Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Hand Plane questions.....

Posts

Hand Plane questions.....

#1

Hand Plane questions.....

Barry Irby

When I was kid, just starting wood working, about fifty years ago, I bought a hand plane, because you are supposed to have one...or more than one. Its a Stanley, probably a No. 4 or 5 (How can I tell?). It has basically never been used. Been in the drawer with maybe and hour of day light in all that time.

So, how does one become friends with a hand plane? Clearly I am missing something. At least two things actually, the benefits of hand planes and how to tune this one. I feel the tug, but have not fallen into the vortex of hand planing. I have read articles on tuning planes. I wonder if flattening the sole is all its cracked up to be? It seems they all need it, but how important is it? I assume mine is not nearly as sharp as it should be so I am thinking that's a good place to start. So now I am into flattening the back of the iron and the face of the chip breaker and then actually sharpening the iron.

And, The L-N folks are having a demo in Culpepper Va, about 2 hours form here at the end of the month. If I go, what should I be looking at and should I carry the big coin purse?

So, some encouragement and guidance would be appreciated.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#2

been there, done that

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My 50 year old hand plane that never saw the light of day is now a valuable tool in the furniture building arsenal. Some thoughts:

Planes provide a means of removing a precisely controlled amount of wood, quickly. If you have no need to do this task, forget learning about planes.

1. If the plane has not been useful when tried it is most likely because it was not sufficiently sharp. Learn to sharpen. A mentor will be especially useful; the internet greatly less so. I just went through this exercise with a new club member. They had become incapacitated with confusion. When ever in history someone learns to sharpen the technology of that age becomes frozen in their brain and becomes the ONLY way to sharpen (generalization here). Abrasive sheets are a cheap and effective way to start. see my article in the Articles section. Modern synthetic water stones are a good place to end up.

2. A second limitation is fear of unexpected tear-out. Learn to set the cap iron(AKA chip breaker) again from Weaver's article in the Articles section. Our new to planing club memebers who have tried it were most satisfied.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#3

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

chuck wintle

With all the machines available today, planers and jointers why mess with a hand plane?

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#4

Yep...

John in NM

Those two things, if you do nothing else, will vastly improve your plane's performance.

Personally I like aftermarket blades, as I find they hold an edge better than the factory blade.

All the other tuning is secondary at best, a waste of time at worst. That statement may be overly provocative, but from my perspective it is true.

The other thing to remember is that there are several ways to sharpen a blade. As near as I can tell, there is little difference between them in terms of results. Subjective as it is, the best one for you is the one you end up liking best for whatever reason.

I like LN planes, and have a few. They're very pretty and I like them. They are not a working necessity however.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#5

Re: Hand Plane questions..... *LINK*

mdclor

Hey, Barry, I found this article by fellow WoodCentralian, Derek Cohen. I am getting geared up for learning to properly sharpen a plane iron, then learning to use it (also, a scraper). There are times when the various machines and sanders just don't cut it. :D

Currently, I am leaning toward going to the LN event Friday, but may go Saturday afternoon. I was warned to either keep my hands in my pockets or bring my checkbook.


Lapping the backs of blades

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#6

Re: Hand Plane answers ..... [PICS]

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

With all the machines available today, planers and jointers why mess with a hand plane?

There are many joints and features that are only possible with a handplane.

There are places a handplane can go that a machine cannot.

In a number of cases, it is quicker to use handtools than set up a machine.

How many machines costing under $50 can work to the level of precision that a handplane can, such as removing .001"? :)

There are a number of handplanes that every shop should have and woodworker should master, regardless of whether power is the first preference (and vice versa - I use power to prepare rough boards).

Built with handtools:

Copy of Hans Wegner "The Chair":


Coopered legs:


Current work (curved wides and front - ala Bombe - with sliding dovetail construction):


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#7

Sage Advice

Ron in Sterling, CT

Barry,

Follow the suggestions made by Bill, and seconded by John, and you will be well into the slippery slope. I started out with a Montgomery Ward #4 (made by Stanley) received as a Christmas gift back in the late 40's. It also sat on the shelf and collected dust for many years. I have since learned how to properly sharpen a blade and make decent shavings. I now have several bench planes (excluding block planes) in my colle er arsenal, each having its own purpose. I am by no means a plane expert, but properly sharpened and set they can do a lot for you. I rarely use them for final surface preparation, but when the occasion arises, I do not hesitate to put them to the task.

