood. The hose on my bandsaw is closer to the bottom but I found that quite a bit of dust does follow the blade and came out the top where there were 3 holes, one for the blade guide when it's lifted all the way up so you can't cover that hole. I put a second hose over that hole and it's eliminated almost all the dust in the saw.
I tried putting a hose over the blade on the table saw but it's not as effective as I thought and it bothers me trying to look around it when cutting or lining up cuts.
Since I'm going to be building 3 or 4 inserts I'll just build an extra one and drill one and let you know what happens. It just seems like I need more air flow around the blade. Not sure how hard it would be to build some sort of dust collector around the blade. There aren't many places to attach it.
John at the time I did mine, I spent a lot of time and thought on it. Contractor Saw vs cabinet saw, etc. Went to Bill Pentz' site and studied up. The whole thing is a vortex with a slippery slope. Fascinating and you can get so wrapped up in it you forget to actually do any woodworking.
I remember putting a giant paper try under my saw to really see what I was missing, It was such a tiny amount I figured I was finished.
One thing I did was get some brushes that have abut two inch bristles and they are about 6" long and stiff. I think they came from somebody that made Ice scrapers and were intended for brushing snow off your car. They had a metal back bone. I epoxied them under the standard metal insert for my saw. They closed the space between the top of my pick up box and the underside of the table but let some air in. Eventually they fell off. While in place they seem to have helped a lot. I think they physically directed the saw dust down and into the box.
I removed the original half chute from the saw and used the holes to attach my pickup box. I also found a threaded hole behind the blade to attach the other side of it. That hole may been for some sort of splitter I never had. Getting good dust pick up on the TS was very "interesting".
John, take a look at the SharkGuard. It attaches to the splitter and has a 4" port on the top for dust collection. I don't know if a model is made that would attach to a riving knife. I will guess that it gets 90-95% of the dust that comes off the top of the blade. However, it doesn't work when you can't use the splitter, e.g. dadoes.
I experimented with an over the blade pick up. I used a piece of that stretchy aluminum four inch dryer vent and hung it down over the top of the blade. I mashed the end into a more elongated oval shape with the front angled down. The idea was that the blade woudl fling the sawdust into the chute and the impact with the chute would stop it, negating that 100 mph thing and if the aluminum hit the blade it would be fairly harmless. It did not work very well. Not enough slurp factor. Discouraged me from buying another manufactured version. I did not want one because I have a tiny shop and I felt it woudl be in the way. If anyone has one they love, let me know.
Keep in mind that the sawdust ejected from a table saw blade is moving at over 100mph. Suction alone will not cause the sawdust to materially change direction.
To change direction, you need a sort of shroud to funnel the dust to the entrance to your dust collecting hose.
On another point made above, holes in your insert will have little or no affect in picking up the dust from the top of the blade or the tabletop. The material being cut will cover the holes. The higher you raise the blade, the more the dust will be directed downward into the sawbox.
The only way to get most of the top-of-the-saw dust is to have suction from above the top of the blade.
For those considering enclosing the sawbox on a contractor saw keep in mind that you need to have entry points for air to replace the air going into the dust collector. The entry should be at minimal the same number of square inches as the entrance . The entrance hole should also be strategically located to have the air/dust stream targeted into the dust collection entrance.