Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Demilune table question, with a drawer?

Posts

Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#1

Demilune table question, with a drawer?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Daughter needs a "wall table" to go between two doors. I thought the half moon top would be ideal for this location, offering a less obstructed passage in the door areas. I would like to add a small drawer which immediately leads to framing the table with a drawer questions.

1. Is it practical to engineer a drawer into this style of table or am I pursuing a flawed goal?

2. At what angle should the front legs be located in relation to the back and should their faces be parallel to the back or tangent to the curved side rail?

2. would one frame the drawer opening between the legs like in a rectangular table- dovetail in the top blade and M&T in the bottom one ?

3. Any advice on laying up the brickwork for the curved parts to wind up with tenons to insert into the legs? I am thinking about trying to arrange the top and bottom layer of "bricks to get optimum grain orientation for the tenons.

4, When laying up "bricks" for the curved parts to be veneered are they glued and nailed? I can' t imagine trying to clamp all the parts.

5. Anything else I need to know in moving from familiar construction at right angles to curved construction.

Or, would it be practical to lay up the bricks for the curved apron as one would proceed to make the table without a drawer. But, use "show wood" for the top and bottom brick layer in the area of the drawer and just leave out the bricks where the drawer opening would be located? Then add the legs with conventional bridal joint?

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#2

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

Keith Newton

Bill, Im not sure I know the answers to your questions, but dimensions and radius might be helpful for meaningful answers.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#3

Ask the experts

David Yoho

Bill, not having built one of these I don't have any answers. Maybe you could go over to the 360 Woodworking site and ask Glen Huey. I know for a fact he's done this countless times and could answer all your questions.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#4

Consider

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

the arc of an oval rather than a half-moon.

Depends, of course, on how wide the space between the door trims as I wouldn't have projection more that 20-24"

Rear legs square with the wall, fronts go tangential with the arc surface.

Consider torsion-box construction with the drawer front (full width between the front legs) hiding the structure

What, no steam bending or bent lamination for the curve?

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#5

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

John in NM

I would say it's practical to pursue, though I admit I've not seen one done before.

Legs tangent to the curve, definitely. I would approach the drawer like a square drawer and figure out where the least inconvenient place to accommodate the curve is.

Bricking the curve shouldn't be difficult at all, I've done rub joints with both hide glue and yellow glue, that is how I would approach it. I would oversize them and use a bandsaw and then a spindle sander or belt sander to refine the curve down to what you want. Trying to clue brick laid curved parts with a lot of precision strikes me as time consuming and more difficult than cutting and sanding to a line. If the belt sander is too aggressive for your tastes, there is always the spokeshave and rasp route to follow.

Personally, I prefer bent lams to brickwork, but that is usually not the way to go for a drawer front or if you want to stick to strictly historical methods. For shallow curves I have also cut the drawer front out of 8/4 usually after cutting the dovetails. That is unlikely to be an option for a demilune though.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#6

Fairing the curve

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Not sure that "fairing" is the correct spelling for turning a rough cut curve into a finished curve but I have done it easily with a hand plane on curved drawer fronts. One uses the band saw teeth marks as depth guides and just plane till they go away. It is amazingly fast with a #5 hand plane and vastly quicker than a spoke shave.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#7

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

Jesse Cloud

Haven't done one myself, but I saw a woodworker I admire do one in a class.

He used bent lams. Made the whole front curve from one lam. Then ripped it into three pieces, cut out the drawer front from the middle piece, then glued the pieces back together. He then crosscut out the places where he would later attach legs with mortise and tenon. Drawer framing was pretty traditional, dovetail and m&t.

He made a very meticulous full scale top view drawing and referred to it often to get the angles for joinery.

The piece looked spectacular, though he wasn't trying to make a period piece.

I think the suggestion about Glen Huey is an excellent one. Right up his alley!

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#8

That is a good idea....

John in NM

I like the approach your classmate used, that is pretty clever.

Also makes me think of how I would hang the drawer - use traditional saddle joints for the legs and leave the drawer opening narrower than the distance between the legs. Then slab rails to hold up the drawer guides are fairly easy to attach to the inside of the rail.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#9

Another approach....

John in NM

More of an A & C look, so you may not go for it.