I have attended several of the LN events. They have been worthwhile to me. It seems I always learn a new tidbit, or 2. Its a great opportunity to pick up a tool and actually try it out. Good Luck.

Ron

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#8

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I can cite a couple of examples where all the machinery can't do the job of a hand plane! When I retired from my occupation as a manufacturing/ quality Engineer, I had had enough of designing and building machines and tools from metal. So my son's, friends & I built my dream woodworking shop. Over a 3 ~ 4 year period, I purchased equipment and have just about everything I want. These include 8" joiner, 20" stationary planer, power planer, ROS's (both air and Electric) Belt sanders, a half dozen or so Routers and router table, CMS, Unisaw, Minimax MM-16 band saw, Powermatic Lathe and Drill press etc., etc.. I had done hobby shop woodworking for 40-50 years so did know what I wanted. One of my first major (to me) projects was to build a cedar lined Oak chest for my DIL. I built this with frame and panel and mortise and tenon construction. after partial assembly and glue up of the oak cabinet, I found that one of the panels was about 1/32 to 3/64" higher than the rest. The ONLY tool in my shop (short of possible clamping guide boards to the panel and using a router, which would have been very awkward and probably not accurate enough for me was to use one of my old rebuilt hand planes. In less than five minutes I had trued up all the panels within a few thousands (checked with a LV straightedge.

Just recently, Son and I installed a new furnace in my house. We built a new return air trunk from plywood so I could install a filter grill in a different area so the furnace operation would be much quieter than the old one. During assembly of the box type structure, one edge was to high to allow the "top" to fit properly. Son grabbed a hand plane and the fit was corrected ~ again in less than five minutes!

Power tools are wonderful, I remember in the 40's and 50's watching master carpenters working with hand saws and doing work with chisels and other tools that was very accurate. However, the skills required to be that accurate took years to achieve and the time to execute some of the work was several times as long as I can do it with my power tools. However I have found there are times when a hand plane, chisels or other hand tools can do things faster and more accurately than my best power tools.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#9

Here's a thought

David Yoho

Barry, like you, I was in the dark about tuning, sharpening, and using hand planes. Back when Woodcraft was still at Willow Lawn there was a manager there named Mike. He was very knowledgeable about this stuff so I inquired whether they ever would do a one on one class for me one day. Well, they did and I learned a lot. Maybe you could inquire about something like that again. I have always been the type that learns more from hands-on than reading.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#10

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

TomD

"With all the machines available today, planers and jointers why mess with a hand plane? "

Because planers and jointers leave surfaces that are rowed, and for which a plane is the perfect clean-up tool. The existence of planers and jointers makes more work for planes to do, not less.

Planes are also superior to jointers at jointing. I have a nice jointer, but I always hand plane joints.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#11

Surprising

Neal in San Jose

That no one has told you to post this over on the Hand Tool side. Over there you will get more opinions than you know what to do with!

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#12

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

TomD

I would go about it differently. Sharpen the blade, and see what it will do. If you can get a personal tutorial or even observe one, all the better, but sharpening with a jig is child's play, and all the info you need is on the internet.

Step one is getting the blade sharp and the plane cutting. You shouldn't have to touch the sole. The Weaver articles are down the road, because if you can't get the plane to cut you won't go there, and apparently most of the world was happily planing away, as you will be, without a close set breaker. Close setting the breaker will reduce tearout and make life easier, but until you know your plane is even capable of taking such shavings and doing that kind of work from the box, you will only make matters worse by trying. Your plane was designed to work from the box, some do and some don't.

Your plan should be:

- sharpen the blade, and set the plane and get some shavings;

- try setting the plane to take fine shavings.

- When tear-out gets to be a problem, experiment with a close set breaker.

A lot of these plane tuning articles came from a time when the best tools where either a process of doing work on new tools that should have been done at the factory, or reconditioning old tools. These days you can buy perfect, out of the box planes from many suppliers. But back in the dark ages, I bought a Record Jointer, and that plane was perfect out of the box. You can be lucky or not, but new products shouldn't need work, even from the 70s or 80s, but they often did. I bought a Record block plane during the same period and it had an adjustable infeed that was terribly machined and 1/16" out of true. It couldn't be fixed, and it is still cluttering up the shop somewhere.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#13

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

TomD

I should have said until you want to play with the close set breaker (which can be any time after you are getting paper thin shavings), set the breaker well back from the edge, even 1/8", and have some fun peeling off some pine shavings or whatever, and getting the feel of the adjustments.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#14

A compelling advantage to after market blades

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

they arrive flat. The Lee Valley blades arrive very flat.

