Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Titebond II glue failure

Posts

Titebond II glue failure

#1

Titebond II glue failure

andrew nistock

Hi All,

Wondering if anyone out there has had any problems with the new Titebond II premium wood glue failing. I recently did an outdoor project that required glue-ups for spindles in a cemetery fence. Installed it in July and it is now showing hairline cracks in the glue joints. I have used Titebond II for years and have had no problems. The new label lacks the word weatherproof but the "user tips" read the same. Any thoughts.

Andy

Re: Titebond II glue failure

#2

Re: Titebond II glue failure

andrew nistock

Hi all,

I have been in touch with the Titebond people on this matter. Was told that the formulation has not changed for titebond II. Just the label has changed. They said what may be causing the hairline cracks is that if the fence is in full sunlight the wood may be continuing to dry causing the hairline crack. They figured that if the glue had failed it would be much more than a hairline crack. So we will wait and see what happens.

Andy

Re: Titebond II glue failure

#3

Re: Titebond II glue failure

TomD

The fact that glue is waterproof, is a long shot from saying nothing bad will happen. Wood movement is still there and certain structures will easily tear themselves apart.

I build boats, and to ensure weather integrity, they need to:

- Be laminated out of pieces that are 3/4" or less, using good marine grade epoxy, or other high performance glue. All elements need to be coated with 3 layers of epoxy, and preferably glassed. All hardware intrusions, and such need to be specially engineered. The whole thing needs to be painted white.

I have seen products made by the best, left out of doors, that used all these rules, and were still coming apart. It is a long time ago now that I saw it, but the wind farm blade the Gougeons made for GE and NASA, there is/was one on display in a park in Bay City, and when I saw it is was showing signs of serious problems.

Short of that I would want to use solid wood without laminations.


Re: Titebond II glue failure

#4

Re: Titebond II glue failure

BrianMonumentCO

Titebond II is weatherproof while

Titebond III is for waterproof.

If the fence was wet that could be the problem.

Re: Titebond II glue failure

#5

Re: Titebond II glue failure

BrianMonumentCO

Titebond II is weatherproof not waterproof.

Re: Titebond II glue failure

#6

Re: Titebond II versus III

David Yoho

What I found interesting when reading their website is while Titebond II is weatherproof and Titebond III is waterproof, neither are intended for below water use.

Re: Titebond II glue failure

#7

Re: Titebond II versus III

John in NM

Yeah, funny how we've always given PVA manufactures a lot of latitude in the meaning of the word "waterproof". I have always taken that to mean water resistant or weather resistant, as in if you keep it painted or otherwise sealed you can use it outside ok.

I would try an epoxy or poly glue if I wanted actually waterproof glue, or perhaps plastic resin glue. The trouble with all of those is that they do tend to let go of the wood as the wood moves with changing MC and the glue stays stiff.

Seems like PVA and sealing is still the best solution, though it does require maintenance.

Re: Titebond II glue failure

#8

Re: Titebond II glue failure

Howard Acheson

>>>> The fact that glue is waterproof,

Titebond does not claim that the Titebond II is "waterproof". They claim it is "water resistant". It will not stand up to long term exposure to sunlight and moisture. The Titebond III is the version that is much more "water proof".

Re: Titebond II glue failure

#9

Re: Titebond II versus III

Howard Acheson

>>>> I would try an epoxy or poly glue

Not a good choice either. Epoxy will quickly deteriorate when exposed to the UV in sunlight. Epoxy adhesive or finish or polyurethane must be overcoated with a UV coating if you want it to last.

Re: Titebond II glue failure

#10

Gorillas

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I fixed a stairs that connects my steep bank to the river with Gorilla glue some years ago. It gets submerged now and then and rained on often. The exposed squeeze-out glue turned brown and disintegrated but the joint remains secure.

Re: Titebond II glue failure

#11

Yep...

John in NM

The UV doesn't get into the joint itself.

Now poly hole filler foam is terrible stuff if left exposed, but poly glue is on occasion a good adhesive for a tight joint. Unfortunately I don't find those occasions to be frequent enough to make it worth having the glue on hand :D