Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

Posts

Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#1

Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics. 

Gary Smyth

This weekend I found this rocking horse in a loft of yet another barn. Carved solid hardwood horse and softwood rockers. About 51” in total length and 31” at the top of ear. Weighs a good 30+ lbs. From what is visible the various parts have been glued and pinned using regular finishing nails. I’m told that the former owner was an artist and probably made or purchased the horse in the 1950’s -- at least that’s what a relative remembers. The horse has damage which the pictures show.

The break in the rocker can be easily replaced if to be painted, or alternatively detached, separated, doweled and glued if to be left unpainted. What I don’t know what or how to do is reverse the botched glue, Bondo/wood filler that was used to ”repair” the horse in times past.

I don’t want to damage any of the carving. Is there a solvent that can get rid of the old repair stuff? The more important damage is the head/neck split which is rock solid on the body. Someone, maybe the artist or her kids made repairs before it was taken away and forgotten in the loft, which was rarely (if ever)visited and hot as blazes there when found.

The question is how to remedy? The splits on the horse chest are probably moisture related, been there for who knows how long but do I leave them or fill? Epoxy? I’d like to fit the head more closely to the body but I don’t want to make matters worse. I can’t see how it is attached. A knife blade run around the void does not hit any metal. Any fill will be obvious, but I hope better than what is there now. Is a carousel style painted horse something you would consider? Perhaps just some combination of beeswax and oil if to be left unpainted. Opinions and suggestions?


Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#2

current thinking....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...in the antique conservation field is to not do anything that can not be reversed at some later date as fashion, technology, value, etc changes.

Step 1 in the adventure. Live with what you have in hand for a while as the minds considers possibilities and goals.

There is no solvent for bondo. A strong solvent, for example a paint stripper that contains methylene chloride, will soften if not dissolve most anything. Softened the stuff may yield to scraping.

It is likely that the head is carved from a separate piece of wood from the body.

What you want to do with this horse needs to be decided before you do anything other than the repairs to stabilize it, for example the rocker. Personally I like the color as it is. If you are going to paint it begin with a barrier layer of shellac so that the paint can come off at some later date if desirable.

Oil may undesirably darken it. Before I did anything major I would see what a rub down of wax with 4/0 wool would look like to clean it.

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#3

Re: Opinion.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I think I'd get some walnut shell media and blast off the bondo and other garbage repairs made.

Then, since this is a unique piece, I would do nothing more. Cracks and open joints are a natural consequence of the material. It will never be an "in-use" rocker again, but it's inherent value as a sculpture (which may be substantial in the right "market") will be preserved.

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#4

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

fredhargis

Oh, wow! What a niece piece. I think the advice to wait and think it through would be a good thing to do.

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#5

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

walta

I think you should find an expert and pay them for an opinion.

Until you are certain what you have and what it is worth you should do nothing.

Should it turn out you have an original carousel horse carved by a master anything you do will only lower its value.

Should it turn out you have a failed attempted copy by an amateur domed from the start because the stock was still too wet. Bondo and paint may be a good choice.

Walta

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#6

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

Larry

Try this place http://carouselworkshop.com/

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#7

Thanks.

Gary Smyth

Thanks to all that commented. I'll check out sites. I’m working two paths. One is to make things better for the piece, and the other is to find out if I have something other than a jettisoned barn find. I have time. I’ve done nothing but dust it, remove the webs and remnants of the horsehair tail, and take pictures. I have it inside in my garage and am going to let it react to a different less harsh environment for at least the next several weeks. I have no intention of selling it, thus far I have very little involved, and am willing to wait for input, and look for similar designs from internet photos. Painting the horse is not of much interest at this time, and I would only consider it if there was a similar rocking horse out there that was painted. As mentioned, this was a barn discovery and at first sight I thought it was not wood. Once I got up close, clearly it is not. I have searched for any sign of initials or signature but so far, no sign. I don't see any clue in the "tooling" of the harness and the two front legs are carved differently and I thought that might mean something….but who knows. (I even looked inside the mouth, which as the saying goes. you should never do) If anyone has an inkling or knows of anyone who might be able to shed more light please keep me in mind, post as a reply or to me privately and I’ll take it from there. Thanks all.

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#8

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

Keith Newton

Cool find. I'm not so sure that is Bondo, I think it may be one of those old fillers like Rock Hard wood filler, which came in a powder mixed with water. Or maybe even one of the shellac base fillers that come in several wood tones. Due to the fast drying, may give some insight to the poor job of smoothing it out.