So the table has four legs on a curve. Of the three rail sections between the four legs, make only the outer two curved and the center one (the drawer) straight. Means cutting angled tenons, but other than that construction is vastly simplified.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#10

Ellis Walentine

I put the word out

Ellis Walentine

Let's see if we get any responses from the experts.

I've actually built things like tables and smaller boxes with curved fronts and drawers. My preference is to laminate the curves and then cut the drawer opening. Make drawer runners, use saddle joints for the legs. The traditional method for demilune tables was to bricklay the curves, fair them and veneer them.

Ellis

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#11

Re: I put the word out

360_Glen

I think Ellis hit the nail on the head. If you brick-lay the apron, then cut out for the drawer, which should not, in my opinion, run from leg to leg, you could easily veneer the apron and drawer front keeping the pattern consistent.

Even though a bricked apron might not be as strong as its laminated counterpart, matching the veneer would be easier than trying to saw out the drawer front without any problems.

Also, runners and guides would square off the back apron similar to how a medial stretcher fits in a table without a drawer – the front connection could be fussy.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#12

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

Sgian Dubh

This is quite a simple project. You're overthinking it Bill. Laminate the curved rail over-width. Forget bricking the job - too much complexity when laminating is so relatively straightforward nowadays. After truing up the curved rail width, split off from it three parts, a narrow top and bottom edge, and a full depth drawer front. Cut out the arc length of the drawer front, and reassemble the four parts remaining to make up the rail, with a gap where the drawer front came from, and will go back in place later. This all assumes you veneered the curved laminated rail to start with, so that the grain of the rail and the drawer front are contiguous.

The front legs are then set the circle's arc, and joined with a bridle joint to the rail - you might consider using a bridle with a sliding dovetail element at the rear of the rail to leg part of the leg to rail joints, or even a halving joint with the leg screwed and glued in place from the back of the curved rail.

You need runners and kickers for the drawer to run between. Carcass dovetail these to the curved front rail and the straight rear rail, entering the runner/kicker parts from either the top or the bottom according to the function. Screw and glue them in place through the dovetails - if you don't get a perfect scribe at the shoulder dovetails, it won't matter much because they'll be hidden up tight and outta sight within the framing, and probably only you will know about it, unless you tell.

True, you'll need a former around which to bend the lamination, and something thin enough to bend, e.g., plywood or construction veneers, plus a show veneer for the front face. But the former is fairly simple, and you could do a male only former milled from layers of MDF using a router off a pivot point, and arrange for plenty of clamps to glue all the laminates together, using something other than creepy PVA or similar - I know you don't believe either PVA or aliphatic resin adhesives creep, but they really do, because I've seen it so often I can't ignore what I see - use something non-creeping such as urea formaldehyde or epoxy resin.

That's about it - don't try and overthink a pretty standard construction job, and look at historical examples for precedents. Slainte.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#13

Re: I put the word out

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The proposed drawer front is to be contrasting with cock beading.

I need to draw up the drawer not extending to the legs. I have in my mind how I might add the "filler" between the leg and where the drawer starts and you are right about "fiddly". Fiddly comes with things that are not rectangles.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#14

food for thought.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your post gave me some ideas to ponder.

The drawer is to be contrasting wood and cock beaded so I don't need to worry about its veneer matching the surroundings. And because it is cock beaded minor deviations of drawer to opening are not noticed.

While I will give serious thought to bent laminations it seems to me at this point to be more involved than bricking , band sawing and fairing the curve. But, I can use your idea of three sections, bricking in a way that leaves me with a drawer opening.

I have faired bandsawed curved drawer fronts and it is a quick and easy job with a hand plane. The result only needs to be perfect enough to accept veneer. The band saw teeth marks provide guides for how much to plane and where. The veneer then can be done in sections between the legs which makes clamping the shorter sections easier.

If the drawer does not extend to the angled legs its internal framing becomes straightforward. I can see in my mind that a veneered space between edge of drawer and leg is better than drawer to leg.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#15

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

AZ in Colorado Springs

A friend made several of these for family members. He used the bricking method . He made it oversized and cut out several fronts ( three IIRC) of diminishing radii. Might be something useful over the longer term.

Re: Demilune table question, with a drawer?

#16

Re: food for thought.....

Brian Holcombe

Looking forward to seeing this project as you build it!

Thanks for posting it up.