Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

LED light question....

Posts

LED light question....

#1

LED light question....

Barry Irby

How tough are they?

Incandescent bulbs had a filament that could break if your dropped them. I bought a case of LEDs and my son dropped the entire case. (These are the ones that are like incandescent ones.) They fell about three feet. Any chance I need to go through them all and check? This carries over a bit to the shop. What happens if you bump one?

Re: LED light question....

#2

Re: LED light question....

John K Jordan

From my own experience and from what I've read from manufacturers, LED bulbs are quite shock and vibration resistant. If you take one apart you can see how they are constructed. I think if the entire case with each bulb individually protected was dropped just three ft the bulbs would not be damaged internally.

That said, anything can happen. The guy who assembled them could have been having a bad day. If I needed to be absolutely sure each is OK I would test each one. Actually, my fumble-fingered son would test each one.

JKJ

Re: LED light question....

#3

Re: LED light question....

Bill Howatt

My guess is that if they were still packed in the case as shipped from the manufacturer they will be fine. I think the packaging would be designed for more abuse than the drop for general shipping and handling purposes.

But the only way to be 100% sure is to test them or take a statistical approach and test a few and if they are OK then assume the rest are.

Bill

Re: LED light question....

#4

Clint Searl

Not to worry...

Clint Searl

You'll find out when you need to use them.

Re: LED light question....

#5

Re: LED light question....

john lucas

Well I'm new at LED lamps but I just bought some 4 foot 2 light fixtures and dropped one box that had 2 of the fixtures with 4 lamps. It worked perfectly. I also had one mounted too low on the ceiling and the garage door hit it knocking it loose. It fell down hanging from the cord and hit my ladder knocking it over. It still works. So I'm going to hazard a guess and say I think they are alright but I'd sure check them anyway.

Re: LED light question....

#6

Re: LED light question....

AZ in Colorado Springs

Drag racing -- during a weekend event the NHRA would have to replace more than a dozen bulbs in the starting line "Christmas tree" that failed from the vibration caused by the race cars. No bumping involved. Several years ago they switched to LEDS which are far far more reliable. This little anecdote says the LEDS are sturdy and your bulbs will be OK.

Re: LED light question....

#7

Re: LED light question....

TomD

I agree they are durable. I have several in use that got really badly socked and all that broke was the dome that was supposed to configure them as a "bulb" The internals were fine.

My one distinction would be to point out that most led bulbs are actually sockets, transformers, bulb, and some casing. The bulbs alone are supremely solid state, often look like all the parts were encased in silicon or epoxy. But the units we buy for 110 fixtures are made up of many parts that have the durabilty of the weakest ling.