Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Cutting tenons question?

Posts

Cutting tenons question?

#1

Cutting tenons question?

Barry Irby

I am making fifty shaker style doors and drawer fronts. I need to cut tenons on the ends of the rails. A lot of them. Would you use a tenon jig and flip and flop scores of pieces or would you use a dado blade and nibble them off with the pieces laying down on the TS?

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#2

Re: Cutting tenons question?

BrianMonumentCO

Are your mortises going to be cut with a router or a mortising machine, ie are tenons expected to be round or square?

If square, I would use a sled/t-square with starting fence for length.

The cut the other edges on a band saw with a fence clamped to the table.

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#3

Re: Cutting tenons question?

Wess

I would make a jig for the plunge router and use loose tenons. Or as much as I hate to say it think about a Dominoe, it really does shine in situations like this. That being said why not the standard cope and stick run on the shaper or router table?

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#4

Re: Cutting tenons question?

David Yoho

Barry, I've always found using the tablesaw with dado blade to be quicker for that many pieces. Too much time consumed with a tenon jig.

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#5

niether works for me

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I find mass producing tenons difficult. The problem is a well fit M&T requires +/- 0.005" or less precision of the joint. Because of varying thickness of the wood, and maybe the phase of the moon, neither of the approaches you propose works for me because the procedure involves using both sides of the board as a reference face. The solution is to come up with a procedure that uses the same reference face for both cuts.

A tenon jig can be used to reference from one face and I find it works for me. Make the first cut as usual. Then insert a spacer board behind the stick to be tenoned that moves the stick over the amount needed to make the tenon thickness and make the second cut. The thickness of this spacer depends on the width of the saw blade and the width of the mortise. I use the same rip blade for this operation. I have spacers made for 1/4, 5/15/ and 1/2" mortises.

This same approach works for band sawing the tenons but I find the precision less.

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#6

Re: Cutting tenons question?

mdclor

I use a router jig and slip/floating tenons. I find this process to be very fast as long as you mill all your stock in one run. A Domino would be my first choice, but I don't make enough M&Ts to justify one.

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#7

Re: niether works for me

Jim Matthews

I haven't made so many at a shot, but have the same project in mind.

Do you have a bandsaw and router?

If the rails are a uniform thickness, set the fence to cut the cheeks off heavy,

about a 64th thicker than the mating mortise.

Set your router to the leave the precise thickness (plus glueline).

I like my tenons to be press fit - so they'll hold without glue.

It's traditional to pin these, so you could drawbore them tight.

FWIW - I intend to make mine with bridle joints, to avoid the mortise.

Testing has shown that the bridle joint is plenty strong for doors, particularly in homes where children are older (or absent).

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#8

Re: Cutting tenons question?

E Snow

Solid advise in the other postings. There are few good options for a 'production' run of doors outside of dedicated machinery. A tenoner being the end all be all, big shaper with a stacked head and a coping sled being #2.

Aside from those a slot mortiser is serviceable but slow in set up and cycle time unless it is a an auto feed unit. Benefit here over the tenoning jig or the nibble is that it manages stock variation as it has a fixed reference datum. Much quicker and perhaps most accommodating and future flexible is the domino which kills the cycle time and set up while maintaining the benefit of stock variation management via a common datum. Have to get creative at times with how best to use the limited size of dominos but generally not enough tenon is easily managed by more than one smaller tenon. So long as the frames don't use stock larger than about 1.75" wide a single standard domino in an 8mm/10mm thickness is more than adequate.

This common datum I have referenced can be accommodated with the tenoning jig but you must stack a pair of blades around a spacer cutting both sides at once. This alone will take care of most the the idiosyncrasies of the woods moving and stock prep so long as your spacer is well matched to your mortise. Set up is a bit of a pain as your are using separate machines for mortise and tenon. Personally, I still would go with a domino or floating tenons via a slot mortiser.

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#9

Re: Cutting tenons question?

William Duffield

I would definitely use my Domino for this job. It would save you a significant amount of time and improve your accuracy.

It might even decrease the amount of poplar you need, depending on the length of the lumber you are starting with, since your stock can be a couple of inches shorter. It drives me crazy when that last piece of stock is a little too long to use the end of the board, and I have to put it in the scrap pile.

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#10

Re: Cutting tenons question?

William Duffield

After your wallet takes the initial hit on the Domino mortiser, you will find all sorts of uses for it, that in the past you would have used a slower, more complicated method that wouldn't have given as strong joints. I never use my hollow chisel mortiser, or my biscuit cutter or my Kreg jig any more.

If I can't exactly match the thickness of the Domino to my stock using the "thirds" rule of thumb, I just go to the next larger Domino. I figure the main reason for the mortise walls to be as thick as the rule says is because of the stress of the mortise chisel or the mortising machine on the stiles. The Domino puts a lot less force on the sides of the stiles, so you can make them thinner, and again increase the strength of the joint. I am not concerned if the thickness of the joint ends up as much as 1/4-1/2-1/4 instead of 1/3-1/3-1/3.

Re: Cutting tenons question?

#11

Re: Cutting tenons question?

Richard McComas

Now that I have the domino I'd say that's the way to go. Prior to have the domino I'd use my shaper with two rebate cutters and a spacer between. This worked well for me.


Re: Cutting tenons question?

#12

I learned two or three things.....

Barry Irby

Well, maybe relearned one of them.

I nibbled them. Both ends of 117 pieces. Not sure how it got to be 117 but I have spent a considerable amount of time befuddled, counting, recounting, making and remaking parts. Should have been better organized with better plans and parts lists. That's a good thing to keep in mind.

I was nibbling away with my rip blade because it cuts a flat bottom kerf. Struggling with a cross cut/miter guage. About a 1/4 of the way into this I broke down and waxed the table. Something I have done many times, but not lately. Must have reduced the effort by about 75%. Huge difference. If you have not waxed yours lately, go do it.

The thing I actually learned was that the rip blade does a fairly good job of cross cutting the shoulder, with very minimal splintering. Then I found that if I laid the piece down flat and fed it forward taking the splintering from the original cross cut to clean up the end and allow the piece to register better on the table and then, with it beyond the blade slide it over to the fence and pull it backwards through the blade it cuts the should even better and cleaner than it does going through the "right" way. This also sped things up. I was nibbling in both directions, back and forth. The improvement in the cut was impressive.

I started cutting out the plywood panels. Befuddlement set in again and I quit for the day. Tomorrow I will assemble doors.