Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Waterborne lacquer

Posts

Waterborne lacquer

#1

Clint Searl

Waterborne lacquer

Clint Searl

My clear finish of choice has always been a one part solvent lacquer, either NC or CAB acrylic, but am considering a waterborne instead. General's water based lacquer is what I'm leaning toward. Is that a good choice? I assume I may have to replace the tip and/or the needle in my guns.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#2

Re: Waterborne lacquer

don stephan

For clarity, you might want to name the specific General Finishes product you are considering. I have seen at different times all the various types of water borne finishes called lacquers, and the different types are not the same. I very seldom spray any more, but the last few years I did I used General Finishes products exclusively and was always happy with the performance of the product and the customer service.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#3

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Waterborne lacquer

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

My preference is Target's EM6000 waterborne lacquer.

I've used the General Finishes stuff, and it works well, too. Probably just a matter of personal preference.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#4

Re: Waterborne lacquer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Had very good results with Target's EM6000, but my go-to finish is General's Enduro Clear Poly.

A note on waterbornes, seal your piece with shellac to prevent grain rise.. 2 coats of 1 lb cut with a light sand in between to remove fuzzies, then 3 coats of the top coat.

I use a 1.0 tip in my HVLP guns

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#5

Re: Waterborne lacquer

mdclor

Clint, I have also used Target's EM6000 with good results. I find it to be very easy and forgiving to use in terms of ambient temperature and humidity. I like it a lot. Unfortunately, it isn't readily available locally in most areas of the country and shipping can make it cost prohibitive. I think you can use a needle up to 1.5, but 1.2 or 1.3 would be better.

I asked about a substitute for EM6000 on Jeff Jewitt's site and he indicated that he had heard good things about SW Kem Aqua Plus, but that he hadn't used it personally. I asked about it at my local SW store and the employee wasn't aware of it, so Kem Aqua might be hard to find.

http://oem.sherwin-williams.com/products/wood/sher-wood-kem-aqua-plus

General Finishes generally get good reviews but I haven't ever used them.

Finally, depending on your application, you might consider adding a cross linker to the product to make the final finish more durable.

http://targetcoatings.com/products/additives/series-cl100-cross-linker/

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#6

Target vs. General

GolfSteve in Calgary

Can anyone give a list of the differences between spraying General and Target finishes?

I've used Target in the past with good results. It does burn in 100% and I've never had any problems with witness lines. I have to mail-order the stuff, and I always seem to do my finishing in the winter when I don't want to ship waterborne laquer from Saskatoon in -40 weather.

I've never used General finishes, but the Internet says it's good stuff, and I can buy it a 5 minute walk from my office at Lee Valley Tools.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#7

Re: Target vs. General

mdclor

Michael Dresdner used to drop by here on occasion maybe he will see this and share his expertise. (Ellis, can you facilitate??? :) )

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#8

Re: Waterborne lacquer

Richard McComas

Mark, I kind of have to laugh at recommending shellac to Clint. If you have ever read his post on other forums you'd know that Clint vehemently opposes the use of shellac for anything.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#9

He'll Change His Tune

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If he tries to use waterborne finishes on raw wood. Alan Young here has first hand experience.

Water-based finishes will raise the grain but not sand off like shellac. The result is a finish film with tiny fibers proud of the surface that kill the optical depth of the coating. Two spit coats of dewaxed shellac (one as a sanding sealer, second as final sealer) prepare the surface to get the full brightness and depth the waterbornes can produce.

Shellac is even more important if you stain, because waterbornes tend to pull pigments (or dye particles) out of the wood making the finish film muddy.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#10

Clint Searl

Re: He'll Change His Tune

Clint Searl

Mark, you answered my question before I even had time to ask it. If I go to a waterborne, I'll (initially at least) stick with my usual schedule of using the top coat as the initial/sealer coat, and knock down the fuzz that raises. With solvent lacquer that works and eliminates any reason to use shellac. If shellac "really" is necessary, I could well lose interest in waterbornes. BTW, a guy I know does great work going straight to Minwax water based poly that he sprays.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#11

Clint Searl

Re: Waterborne lacquer

Clint Searl

Thanks for all the informative replies. Food for thought. I'm still leaning toward solvent lacquers.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#12

Re: Waterborne lacquer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Clint, I find that waterbornes tend to pucker the raw wood surface in addition to raising loose fibers. The result is that the reflective ability of the surface is changed. Shellac will raise fibers as well, but they are easily cut with fresh paper. The 2nd coat of shellac ( talking 1/2 - 3/4 lb. cut stuff) restores the reflective surface for a deep, rich film from the top coating. I also get much better leveling of the waterborne film when it goes on over a sealed surface.

