Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Moravian Bench Build

Posts

Moravian Bench Build

#1

Moravian Bench Build

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Our club president Rick Foltz tries out the bench for the first time.

The club needed a portable work bench useful of a wide variety of demonstrations. A work bench patterned after a Moravian bench at MESDA seemed idea. A group of club volunteers set about to make one. Most had little woodworking experience. The project involved selecting lumber, planing it, and gluing up the top and legs. To assemble the legs, bridle, mortise and tenon and dovetail joinery was done, largely with hand tools. Tusk tenon joinery was done to secure the leg stretchers to the legs.

The bench disassembles into the two leg units, two stretchers and the top which sits on locating pins.

The bench is amazingly stable. If anyone needs a portable bench this bench would be a candidate. The bench in the picture is 42” long and 18” deep.

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#2

Re: Moravian Bench Build

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Nice. What is the wood?

Poplar, Maple... ?

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#3

The shape works for welding too

Gary Smyth


Bare bones. Upside down and has yet to have its casters, power outlets, torch holder, shelves and top fitted, but it is very lightweight (for a welding table,) stable, will be "portable", and will support 300lbs when finished. Weather is too stink'in hot for me to weld it, only bolted for now.

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#4

Re: Moravian Bench Build

Dick Coers

How does the top fasten to the legs? You sure didn't spare any material in those tenon wedges!

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#5

Wedges

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For ease of construction the taper needed to match the leg taper, 16 degrees. They are not shaped yet. Someone with an artistic flair is going to shape the top into some nice profile and then I am going to Line and Berry a pattern on their top.

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#6

yes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

poplar top with hard maple edge banding

Soft maple legs and stretchers.

The legs are the size they are for weight.

The bench is amazingly stable. No problem planing on it.

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#7

the top

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It sits on 4 pins located in the top of the legs. You can imagine our satisfaction when we lowered the top onto the bench and the pins slid snugly in place and it didn't rock. Whooohooo!

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#8

Re: Moravian Bench Build

Barry Irby

That's a beautiful bench, I know the club will be proud to have it.

It strikes my Engineering brain that a trapezoid is not a "stable" shape. A triangle is. (Cannot be deformed unless the material or the connection fail.) The bench is relying on the strength of the joints and the mass (inertia) to resist rocking. I am wondering why I never see a bench that incorporates triangles in base? I am not being critical just curious. I have reasoned that it may be that triangles practically eliminate the possibility of drawers.

The local county built about six small branch libraries. They had a big atrium in the center that was framed with an exposed steel frame that was composed of trapezoids. I was researching something in one of the one day and noticed it. Went to the supervisors and pointed out the instability. The laughed at me. I went to the Chief building official and had a long talk with him. He got the engineers to review the plans again. They have torn all six of them down and built something better.

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#9

Where is that vice?

Keith Newton

While it looks plenty stable, I don't know why you would want such a small top. I wouldn't be happy with one that small, with feet sticking out beyond the top on the ends to trip on. The sneakers and sandals I wear aren't much protection when I kick something that solid.

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#10

theory correct, in fact wrong

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the bench was stable without the top before we even added the wedges. When the wedges pull the tenon shoulders into the legs it is equivalent to bed bolts pulling in bed rails. There is no movement under stress.

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#11

Re: Where is that vice?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

maybe you missed the part that our retiree program chairman needs to be able to carry the bench parts to meetings and other demonstrations. The bench is to do demos on not earn a living.

Vise Is inboard of left leg. That is where it is stable with the removable top.

While the bench would not meet the needs of everyone it meets the needs of the club perfectly as it was designed to do.

Re: Moravian Bench Build

#12

Re: theory correct, in fact wrong

Barry Irby

Don't you just love it when stuff works like its supposed to?