1st goo PLANE
Russ
I am considering purchasing my first good plane for general purpose shop work. small to med.project sizes and mostly from hardwood.
any helpful recommendations on a type of plane and mfg would be appreciated.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
1st goo PLANE
Russ
I am considering purchasing my first good plane for general purpose shop work. small to med.project sizes and mostly from hardwood.
any helpful recommendations on a type of plane and mfg would be appreciated.
Re: 1st goo PLANE
Dave Bair
A #4 is a good, basic plane. You can pick up good used ones by Stanley. If you want new, you might want to try Lee Valley's Veritas line. They also offer a series of "bevel-up" planes that have fewer moving parts. I have their low-angle smoother (cat#05P25.01) with two blades sharpened at two different angles so that I can use it for end grain as well as with the grain. It also makes an excellent shooting plane.
Re: 1st good PLANE
JL
Second the Veritas line of planes. If you can't (or don't want to) afford the Lie-Nielsen line of planes - the Veritas are good planes.
I am not knocking the Stanley planes, I have a couple of those - but IMO, the Veritas are better.
First plane recommendation
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
1. Buy a bevel down plane so you can take advantage of the cap iron effect. See Articles Section if cap iron effect has no meaning. Employing the cap iron effect will made the plane greatly more useful to you. (it mitigates tear-out)
2. With good reason Stanley sold lots of #4 and # 5 planes. You will find passionate advocates for each size. I have both but rarely use the #4.
3. If you could buy an old Stanley that was assured of being in good working order you could get in the planing business for $50 or less. You might ask on the Hand Tool Forum if anyone has one for sale.
4. The Wood River Woodcraft planes are cheap and Chinese made. Personally, I don't support the Chinese economy.
5. The new Lee Valley plane seems to be well designed. I have seen them made but I have not used one.
6. The Lee Neilsen plane is an expensive version of a Stanley guaranteed to work well out of the box with out further diddling with it.
Your success with a plane will depend on your ability to get the blade sharp and properly set the cap iron. You probably need to worry as much or more about how you are going to sharpen it as the plane itself.
Veritas Low Angles
Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level
I'll bet you get a lot of responses to your inquiry!! 
I have several bench planes. But the one I grab the most is a Veritas low angle jack plane. It works very well for a variety of situations and does well with figured woods too. That said, the Veritas low angle smoother is also a fine choice.
Have fun with whatever you choose!
T.
Re: 1st goo PLANE
David Bassett
You don't say how you plan to use the plane. The #4 & #5 planes mentioned already are bigger "bench" planes that would normally be used for preparing boards for projects. You can change their function by how you set them up, but the #4 is normally considered a smoothing plane to create a finished, or near-finished, surface. The #5 is a "jack" or general purpose plane normally used for coarser work, e.g. initial flattening. (Christopher Schwarz suggests #5 to start because it can be adjusted to rough, flatten, and smooth. But if you read his projects, he pretty much assumes you've got 6 or 7 planes for different tasks, so YMMV! :-) )
If you are looking for something to supplement power tools, for touch ups, small spots, etc. you should consider a low-angle block plane. It's sort of in a different class than the bench planes, but very useful for quick touch-ups and when the bench planes are too big for any given project. (The category is block planes. The low-angle is a sub-category that is more versatile. With work it can be set up to mimic a standard-angle block plane and the low-angle has advantages with end grain, e.g. if you are trimming a dowel flush.)
I have a Windriver low-angle block plane and it is quite usable and it gets better as my sharpening and setup skills improve. In hindsight I'm not sure paying a little more and getting a Veritas wouldn't have been a better choice, but my doubts haven't lead to a replacement. Yet. Stanley also made block planes, so used are available. Veritas and Lie-Nielsen both make many models. Two that have me intrigued are the Veritas Apron Plane and the L-N Rabbet Block plane. I haven't tried either and they are very different. Very small and simple, on one hand, and more expensive, complicated, and versatile on the other.
Hopefully, you can say what you intend to use it for and more experienced users can be more specific.
Re: 1st goo PLANE
BrianMonumentCO
If you don't have a block plane you might consider it......
Many uses.
Re: 1st goo PLANE
don stephan
I have several LN planes and have never been disappointed with them. The Veritas line of planes is probably just as dependable, but I think they have a slightly different look and feel than the traditional Stanley type.
I have a LN low angle jack plane, and I is very versatile. I prefer my LN 4 1/2 and LN low angle block planes for most work though. My biggest reason to use the 4 1/2 over the low angle jack plane (62?) is the latter is much lighter, requiring some downward pressure in use. The weight of the 4 1/2 is enough that I don't try to add downward pressure.
