Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Drawer Bottom Engineering

Posts

Drawer Bottom Engineering

#1

Drawer Bottom Engineering

William Duffield

Does anyone know of an application, or spreadsheet, or set of tables and formulas, or other tool, similar to the shelf Sagulator, for plywood drawer bottoms?

For example, I need to build some drawers that will be either 15" x 22" or 14" x 25" and hold at least 22 lbs. (10 kilos).

I need to know what is the minimum thickness of plywood that will work with a reasonable amount of reserve strength. I will use either Baltic birch, Paraply (guatambu) or okume, and plan to glue it into the grooves in the drawer sides for additional stiffness. I know that different species of ply have different bending strengths, so the species is significant. Also, the project will need several shallow drawers, so I don't want to waste vertical space, expense or weight with unnecessarily thick plywood. I'm not concerned about the minimizing the stiffness of the drawer sides, because they will be supplemented by Accuride slides, and I can make the drawer fronts and back as thick as is necessary.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#2

Why not do testing?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Weight distribution is going to be a critical factor. Spread over the surface of the drawer bottom 1/4" anything would do fine but a lead brick in the middle might require something more stiff.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#3

Good read to get you thinking.....

Brian Roberts

http://www.ewp.asn.au/library/downloads/ewpaa_shelving_design_manual.pdf

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#4

Re: Why not do testing?

William Duffield

You can't argue with the validity and utility of doing your own testing, to make sure any unique conditions will be covered.

I figured this is a common enough problem that someone else must have done and published extensive testing on the subject. If it exists, it would save me a lot of time and materials, because I wouldn't need to cut out a bunch of drawer bottoms and set up a dado stack for a bunch of different thicknesses, and wouldn't have drawer sides and bottoms that I couldn't use, and that would add to my "too good for firewood" scrap pile.

If anyone is curious, I'm designing a printer stand. An A-size all-in-one will go on top, a wide carriage ink jet in the top shelf, several reams of paper in different weights and sizes in the lower drawers, and ink cartridges, envelopes, stamps, etc., in the bottom drawer. Obviously (no bricks need apply) and all the loads will be distributed evenly, or all the forces will be all the way at the four corners. I already realized I will be working with the best cases.

My worst case is a ream of 13x19, 32 lb. paper, which weighs two kilos and may be dropped into the drawer from four inches or so.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#5

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

TomD

You probably don't want to glue them in and it is unnecessary anyway. If your sides are real wood then you are just asking for trouble if you use glue as there will be some wood movement even though the drawer is essentially a frame and panel.

1) you want to determine whether you are really concerned with strength or panel stiffness in this app. The stiffness tests are different, and more likely your actual concern. Stiffness is easily measured by deflection over a span. So with something like joists, the engineering data may tell you what span will create a 1-480, 1-360, or 1-240 deflection for a given static load. as the panels deflect in your drawer they start to load the edges of the grooves unevenly promoting failure in that region. So a panel that can stay pretty flat is advantageous. This would seem to be pretty easy to model.

2) Plywoods tend to be available in two quite different types. One, typical of better furniture, boat and aircraft panels will be almost as stiff in the 0 as 90 fiber orientation. Typically these will have many layers of thin plys. Or at the cheaper end, as with underlayment, a thick core, with very thin face veneers. These panels will function best in nearly square drawer bottoms, but one must still be careful to align the fiber with the shortest span

The other type is the often 3 ply material where each ply is the same thickness and therefore the ply is dramatically stiffer in usually the 0 axis. How you orient and contain these plies is critical to performance. Since stiffness varies as to the cube of thickness, relatively minor looking changes in plies can completely change a panel's characteristics. For instance, out of the blue, the underlayment we get is now stiffer in the 90 and not the 0 axis.

Of course this thinking applies to solid wood bottoms also, they are linear fibers with the vast majority of their stiffness in the 0 axis, this can be very powerful in some drawer applications

3) how you engineer the opening is also critical. If you had a drawer that was 48 inches wide and 12 inches deep and you cut the ply so that the 0 axis was front to back in the drawer, but the back of the drawer was open with maybe only a few tacks, that would be a very limp drawer bottom. But the same drawer containing the ply on all 4 sides would be very stiff since the 0 axis is supported over the shortest span (front to back).

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#6

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

Chuck in Mtl.

when is doubt over build the drawer. Instead of this plywood use 1/4 inch birch that cannot break.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#7

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

Joseph Mulherin

I would use double 1/4" hardboard for them bottoms and NOT glue them into the sides. Make the side grooves 3/8" instead if 1/4" for extra stiffness and make the back slide into a groove also. Pin nail the back together to the sides after inserting the bottom into the back groove/no glue.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#8

You are way over thinking this drawer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....and a test.

