Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

box lids

Posts

box lids

#1

box lids

DizD

Over the years I have seen plans and photos of boxes made with a single board hinged for a lid. I've wondered about long term prospects of this type lid staying flat considering that "wood moves". Has anyone built a box like this and kept it around to see what the long term effects were?

Re: box lids

#2

Re: box lids

John in NM

I've done that, usually with very small boxes, less than 4x6 in size. Seems to work fine, but then I'm hollowing them out considerably, leaving around 1/4" or less for the sides and top/bottom.

That probably helps a lot, since some I've seen for holding tool sets (tap/die sets, brace bits, etc) that have a slab top do tend to bend. They still seem to work ok with a hook clasp but they don't look nice.

Re: box lids

#3

Re: box lids

John K Jordan

What size? The small box lids I've made like that with solid wood (decades ago) have tended to warp (cup) without delay.. If I wanted to make one today I would use quarter-sawn wood, dry, and sealed well all around. I would also try to use a stable species like sassafras, cedar, etc. Perhaps internal cleats would help, especially if the top is quite thin. I have an old chest made like that.

Re: box lids

#4

I won't fool with Mother Nature

Dick Coers

I always float the panel, unless it's veneer on MDF, or plywood. No sense in going to all that work, then HOPE it doesn't self destruct. I never want the call that my work failed when I did something where I knew better.

Re: box lids

#5

Re: box lids

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I've made several boxes with flat solid wood tops. None have cupped that I know of. I make the lids 3/8-1/2" thick and I make sure the wood is dry before I use it. Be sure to finish both sides of the lid and the box equally with a film forming finish.

Here is one of the boxes.

Lee


img

Re: box lids

#6

Re: box lids

Larry U. Verhoff

About these LED`s, does anyone know much about them. Like how are they made, what are they made out of, especially the "filament". Or where could I go to read about them Thank you. Larry

Re: box lids

#7

Re: box lids

Larry U. Verhoff

Sorry I posted to the post, of course I wanted to post at the LED post. I tried to delete but just as the whole day has been going, I better go back to bed. I`m quitting while I`m behind. Larry

Re: box lids

#8

This is what I was curious about

DizD

I'm glad you have had good results. The relatively thin lids would seem more susceptible to movement. On my projects it seems Murphy always gets final say.