As I'm getting more familiar with the flora of our new land lease, I'm finding some pretty interesting stuff. There are about 3-4 understory species not included on our state champion tree list that I'm thinking about nominating.
40 acres of the 160 was clear cut about 5 years ago, except for a few scattered things. Several of which I believe are in the Hawthorn family. Some of them have stem diameters over 6". I'm having a hard time finding a good enough plant guide to ID the species. But while searching online, Ive been finding some fun facts and lore about Hawthorns generally.
Have any of you harvested any and made use of it? I'm not planning to cut any of these trees, but about 80 acres of land next to ours was logged last year. Those guys driving the harvesters and skidders, are not very sensitive about any vegetation not ready for this or the next harvest cycle, so I'm betting I could wander around over there and find something which was knocked down.
Some info I found, said that some had lived 400 years, which would be a pretty good indicator of decay resistance. If nothing else, I'm sure I can find some dead limbs to take samples to inspect ring size. I'm already planning to get my dendrochronologist friend down for a visit.
There is an app called Leaf Snap that works pretty well. Its put out by the University of Maryland so the further you are from that region the less accurate it is
Hawthorns appear to be an understudied group, specifically identifiable only by expert specialzed botanists and this seems to be aggravated by promiscuous hybridization between types. The leaves of the various types are wildly-varied and don't give much of a clue in themselves. As for identification in general, I prefer to drag out my Peterson Field Guide "Trees and Shrubs" which does a pretty good job all over North America. Even Peterson basically says, "just call it a Hawthorne and save yourself the misery of going further".
Do you know about the free wood ID program the government offers? (five samples each year for each citizen)
I dabble in wood ID with a microscope using Hoadley's book and other resources. A long time ago a forum member sent me a sample and also sent it in for ID. It took a few weeks, but their ID was the same as mine! (yay!) I can't get to my reference books right now so I don't know if Hoadley includes Hawthorn. I don't see it in the Wood Database. I would love to see a sample.
I read somewhere that hawthorn was diffuse porous and may be difficult to ID by pores alone. The leaves will be valuable to your expert. I understand hawthorn is usually a small tree or shrub/hedge, ID complicated by a variety of names (Wiki lists Crataegus /krəˈtiːɡəs/ as commonly called hawthorn, thornapple, May-tree, whitethorn, or hawberry.)
I see from your profile you have a woodmizer LT-15. I do also, and like you don't cut trees on my property but will saw downed trees or those that have to be removed. People give me trees all the time too. Good fun!
I would recommend "TREES OF MISSOURI" by Don Kurtz. It is available from the Missouri Dept of Conservation's web site. It is as complete a guide as you will find. Even if your land is not in Missouri.
The berries are the latest in gourmet/health/local food source craze. Too bitter/sour to eat as such and to difficult to harvest by picking - you will be stung to death by spines.
The harvest method is to cut branches with berries, freeze them, and the you can knock the berries off. Great for jams and jellies; high vitamin C and a nice tang.
I've turned hawthorn wood. It's a lot like its cousin apple. Anything you can use apple for goes for hawthorn. It checks readily, but it can have spectacular color and figure. I have hawthorn trees on my place in west central missouri at least 9" diameter and 25 ' tall. lots of branches. It tends to grow into multiple trunks within a few feet of the ground. Nice wood.
They bloom in Jan - March. The fruit is tart, and the best way to get them, is to spread a tarp, then shake the trees.
However in flood years, you can just shake them into the water, then scoop them up with a big net.
There is a Mayhaw festival in Eldorado every year, I think. My old former neighbor gathered them from this land, and sold them down there. He is 95-6 now, so I may have to take his place. ha
I did find two of my misplaced guidebooks. Neither of which had very much info. Leafsnap only had 4-5, and I can identify more than that without guides. Ill keep digging. I have 3 guidebooks, including Carl Hunter's "Trees and Shrubs of Arkansas", but even he admitted there was more, and his pics leave a lot to be desired.