As for the broken rocker, like most, I think it is best to try to keep all parts original, but then not broken is always better. If you can get it apart, and clean all the wrong glue that was used over the years, and extract the nails, to where you have some bare wood again. I would clamp it between two other boards, then use a router to cut a slot from the bottom to accept a spline internally.

I like to glue these ragged breaks back together with epoxy that I have filled with wood flower that I've saved from different colored species, until I've got a good color match slightly darker than the base wood. If the outside is covered with masking tape, cut back to allow the excess to smash out of the crack, it can be left slightly high, then carefully trimmed down flush, looking like a dark vein in the grain in the end.

I have a friend and client who is the conservator of the historic carousel at the LR Zoo. She has been caring for all those horses for many years. I can get you in touch with her, maybe for advice, and good products. She is really an expert on getting most of the historic buildings around here back to the original colors, when they are taken to that level.

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#9

Ditto Bills input and...

Grant in Iowa

Gary,

From your description, the horse has been stored in what is effectively a solar kiln for a very long time. I would ensure that it get stored in a humidity stable space, such as an air conditioned home starting now and going forward. As the horse begins to regain moisture to "normal levels", some of the cracks might tighten up. Given that you said it is solid wood, we're talking years for it to reach equilibrium. The old rule of thumb is a year per inch of thickness, but I have heard people say that isn't long enough.

Once it has reached equilibrium with the air in the space in which it will "live", only then begin looking at making repairs. You may find that a juxtaposition of grain in the parts is why the neck opened up as shown in the photo, and that it might just close back up on its own. If you were to fill the void now, and the piece picks up moisture, you might be causing a crack elsewhere.

If you believe the object is or will be around indefinitely, ensure you "do no harm" with your repairs. Consider not cleaning it with solvents or strippers, as much of the value of antiques lies in having the original finish or "patina". If, on the other hand, this is an incomplete/ unfinished work, you could justify adding finish or paints to complete it. If you decide to go that route, I would think about using what was available at the time it was carved. Varnishes and Shellac come to mind, with the former being preferred if it will be used by a kid.

Finally, if it is to become a child's toy, then consider either Varnish or other more durable of the modern finishes that would hold up to the use and abuse. There are some catalyzing finishes available that marine stores and industrial suppliers sell, for example. These might be an option if painting is the plan.

I'm sure others here can provide better advice if you can figure out what the planned use is going forward.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#10

Might be a clue in what type of wood it is

Grant in Iowa

Gary,

One more thing. Can you tell what the wood is? From my chair it is hard to tell.

My thinking is that if it is an exotic like Philippine Mahogany, then there is a chance that it was carved overseas somewhere. I recall seeing Mahogany rocking horses offered for sale at the shops outside Clark Air Base in the Philippines in the 80's. of course, Mahogany has been widely imported, so it isn't a sure thing.

I would say that if it is a domestic, then it was likely carved by a craftsman here.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#11

Taking it slow

Gary Smyth

Grant,

Several points.

1. I'm assuming that it was carved domestically and is not foreign. Not that it couldn't be foreign, but I'm leaning here. It does not appear porous as mahogany might be. More like poplar. The rockers are pine but the body is of denser stuff

2. It is now in a garage where the "weather" is less harsh. Did not want to take it directly to full AC conditions. It can rest there through the autumn.

3. I have been checking books and the head and the body were hardly ever carved as one piece. The information was that the head was largely carved and a canted dowel was placed generally following the neck line, and then into the body. The bottom connection was then carved to blend the pieces. The split fits that description. If so the removal of the head to refit it as originally set in line may be a challenge. I'll wait for additional information.

4. Until I have more information I will make no adjustments. I'm past family for me to turn it into, or at this time, return it to be, a child's toy. Until I find out one way or another I'm treating it as sculpture. It still could be a commercial piece, incomplete (as the are no holes for leather stirrups or reins), or folk art. Thanks for the reply

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#12

The worthless rule of thumb

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The old rule of thumb is a year per inch of thickness, but I have heard people say that isn't long enough. "

This worthless guideline greatly overestimates drying times. This horse is essentially a chunk of firewood (in terms of grain orientation). Does it take decades to dry fireplace logs?

Given the nature of the piece carved, drying is going to mainly occur out the end grain unless it is sealed. If sealed, then indeed it may take a year or two to equilibrate.

Re: Opinion. Carved Horse. Many pics.

#13

Dale Lenz

A suggestion

Dale Lenz

While waiting to decide what to do and allowing the wood to adjust to the humidity, I would blow the dust out of the wood cracks the best I could. When some of the fine cracks close up, you won't have traps dirt.