Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Question about seasonal wood movement

Posts

Question about seasonal wood movement

#1

Question about seasonal wood movement

Yonak

Plywood is made of thin cross-grain layers of solid wood. Veneer is a thin solid wood sheet glued to a stable substrate. There is no concern about wood movement (separating or buckling of the solid wood sheets) in either of these cases.

On the other hand, when one attaches sections of thicker woods cross-grain, such as breadboard end of a table, the concern, and the reality is that the wide panel will move counter to the end piece.

What's the difference ? Apparently it's the thickness of the solid panels. If I were to glue a solid 3/8" panel to a substrate would it move and detach ? What if it were a 1/4" panel or a 1" panel ? How thin does veneer have to be to not move ?

Is it that thinner wood doesn't move or that, being thin, it doesn't have the muscle to overcome the glue ? Where's the breaking point ?

Has anyone thought about this and come to any conclusions ?

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#2

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

Barry Irby

I think you are thinking in the right direction. At least raising some good questions. The American Plywood Association (APA) or the Forest Products Laboratory might have some good info.

I don know that OSB gives the hardwood flooring industry fits. It turns out that OSB is not as dimensionally stable as plywood, particularly in width. Apparently The somewhat random orientation of the flakes does not "lock down" the width as well as plywood. The sheets would shrink a bit after they were installed and allowed to dry thoroughly. (Probably got wet during construction) For several years the Hardwood manufacturers would not stand behind flooring installed on OSB. Demanded plywood sub-straight. Apparently the plywood manufacturers 'plained things to them and we see hardwood over OSB regularly now.

The problem was "rafting" or "panelization". Install hardwood over slightly damp OSB after allowing the hardwood to acclimate tot he slightly damp condition. Then turn on the HVAC and add winter and both of them shrink. You get a fairly significant crack every four feet. Each panel and each board shrink, but the panels carry the hardwood with it, so the cracks in the hardwood tend to accumulate at the joints in the OSB

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#3

Kneale Brownson

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

Kneale Brownson

I don't know any builders who think OSB should be laid flat!!! Only plywood should go under any flooring.

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#4

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

Keith Newton

Breadboard ends aren't glued on. There is a tongue and groove, or tenons which allow the middle to expand and contract, while the BB ends keep it from cupping.

About 1/16" for a face veneer is my limit.

Has anyone thought of this? To answer your question would take a book length answer, so since you ask, I would suggest you get a copy of Bruce Hoadley's Book "Understanding Wood" since you are curious.

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#5

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

AZ in Colorado Springs

I would think that the "layers" of adhesive spread on the plies also inhibit the passage of moisture through the sheet of plywood. Added to the thinness of the plies and the presence of adhesive throughout (acting as as adhesive in this case) the sheet acts like more a solid piece of something else rather than a board

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#6

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

George Koch

3/4" T&G OSB sheets are commonly used by builders today. Georgia Pacific Sturd-I-floor and Weyerhaeuser Edge Gold Floor Panels are both recommended as subfloors under hardwood strip flooring.

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#7

You missed a few things

Mark Hennebury

Plywood is always made of odd numbers of veneer so that they are balanced. As the veneers are layered over the center veneer, the grain direction species and thickness is the same. Any stress from moisture movement is the same on both sides to maintain a balanced pressure. If you add moisture to one side of a sheet of plywood it will warp. If you apply finish to one side of plywood it also can warp.


As to how thick you can make veneers; i am not sure that you can nail that down exactly as there are many variables; Wood species; some are very pliable and some are very brittle, Cut type; rift, quartered, flat, Size, Substrate, finish, and atmospheric conditions. Very thick veneer will probably crack due to the exposed surface cells reacting to atmospheric changes and the glued surfaced not.

But as a general rule with panel stock ( solid or man-made): whatever you do to one side, do to the other. Panels have to be balanced to be stable, materials and moisture content

You can stabilize solid wood by applying veneer layers to each side to make stable panels, called Block-board. But attaching a breadboard end wont stop a solid table from seasonal movement.


Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#8

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

Yonak

Keith, when I asked, "Has anyone thought of this ?" I guess I was thinking of those that may respond .. someone who frequents this forum. I'm certain people have studied this and wondered if anyone here had learned anything on the matter. I appreciate the book recommendation. That's certainly a book I need on my bookshelf.

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#9

Re: You missed a few things

Yonak

Thanks for the thoughtful response, Mark. Yes, I'm aware that what's done to one side of a panel must be done to the other.

I never thought about stabilizing solid wood by applying veneer to each side. I assume you mean cross-grain veneering. It's valuable information. Will it really keep the movement in check for a wide solid panel ?

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#10

Re: You missed a few things

Mark Hennebury

Hi Yonak,

They make fullsize 48" x 96" panels out of the blockboard construction, it has several crossbanded veneers on each side, so basically thin plywood on each side, with a decorative face veneer. I haven't used them myself, so i don't know for sure what they are like, but i have seen them around for many years, so i would guess that they are quite stable.

Mark Hennebury

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#11

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

don stephan

The general recommendation I've always seen is that veneer thicker than about 1/16" starts to act like solid wood. I interpret that to mean veneer thicker than about 1/16", glued to MDF or plywood, may have problems during seasonal expansion and contraction.

My understanding is that a single layer veneer glued to a solid wood substrate should have its grain running in the same direction as the solid wood. And ideally the veneer and the solid wood substrate are the same so they will have the same expansion and contraction rate.

A gentleman I know repairs furniture, occasionally including pieces with veneer on solid wood substrate. Even when the substrate was quartered wood, after a hundred years or more the glue joints in the substrate form cracks in the veneer. Often in those old pieces the veneer and substrate are not the same species of wood, for what it's worth.

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#12

Re: You missed a few things

Dick Coers

Pretty sure solid core is all quarter sawn. Then the seasonal change is vertical instead of across the sheet.

Re: Question about seasonal wood movement

#13

not exactly correct..

Mark Hennebury

Quartersawn wood still moves across the width of the board, just not as much as in the vertical/ thickness.

There are many different panel materials these days that seem to prove that wood movement can be contained in panels in variety of thicknesses and layers.