Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Circuit Breaker ?

Posts

Circuit Breaker ?

#1

Circuit Breaker ?

mdclor

Is it acceptable to use a circuit breaker as an on-off switch for a 240v tool on a dedicated circuit? The tool in question is a dust collector that I tend to use for long periods of time (maybe 45 minute stretches) without turning it on and off. Thanks.

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

#2

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

Barry Irby

No. Circuit breakers are designed for a certain number of cycles and are not intended to serve as switches. Not a bad idea to cycle them once in a while, but not several times a day.

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

#3

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

Keith Newton

I have done it, and it works fine in that the snap in and off quickly without arcing, while still giving some overload protection. However it could pose a hazard on some tools, like a table saw, if the power went off, then someone didn't know and tried to change the blade when the power came back on. A magnetic switch does protect against that. But a dust collector probably doesn't have any hazard that I can think of.

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

#4

Re: Circuit Breaker ? *LINK*

walta

The code says no.

If the motor has an internal overload a leviton MS302 can be had for $35.00

If the motor needs protection you need something else.

Walta


leviton MS302

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

#5

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

Dave Bair

I have seen circuit breakers that are rated for service as switches.

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

#6

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Most definitely yes, Circuit breakers can be used as on off switches according to the NEC.

I know from experience that they have no problem being switched on and off. A place I worked used the circuit breakers to turn off power to machines and lights at night for over 25 years and never had a circuit breaker failure. They had at least 100 breakers that were turned on and off every workday for over 25 years.

Lee

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

#7

Leviton MS302

John K Jordan

This 30 amp Leviton ("suitable as motor disconnect") is what I use for both my 5hp dust collector and 5hp air compressor. Very solid. I want to disconnect them right by the machines, not over in the breaker box - especially if there are other breakers and any chance of flipping the wrong one.

They are currently about $22 on Amazon.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002MPQ51O

JKJ

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

#8

Alternative

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Although it has been said what I do doesn't work well I have done it for many years on 220 V as well as 110 V machines. Buy the best double pole toggle switch ("light switch") you can at Lowes and use it. I have used this on up to 2 HP motors reliably for years.

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

#9

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

mdclor

I appreciate the responses; I will order the Leviton switch. :)

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

#10

Re: Circuit Breaker ?

walta

Please do read the label on the dust collectors motor.

Look for the words “thermally protected” If you can’t find it please post a photo of the motors label.

This switch may or may not be the correct device for your motor.

Walta