I intended to get out with my camera this weekend to share some of my favorite places, but once again spent the whole time working. It is so dry down there now, that I can walk down the middle of some of the sloughs where Cypress knees tower over my head like giant cloaked swamp creatures.
Another dried slough is a almost solid stand of Water Elm, Ulmus aquaticus, which are low spreading trees much wider than tall. Since they are growing where they are normally in the water, there is no undergrowth, so I can walk around on a clean floor in a forest that would make a good set for Harry Potter. I also need to find a dead limb to sample for a ring count for these trees. They look ancient.
Along the margins are also some Water Locust, which have lots more thorns than their cousins Honey Locust. While showing some friends around out there, one spotted it in awe. Since he will be out there, i commented that whenever a wild boar gets after you, make sure to look up and not start climbing one of them. ha. There is one large one out there, free of thorns on the lower trunk, which appears to me would have a birds-eye pattern. I may see if I can get permission to harvest that one.
Yes I knew about the Forestry lab service, but have never used it. I wonder if I could speed the process by sending them some of my images. I can take a full frame image about 3/16 x 1/4" at 16mp, or less by panning.
You said, "hawthorn was diffuse porous and may be difficult to ID by pores alone."
I'm sorry to hear diffused, I'd rather find rings, so I can determine their age.
I do love having my Woodmizer. I'm thinking about switching it over to Electric, but I've got a few trees down at the cabin reaching the age of needing to come down, so maybe after that.
I'll try to get some pics soon of some of my favorite trees down there. I'm intrigued by the Water Elms down there, not American Elm. I need to study them, because they appear ancient.
> I'd rather find rings, so I can determine their age.
You can still see and easily count the rings in most diffuse porous wood like black cherry, sugar maple, basswood, etc. The pores between the rings in diffuse porous woods are distributed fairly evenly between the rings, unlike the large early-wood pores and small late-wood pores of ring poroius woods like oak and elm.
Dogwood is harder to count - the rings are sometimes difficult to see.
Speaking of rings, a guy I know taking a college course in dendrology recently said they told him that determining the age by counting the rings (dendrochronology) is pretty accurate but when you get to the center of older trees one ring can represent more than one year, even as many as 10. I've never heard of this and don't know what to think of it yet or if I even believe it. I have read that unusual conditions (wet/dry/temperature) during one year can result in an extra ring or two in that year. I would love to hear from an expert in this.
I don't know if it would help to send photos (except maybe photos of the leaves and bark). You would have to shave the endgrain with a razorblade to get a picture of the pores. Just guessing, I suspect they use something like one of those very expensive microtomes to get a clean surface for inspection. Some species they also have to count the cells in the rays which might need a higher power. Hoadley and others teach ID with a 10x hand lens. Just because I have one I usually use a stereo microscope (Swift) set to 15x, which is more comfortable than using a loupe.
If you get into this, I found the most useful 10x loupe in the world on Amazon - so far I've bought 6 of these for myself and gifts. LED Lighted, measuring scale, good optics, good field of view, and only $14. Great for shop, electronics, splinters, spider ID, etc:
My friend says that some years in extreme drought, enough moisture makes it to the leaves for photo synthesis, then due to transpiration, there may not be enough to send back down the trunk to feed new cell growth all the way back down the stem. They may exist higher up, and maybe only partially around the trunk. I don't think this would be any more likely like you state, "when you get to the center of older trees one ring can represent more than one year" than later in a larger older tree.
Dendrochronology only works by averaging out the indices of a large number of trees, which could show repeated patterns, with missing portions in certain individuals. There are lots of local influences that can affect the ring size of an individual tree, like insect infestation, vines covering it, a large neighbor falling to open more light, to fires.
They use a stereo scope, with the samples mounted on ways that move on X axis, which measures thousandths, where they click a mouse on each ring as the move across. Now it is all in the computer of calculating and finding patterns, although in the early days, it was done by taking notes, then plotting it on graph paper. Then by placing them side by side, you could slide one along next to the other, and when they are the same, as one old friend used to say, BOOM, you instantly can see the match.