I've used several that were KCMA approved as "self-sealing" but they didn't compare with a surface pre-sealed with shellac. You could, I suppose, use solvent lacquer as your base sealer, but I'd have qualms about how long to allow the lacquer to dry before top coating. Alcohol won't mess with the waterbornes' tail solvent chemistry, but can't say the same for residual lacquer thinner.

The other advantage is that I can use the shellac as a toner with TransTint concentrate to "kick" the wood color to match an existing piece. I mix shellac in small fresh batches for every job and rarely have any to store. Never keep it more that 4 months.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#13

Re: Waterborne lacquer

mdclor

I am certain that Mark's comments relative to shellac or no shellac are correct, but I have used EM6000 for years without shellac and have been perfectly satisfied with the results. That is probably because I have never done a side by side comparison. My point is that it isn't absolutely essential to go the shellac route to get an acceptable product. FWIW

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#14

No Absolutes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Scraps and shorts are an excellent way to do a bit of testing to see how a particular finish routine (shellac yes/no, water/solvent/oil) will work on a given piece. The finish is, of course, the last step in the "making", and it's what everyone sees. There's a big difference, however, between just "making it shiny" and "bringing out the beauty" of the material. If we spend all this time in the cutting, fitting, sanding, etc. but then short-cut "finishing" I think we sell ourselves and our efforts short.

I look to make the most of what I do in the shop so that a year down the road I don't look at a piece and say "that could have been done better if I'd spent a bit more time."

Peace ;)

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#15

Clint Searl

Re: Waterborne lacquer

Clint Searl

Multiple coats of shellac just to prep the surface for a speculative incremental improvement in appearance doesn't offer the ROI that I'm interested in, frankly. I'll give Target a try, or stick with CAB Acrylic.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#16

Clint Searl

Re: Waterborne lacquer

Clint Searl

I also like to play with metallics, micas, and candy additives, which solvent lacquers readily accommodate.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#17

Go To The Horse

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Call Jeff Weiss at Target (he's the prez and head chemist) and pose your questions. Nice guy. 800-752-9922

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#18

Re: Target vs. General

Michael Dresdner

General Finishes recently bought a well established and well liked line of waterbased coatings that was sold under the name Enduro. Like all General Finishes, it is well formulated and a very good product. It is, and always was, aimed at the small user and DIY market, so it is designed to be user friendly. I doubt you will have any problems with it.

Target is somewhat different. They are a bit more focused on the professional field. You will see more options from them and also coatings more aligned with the style of finishing you see in larger professional shops. As for quality, Target would be hard to beat. Jeff, Target's owner and chemist, is a top notch formulator and the products they offer are excellent.

If there are things you want (such as various types of cross linked waterbased coatings) that you can not find through General, then Target would be a great source. On the other hand, General is much easier to find in local distribution outlets, like Rockler and Woodcraft.

As I've said before, everything in finishing involves trade offs -- even buying the stuff.

Bottom line: If we are talking about quality and reliability, this thread has managed to name two of the very best, and either is an excellent choice.

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#20

Re: Target vs. General

mdclor

Thanks, Michael, and I suspect, Ellis. :)

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#21

Re: Waterborne lacquer

Thomas S Stockton

Clint

The other thing to do is sign up for their email list they have monthly discount codes that usually cover a good chunk of the shipping cost.

Tom

Re: Waterborne lacquer

#22

Clint Searl

Re: Waterborne lacquer

Clint Searl

Thanks, Tom. I expect a delivery of EM6000 tomorrow. I'll sign up for the future.