Re: How low can we go? - the numbers
TomD
Russ
"At some point it seems it woudl be more honest to just sell it labeled correctly and priced accordingly and let us choose to use the new thinner stuff."
John
"In an industry that thrives on writing, applying, and checking codes, I marvel that this sort of thing is tolerated."
I think these ideas may be connected. When they sell a stamped and rated panel as 5/8, they are saying you can install that where your plans call for 5/8. Reducing a panel all the way from 5/8 to 1/2 reduces the strength about 40% and it almost halves the stiffness. So how can they do that (or nearly that)? Presumably because they have new testing methods/data and all importantly new standards of construction to deal with.
When I look at older houses, and newer houses, the spans between joist/studs and rafters are tighter on the newer houses, pretty much everything is 16" while 24 was relatively common at one time. These days people want more house and amenities, not a single squeak, and all that jazz. So even though there are wood efficient methods of building that are promoted, when it comes to actually building decent houses, people want the backing for all the crap they hang on the walls, the certified quiet floors, the stick trusses not piece framing, and so on. The end result is that houses are enormously overbuilt so it actually makes sense to reduce the panel thickness. Or that might be part of it. The profit motive is only going to be good so far, this stuff is rated. Does HD want to have to pay off every home lost in a hurricane?
So for instance assume your rafters are set at 16 not 24 to maintain the same strength in the panel you could probably drop the thicknes to 1/2 (root of 1.5). To do the same on stiffness which is probably the main point, would be maybe 9/16