I just put 25 pounds of #4 shot (I think #6 would be equivalent) in a similar sized drawer with a 5/16" white pine bottom and saw no perceptible deflection. Drawer bottom captured on 3 sides in a dado and screwed to the back with 3 tiny screws.

The test would involve laying 4 equal height strips of wood to outline the drawer on the bench . Add 1/4" plywood and weight. Observe deflection.

Evenly distributed you drawer bottom is experiencing the staggering load of 0.07 pounds per square inch.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#9

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

Richard McComas

My unscientific test say I can put 120 lbs of weight in the middle of a drawer (1/4 Baltic Birch bottom) and have it deflect a little less that 1/4 in. 22 lbs should be a piece of cake.


Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#10

thats what I like to see......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

a shop shot with sawdust on the floor.

BTW, good test.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#11

Re: Good read to get you thinking.....

William Duffield

And that it did! The first important thing I learned was the proper orientation for plywood supported on all four sides. It was not intuitive at first, but makes perfect sense now. The section on wet plywood was also enlightening. However, I could draw no conclusions from the tables and formulas, because OZ structural ratings have no meaning to plywood sold in the U.S. Of course, that's what I think you meant. It will certainly help me analyze what I expect will be a set of disparate answers.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#12

Re: thats what I like to see......

Richard McComas

I did sweep up the area where the drawer is lying on the floor. Next time I won't bother. :)

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#13

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

William Duffield

You probably don't want to glue them in and it is unnecessary anyway.

The reason I thought I wanted to glue them in was to allow me to move the groove closer to the bottom of the drawer sides, hoping that the glue surface between the top of the bottom and the top of the groove would provide some support. But, that's probably not such a good idea, as it wouldn't provide much more support than tacking and gluing the ply to the bottoms of the drawer sides.

you want to determine whether you are really concerned with strength or panel stiffness

I think you are right. Stiffness is probably more important for my app. The Accuride slides I'm planning to use will deliver several times as much strength as I will need.

Plywoods tend to be available in two quite different types.

That's why I'm leaning strong towards using Baltic birch plywood which is of similar stiffness in both directions. Finnish birch and aircraft ply, while even stiffer, are probably more expensive than I need. The 3 mil. okume, 4 mil. okume and lauan doorskin are definitely of the second type, with remarkably different stiffness in different directions. They're not as bendy as wiggle wood, but definitely risky to use in this application.

how you engineer the opening is also critical.

The front, back and both sides will have grooves to hold the plywood. Once it is assembled, it's not coming apart by anyone but me. I will be joining the four framing pieces with dovetails and hide glue, so if some time in the future some "rug rats" try to use it as a ladder, I will be able to fix it. The top drawer will be longer than it is wide, and will slide out one side of the stand, and the other drawers will be wider than they are long and slide out the front, so the grain of all the visible plies will run from the front to the back of the cabinet.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#14

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

William Duffield

I'm not looking for recommendations here on how to overbuild a set of drawers. I am an engineer, so I know how to do that. :D I'm looking for a minimal design that will still meet the requirements, and whose lightness is aesthetically pleasing. I'm not planning to store cold chisels, crowbars, and splitting wedges in it. I have a drawer in a mechanic's rolling tool chest that I use for that purpose. I'm not even looking for drawers that will hold cast iron and bronze bench planes. I've already built a whole chest of those from cabinet grade Guatambu. They are 32" x 29" with 1/4" ply bottoms glued into grooves in the sides. With constant use, they have not failed in 20 years. Since these drawers will be minimally loaded, I'm sure I can go thinner and lighter than that. I just don't know how thin. I shouldn't have to rederive the formulas and rerun the tests on several sheets of plywood, some of which I would destroy in the process, because some engineers, somewhere, have already done the tests and pubished the results, and defined the standards for the plywood, and certified some of the plywood. I'm not talking about Borg plywood here, whose quality decreases over time, until it stops selling, and they find a new, cheaper product to replace it. I watched that happen with Guatambu, but luckily I bought mine when it was newly introduced and worked well. A good current example is their Baltic birch, which is not nearly of the quality of the product carried by Woodcraft, et. al.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#15

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

Sgian Dubh

"For example, I need to build some drawers that will be either 15" x 22" or 14" x 25" and hold at least 22 lbs. (10 kilos).

I need to know what is the minimum thickness of plywood that will work with a reasonable amount of reserve strength."

William, I suspect an engineering approach involving formulae, spreadsheets, and the like, isn't really necessary. The drawer dimensions you've described aren't large, and the planned load is only 22 lbs. I bet you could use 3/16" thick plywood for that purpose, especially if the load is spread out fairly evenly over the drawer bottom. My recommendation is to base your decision on copying existing examples, using something that approximately matches what's been commonly used in the past, and has held up well enough.