Some of the LN planes offer different frogs to change the cutting angle, which adds versatility.
LN now is selling their honing guide, which is extremely well made and functional. When coupled with their free set up platform instructions and sharpening suggestions it is extremely helpful.
LN customer support is superb - when I encounter a contrary board they are eager to offer suggestions and tips to minimize tearout.
I have no experience with the Veritas planes.
Re: 1st goo PLANE
AZ in Colorado Springs
Bill mentioned Wood River planes. Yeah, they're chinese. But they work well at about half the price of some the other brands mentioned here.
I'm not a hand plane "gourmet." I have #3 & #5 Wood River planes, and a couple of others (#4 & #7).
Size matters.
- For the wood you want to work and how you're going to work it.
- The plane has to fit your hand & be comfortable. If you can get to a wood craft or something similar, handle a few planes and see how they feel in your hand.
- How do you sharpen? This is probably less of a consideration, but as an example, my block plane iron fits my work sharp 2000 port, but for the others I have to use a honing guide and sharpen on top of the machine. (I have a stand for it which provides a surface flush with the top sandpaper so this is easy for me to do.) Keeping the iron sharp is important.
I don't mean to change the subject on you, but if you get a plane that's uncomfortable to use or it's difficult to keep the iron sharp, then you might grow dissatisfied with it or planes in general for the wrong reason.
I used to wonder how there were "hand tool" wood workers. Then I got some decent hand tools and it was like stepping into a (wonderful) new world.
LN customer service
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Last I checked LN personnel do not acknowledge the benefits of a close set cap iron (AKA chip breaker, a totally misnamed plane part). As you will learn on the Hand Tool Forum this handy device was employed for a couple of centuries to mitigate tear-out and was then forgotten about in modern times only to be rediscovered recently as a result of efforts of some WC participants. My annoyance that LN would rather sell a different plane or frog than tell users how to employ what they already have would lower my customer service rating for LN.
Re: 1st goo PLANE
David Bassett
A follow up to what I wrote: "Two that have me intrigued are the Veritas Apron Plane and the L-N Rabbet Block plane. I haven't tried either and they are very different. Very small and simple, on one hand, and more expensive, complicated, and versatile on the other. "
Lie-Nielsen came to a town near by and I got to see, handle, and listen to their experts describe their many different planes. The Rabbet Block plane, I mentioned, is ideal for trimming the cheeks of small tenons. With the knicker and the rabbet-style blade it registers on the shoulder and will trim square to it. *BUT* the demonstrator called it "the plane I love to hate" and emphasized he only used it for that specific purpose (given he has access to all the other planes too.) The reason he gave was that you wrap your hand around a block plane and with this model he was always cutting himself on the exposed blade or knickers. So unless it will be your only plane and you get it for its versatility, I guess I shouldn't have recommended it.
For a block plane he suggested their smallest simplest one as his favorite. I missed the name, but looking at the L-N catalog I think it must have been their Violin Makers Block plane (Stanley 101), because it looked smaller than the 5-1/4" long of their Small Block plane (Stanley 102). (And therefore also smaller than the Veritas Apron Plane.)
Re: 1st goo PLANE
Hank Knight
David, my guess is that the LN demonstrator was talking about the LN #102 small block plane. The violin maker's block plane is a tiny, speciality plane that doesn't generally enter a discussion about block planes in general woodworking. The 102 is probably the standard "small block plane" used in general woodworking. I have one and it is one of my two favorite planes. The LN low angle jack plane is the other. Lee Valley has comparable models.
Hank
Re: 1st goo PLANE
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia) any helpful recommendations on a type of plane and mfg would be appreciated.
I am considering purchasing my first good plane for general purpose shop work. small to med.project sizes and mostly from hardwood.
Hi Russ
I think it is important that you try and zoom in on the purpose to which you wish to use a plane: for example, smoothing a face, trimming a chamfer, tuning tenon cheeks, etc.
There are many different planes for many different uses. There are also "jack of all trades", which may be a compromise that works, or not.
A smoothing plane (e.g. Stanley #4 or equivalent) works for smoothing and even jointing boxes. A block plane (e.g. Stanley #60 1/2 or equivalent) is best used on end grain or bevelling edges.
A jack of all trades is the Stanley #5, which may be used to level and joint edges and faces up to 30" in length. It will not smooth as well as a #4, but the #4 will will not joint as well as a #5.
A shoulder plane is a precision tool that can tweak a tenon shoulder or square a rebate. There are different sizes. Small ones can also make short work of dados.
The list goes on and one ...
Can you say more about your wants?
Regards from Perth
Derek