Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

scms accuracy

Posts

scms accuracy

#1

scms accuracy

Jerry Gibbs

I still have my Sears radial arm saw. One of the knocks was that accuracy was constantly an issue, since the table/fence would get out of square with the blade. Is this an issue with most sliding compound mitre saws? Is it a question of money? When the blade is extended far from the fence, does the accuracy remain? It seems to me the more things extend and move, the more chance there is for error. Any experiences welcomed. Jerry

Re: scms accuracy

#2

Re: scms accuracy

John K Jordan

Want another Sears RAS to keep yours company?

I don't have experience with a variety of SCMS, just one. I bought this when starting on my shop and used it for several years now in the shop. My experience is the accuracy is quite good and has not changed with use. I REALLY like the mechanism which uses clever pivots and avoids rails sticking out the back of the saw.

http://www.amazon.com/Bosch-GCM12SD-120-Volt-12-Inch-Glide/dp/B004323NNC

I got mine from a big box store which matched the Amazon price I showed the clerk on my phone.

JKJ

Re: scms accuracy

#3

Re: scms accuracy

John in NM

I have an old 8 1/2" Hitachi, seems plenty accurate even after years of use. I prefer smaller bladed SCMS's as I've found the deflection of a dull blade to be more of a problem than the mechanism itself.

If extreme accuracy is desired, a table saw and sled (and a sharp blade) are probably the best bet.

Re: scms accuracy

#4

Re: scms accuracy

Dick Coers

I've never used a Festool, so can't say that throwing the most money at it will get you more accuracy. What I have found is money spent on the blade is not wasted. Some big saws don't do well taking a skim cut off the edge. It will deflect the blade, or show you some play in the machine. For the highest accuracy for furniture work, I've always preferred a sliding jig on the table saw.

Re: scms accuracy

#5

Re: scms accuracy

mdclor

Jerry, I have a 10" Hitachi that has been very accurate for me. I cut the 11" miter for this sofa and there is no gap whatsoever. I'm sorry that it doesn't show up better. FWIW


Re: scms accuracy

#6

Re: scms accuracy

Mike Van Pelt

I own a Festool and have two at the school we use dailey. The most accurate, easest to use, and dust collection is some what better than most SCMS. I do realize that they are expensive...but darn are they nice.

mike from CU Woodshop

Re: scms accuracy

#7

Re: scms accuracy

JoeW, Detroit

That's a nice looking saw. I have a couple of Bosch routers, a jigsaw, and orbital sander and like them all. How good is the dust collection at the scms?

Re: scms accuracy

#8

Re: scms accuracy

john lucas

I bought a high end Craftsman radial saw a few years ago on a really good deal just to see if I would like one. I always had the same accuracy problems you had. I sold it and bought a Makita 10" sliding miter saw. I'm very happy with the accuracy. I do segmented turning work with it and the accuracy seems excellent.

Re: scms accuracy

#9

Re: scms accuracy

Dave Paine

I had a Craftsman radial arm saw for a few decades. I found that if I moved the arm off 90 deg, it would return "close" but not to the exact original position.

I ended up calibrating the blade to be 90 deg to the fence, locked the arm and did not move the arm off 90 deg.

Moving the carriage between inward and outward locations did not change the angle.

I eventually gave the saw away. I purchased a SCMS and found it more repeatable in positions.

I now have the same Bosch Glider as JKJ. It is accurate at 90 deg - as long as you check that the fence did not move during transportation. I had to tweak mine slightly. A couple of screws. Just use a good square to set the fence.

Rotating the SCMS horizontally is normally more accurate than tilting the saw due to the larger scale on the base than on the back of the saw. I find it I need to tilt the saw, I check the angle and may need to tweak the setting.

Dust collection on the Bosch Glider is much improved than my earlier SCMS, but even with the shop vac connected to the nozzle on the Glider, I get a good amount of dust around the saw. It is really difficult to trap all the dust as the blade cuts.