Frost rings, may start as growth from an early warm spell, followed by a killing frost, then new early wood. Simple answer, if I understand it properly.
Fascinating subject. I'd like to spend an afternoon talking to your tree friend.
I read an article recently describing how "chaining" tree ring analysis has provided a continuous record for climate study back over 11,000 years. It appears to be tricky and tedious work considering both what you mentioned and the incredibly difficult problem of simply finding overlapping candidates.
The most interesting tree rings I've observed were on a limb on an oak tree here on our farm. The limb was about 40 ft long and horizontal for most of that length except for a crook near the end, maybe 10' off the ground. (My favorite limb, but sadly, died.) The orientation resulted in some pretty extreme reaction wood. This photo is of the trunk where removed the limb. I counted 98 rings but they were a little indistinct at the outside.
Sadly, half of the tree split from a crotch and came down a few years later, crushing a fence behind the barn. Even in the house on top the hill and it sounded like a gun battle, pop pop crack pop pop pop pop... The top was at least 30' into the field.
This is just the the first half that fell. The far bigger "half" stood for a few more years. This one was a challenge to saw and remove safely. I pondered that for a while!
How did you finally get the hung-up trunks down? I have some locusts in similar condition, that I would like to get down on the ground so I can saw them up and use them. They're hung up in other trees, or on top of each other.
Thanks for the recommendation on the loupe. I can't seem to keep the one I have in line with my eyes and focused. It is one of the little metal ones that swing out from two diamond shaped plates. BTW, the little measurement graduations are called reticles. They are very useful, but my loupe doesn't have them.
The magnifier on amazon doesn't have reticles as I'm familiar with (scales etched on glass) but has inch and metric scales on an opaque square border around the outside of the central field of view. They call it a loupe, but it's actually a hand-held magnifier. The focal plane is aligned with the bottom surface so you can lay it flat on a photo or such. There are three LEDs spaced inside for even lighting. And it comes with batteries! Every one who has seen mine has wanted one.
That big downed tree was a challenge. The biggest problem was that angled branch in the foreground, maybe 8" or so if I remember correctly. It was punched into the ground and supporting a huge amount of weight, bent and sprung from the compression. A killer for sure. I didn't even want to walk near it.
I whittled away from the tips of the branches that I could reach from the ground, then cut all larger limb/log sections I could reach that were suspended in the air. Made a big pile of brush and firewood and took a huge weight off the rest. BTW, each time I cut a branch I drag or throw it out of the way - branches underfoot while chainsawing are a real hazard. (I'm sure you know that but someone else may read this.)
Then I attached a 50' 3/8" chain to the bottom of the spring pole and pulled it with the tractor until the whole thing crashed further to the ground. Then I started over whittling at what I could then reach. When enough was cleared, I cut the trunk logs at the stump end to bring them to the ground where I could reach them. (got some good oak saw logs from that tree)
As for hung trees, it depends. If the tree was cut down and hung up in another while falling, or if it is safe to cut it at the ground, I might pull the base away, again with a long chain. On occasion we have to toss a rope up high to pull the top of the tree. Twice I have hired a tree service with a bucket truck to take down a hung tree a bit at a time. If out in the middle of the woods I have occasionally just left it and something will eventually rot and it will come down.
Funny you asked. Just yesterday afternoon I cleared out a smaller tree but in very much the same situation - down across the fence into the field, much of it way too high to reach. Fortunately the only sprung branches were just a couple of inches in diameter and the main trunk was only about a foot or so where I could reach it. I cut it the same way as the big one, whittling away from the top, clearing as I went. The pain with this one is it was a virginia pine full of sturdy pine cones that made the branches stick to each other like fishing hooks. Ack. The whole tree is now in a pile pushed to the middle of the field now waiting for a match.