I recently helped a new club member learn to sharpen. When it came time to sharpen a plane blade the lesson came to a near stand still while I laboriously flattened the back of the vintage blade. There is no task in woodworking I detest more than spending time flattening a blade back (unless it might be removing rust pits). It is easy to spend an hour or more sufficiently flattening a blade back. So, if you time is worth $30/hour buy a modern flat blade.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#15

Re: Surprising

Barry Irby

I did not want to be completely sucked into the darkness and was afraid of going there. I may have been hoping there was an electron or two that might save me.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#16

Thanks for the help...

Barry Irby

I think I will drag out the plane and figure out what it is and sharpen it. Then play with it a bit to see if it likes me. It should, I have taken care of it for about fifty years and asked nothing in return. Time for some pay back.

Where does one buy an after market blade?

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#17

Lee Valley of course

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Or Ron Hock

but mess with what you got first. Stanley blades are soft and easy to sharpen. Easy to dull too!

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#18

Re: Surprising

BrianMonumentCO

Sorry but the electrons are all on strike,

They are supporting the hand planes on this one.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#19

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

John lucas

BTDT i read the books flattened the sole and sharpened the blade and flattened and polisbed the chip breaker my old plane seemed to work better but i still couldnt take those long shavings yesrs later did it all again it worked better but i still wasnt that comfotable with it years later did it all again but this time used the scary sharp sandpaper method now i had a usable plane and thought it was pretty good this was an old craftsman plane

A few years later i got a good dealmon a Record plane did all the same tune up concentrating really hard on sharpening the blade i had heard a japanese woodworker mention a sharp plane will whistle wben it goes through the wood you know how you kind of write that sort of thing up as folk lore well this time around when i put it to wood it tookman extremely fine shaving and there was a sort of wbistling sound as tbe bladenlifted the shaving cool my planes now work better th ever but i know i still hace a long way to go

Oh and to answer why you should learn to hand plane Try running the edge of a 4" board over a joiner or custom fitting a drawer I dont use them a lot because im a wood turner mostly but i really value the time i spent trying to learn

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#20

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

Charles R. Smith

"With all the machines available today, planers and jointers why mess with a hand plane?"

I've never had to wear ear protection when using a hand plane -- the sound of a sharp blade passing over a smooth wood surface is almost like listening to music. I've silently used hand planes late into the night and never awoken a sleeping child (or a sleeping spouse). And I've never had to put on a dust mask to protect my lungs from the long, wispy, curly shavings that come off a hand plane.

Charles

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#21

The answer to your question will be obvious.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

... when in your woodworking a plane becomes essential. My plane epiphany came during a visit to the College of the Redwoods. Prior to this visit I had cut out parts using electrons and assembled the result, that fit more or less. As the projects became more complex the fit became less than more satisfying.

At the college I watched the students fit parts to joints and between spaces by removing tiny amounts of wood with hand planes and chisels until the fit was perfect. I returned home committed to learning how to do that. A difficult journey began.

The journey was difficult because I didn't realize there were woodworkers motivated differently. It was these experts that seemed to have the knowledge I needed. They planed because they liked to plane. It mattered little how long it took to make something, if in fact they did make something. In cases their technology is frozen in some time past. If not smitten by hand tools and the tasks hand tool can do, or a technological time period, it is difficult-confusing-annoying- exasperating -etc. -sifting through the experience of these experts to determine what tools you need and techniques to master to supplement your power tools and today's technology.

A class in a working furniture shop went a long way to help me decide what I needed for hand tools and hand skills. I have wound up in the vast space between an all power tool shop and an all hand tool shop, and even more complicated, I seem to be drifting around in this space depending on the project at hand. It all leads to buying more tools and learning more skills which maybe leads to building more complicated and better stuff.

The bottom line of it all is that you can build stuff, for example Period Furniture, if you have some hand tools and hand tool skills that is difficult or impossible to do without.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#22

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

John K Jordan

>I've never had to...

I like not having to run extension cord to fix a sticky door on an outbuilding. Cordless tools without batteries are handy on occasion.

Re: Hand Plane questions.....

#23

There are plenty of electrons in use....

John in NM

Even on the hand tool side. They're just used for sharpening :D