That would lead you to using 1/4" thick plywood for the drawer bottoms in the drawers you describe. They're almost certain to be over-engineered, only 1/16" thicker than 3/16", and probably cheaper too, because 1/4" thick material is such a common size, readily available, whereas 3/16" stuff is somewhat rarer, and a bit harder to track down. Slainte.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#16

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

William Duffield

Nope, I don't pin drawers together. All four corners will be dovetailed, and I'll use hide glue for added integrity. I've repaired too many drawers where the citizen who built it took shortcuts. My typical practice is to through dovetail the back and half blind the front. On this one, however, I'll be using Accuride full extension drawer slides, so I can easily get all the way to the backs of the drawers. Since I need to cover a half inch of hardware on each side, I'll through dovetail the front to the sides, too, and screw and glue a decorative false drawer front to the structural front of each box.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#17

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

Barry Irby

I just bought 5mm underlayment from the orange Borg to use as panels in my cabinet doors and as drawer bottoms. Its birch (I think) and has a nearly clear face and a knotty face and because its underlayment, it does not have interior voids, I hope. The stuff is less than $13 a sheet, but being the cheap SOB I am, I bought all the damaged sheets for half price.

I am confident it will support 22 pounds without a problem.

Whatever 5mm is, its pretty darn close to 3/16".

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#18

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

TomD

3/16 is usually translated a 4. Which means your 5 is 125/64 x stiffer. That's the beauty, what does 1mm of veneer over a drawer bottom add in weight of visual weight, yet it is twice as stiff. Next, make sure the fiber orientation is good and you are ready to go.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#19

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

TomD

Sounds like you are on track!

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#20

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

TomD

What I should have said though, is that on maybe small drawers, getting the right groove may require a thinner ply, and at that size of drawer the thinner ply may be perfectly acceptable. But other than that, the thicker stuff might be useful.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#21

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

TomD

"I shouldn't have to rederive the formulas and rerun the tests on several sheets of plywood, some of which I would destroy in the process, because some engineers, somewhere, have already done the tests and pubished the results, and defined the standards for the plywood, and certified some of the plywood."

One thing not helpful at the moment, but probably worthwhile over time is to forget the engineers, and just open some drawers. Antiques that have survived the test of time can have some great lessons, not least of all how to use solid wood in drawer bottoms. Also, their smaller drawers are often about the weight of a cigar box, diminutive dimension one rarely sees in modern work. I don't own such things, but some of my family do, and I enjoy poking around in there to see what they are made of, with their permission.

I also like looking at picnic shelters in national parks, or for that mater any exposed structures, one local vegetable stand. In many cases these would not pass modern code, but it is interesting to acquire scantlings for possible sheds, extensions, or workshops in the future.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#22

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

William Duffield

Well, Yes and no.

I was hoping for a general solution, tables or a spreadsheet, so I wouldn't have to experiment or overbuild to save time every time in the future that I needed to design a new drawer for a new application. I don't think that's going to happen, mostly because the plywood itself is a "moving target."

OTOH, I got enough information to be pretty confident that since the loading will be very light, the 3 mil (~1/8") okume will suffice, and if I dry assemble one drawer and change my mind, I can recut the grooves and replace it with 4 mil. I'll be using straight grain quarter sawn tulip poplar drawer sides, so if I decide it still doesn't feel stiff enough, I should be able to glue it in. I'll also be using hide glue, so if I need to redo it for any reason, I can easily take it apart.

The okume is marine grade, for small dingy hulls and decking. I have enough in stock, and can get more from Harbor Sales or Chesapeake light craft.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#23

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

Richard McComas

BTW

There's also aircraft plywood avaialble in thin pieces that I believe is pretty strong.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#24

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

William Duffield

Yes, aircraft plywood is even stronger than this stuff. It is also without voids, with several plies, so it is the very close to the same stiffness in both directions. Using it, I could either make the drawer bottoms even thinner, or with the same thickness make them much stronger. An additional advantage is it is made from closed grain hardwoods, usually birch, instead of the open grained okume, and therefore easier to finish. The disadvantage is that it is quite a bit more expensive.

Another option is door skin, usually made from lauan or other Philippine "mahogany" (Shorea species). I have worked with some examples that are reinforced with fiberglass strands glued between the layers of veneer.

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

#25

Re: Drawer Bottom Engineering

TomD

My trimaran and catamaran are built out of Luan doorskins. I think they even managed to get some charter cats past the USCG that were built out of door skins. Unfortunately it has been a long time since I have seen any with waterproof glue, not that that matters in this case. Luan has a nasty smell though. Birch is better for that. Around here there are 5x5 Birch panels that aren't aircraft quality, in 1/8th, but they are pretty good, I do a lot of patterns in the stuff. Forget what they cost, but it isn't bad. 12 bucks.

I wouldn't tell an engineer what to think, but the luan weighs about .3 pounds a square foot, so the 4mm weighs about .4. So on a 1 square foot drawer bottom 1.6 additional oz will get you more than twice the stiffness, what not to like about that.