I also have a skid steer (bobcat) I use instead of the tractor for problem trees. It has more power and a strong cage for protection from a widow maker branch. My favorite way to take down standing trees is dig around the base with the bobcat or backhoe then push it over! Gets the stump out of the ground that way too. I took down some big cedar, some sassafras, persimmon, and cherry that way recently while clearing for a new barn and access road. Very quick and safe way to take down trees.
I am very very careful around trees. I once researched all the ways I could find that you can die from cutting trees. Many were common sense but there were some I had never imagined. If you can't imagine a situation you can't possibly protect yourself from it.
One VERY good book to read about chainsaws care and safety and tree cutting is the Good Woodcutters Guide:
BTW, when I got my tractor I also read up on every way I could find to get hurt or killed on a tractor. One interesting and gruesome way that has caught several people: drive a tractor through the woods or growth knocking over saplings. Then turn around and come back on the same route. Tractors have been found out of fuel with the driver impaled by a sapling spear that was bent over on the trip out and worked it's way up through the tractor on the trip back.
Thanks for the tips, John. It wasn't clear from the photos and description that the graduations were not etched into the glass, but now I see it.
I don't have a real tractor, or a way to get a tree service bucket truck into my woods. I think I'd better invest in a heavy duty come-along and some cable to try to pull them down from a distance.
I can't tell you how many cheap come-a-longs I've been through, broken, bent. I don't think you can wear this one out. I've pulled lots of trees using a long cable, occasionally used it to roll big logs up onto a trailer in a tight spot where I can't pull the roll chain with a truck. I even pulled my tractor up a hill when I got it stuck once. This puller is not cheap but well worth it to me. (And Baileys is my favorite place to buy tree cutting and handling stuff.)
It comes with a load doubling pulley mounted on the cable. Just be REAL careful with cable safety since it can exert so much tension. A snatch block to change direction is almost mandatory - keeps you out of the line of fire if the far end of the cable breaks AND away from the path of the tree!
Oh Man, I'll bet you hated to loose that tree. I know that would break my heart. Funny though, that some people would want it taken down just because it was too big. I know of one in front of a beautiful old barn, greater than 4' dbh with limbs almost touching the ground all around, that the current grand child owner wants taken down, because it is "out of control", whatever that means.
While I might like to get some wood from it, I tried to enlighten her to appreciate it's wonderful beauty.
There is another Red Oak and Sycamore in front of the vacant old home that she would also like taken down. I'm sure tempted by that sycamore. I could turn an awful lot of one that size into nice wide QS lumber.
As for the pic of the offset pith in your photo, I'm sure you already know that is normal for a hardwood limb of that nature.
(Yikes, something went whacky and the earlier tree picture was substituted for the picture I intended. Hmm, preview was OK. I'm trying deleting and reposting.)
Yes, I cut boards from that tree for barn siding. When the rest of it came down it was too big for the mill but I cut firewood from it for several years.
We are fortunate to have a bunch of big trees. More than 1/2 of our 27 acres is woods and the other half fields, separated by a strip of woods. Just for fun, here is a satellite photo and 3D topo model I made of the place when we bought the place in '03 (before fencing, roads, gates, new buildings, garden, etc.):
We have dozens of trees 2-3' dbh, many yellow poplar but also red and white oaks, one big hackberry, and there was one huge cherry I had to take down. An relative walked through once with me and kept saying "There's another money tree" looking at the oaks - tall and perfectly straight trunks, he said they could be veneer quality. This property must not have been logged as extensively as even neighboring properties which have a lot of scrub.
Zillions of smaller trees here maybe 8-20" diameter: black cherry, persimmon, black walnut, yellow poplar, oak, elm, sassafras, maple, eastern red cedar, dogwood, sour wood, gum, hickory, hackberry, virginia pine, holly, etc. There is plenty of wood for sawing, woodturning, and firewood but I never take down trees for that, only use what comes down or needs to be removed for some reason. This is also a good place for kids we know to collect leaves for school projects (especially since I mostly know what is what!) Life is good!