Neither
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
Neither. You can't have GREEN grass in Cleveland under a giant oak tree, with crappy winters, and multiple dogs.
That combo provides mud. That's all.
Our backyard used to be a mud pit.
Did a lot of research, and ended up with this product. Not the stuff sold at big box stores. It's great.
http://www.foreverlawn.com/k9grass
Took 2 days to install. Crew of 3 guys. In my tiny backyard.
They dug out the lawn plus about six inches, filled with crushed stone, then the "grass" is laid on top of that.

Bye old backyard

Ready for the stone

One of the piles of stone

Bringing in the stone

Stone in, tamped down, and ready for grass

Grass in place, ready for dogs

Best money we ever spent on our house.
Sorry for the gigantic hijack...