Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

Posts

Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#1

Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Not thinking ahead, the door for the spice box is 1/2" thick. It should have been 5/8 to accommodate 1/2" screws for the hinges and lock. As it is, piddly 3/8" screws were required. The hinge and lock mortises are tight so the only requirement of the screw is to keep the hinge in place; the mortise provides the support. Never-the-less I would have preferred a longer screw.

Soooo, let this be a lesson to all. Size stuff to accommodate optimum screws.

The finishing drags on. While I can spray on shellac in less than a minute it takes a half hour to rub out the coating for the next coat. Stain. Sealer coat. sand. First build coat, sand. Apply glaze. Seal glaze and sand. Apply thinned final coat to get a very smooth surface....I hope. I want the box bright to enhance the grain so the final coat needs to be good without further rub-out and wax. The final coat goes on tomorrow....I hope. It rained me out this afternoon.

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#2

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor plan

don stephan

Don't know if you would be comfortable with this, but I occasionally nip off the last 1/8" of wood screws when getting close to opposite surface. I don't mind this because the tip is smaller diameter and thus I'm losing little holding power. You might want to nip off a bit more from a 1/2" screw, but all of what's left will be full diameter and thus offering holding power. Hope this makes sense.

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#3

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor plan

William Duffield

I often do basically the same thing, but usually using a grinder. To keep from burning my fingers, I hold the screw in long nose vise grips.

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#4

I don't remember...

David Yoho

I don't remember who said it here before but I found it to be a smart tip. It's possible it was Richard Jones but nevertheless the tip was to start a build or design with the hardware and go from there. I never considered this before then but it sure has helped me avoid exactly what happened to you.

Too many times the hardware for a project is an afterthought. This not only can affect the outcome of a design but also could lead to installation problems. Since reading that advice, I always start by knowing which hardware I'm using and having it on hand at the beginning.

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#5

Re: I don't remember...

Sgian Dubh

"I don't remember who said it here before but I found it to be a smart tip. It's possible it was Richard Jones but nevertheless the tip was to start a build or design with the hardware and go from there."

Indeed it was me David, and I'm rather flattered you remember! However, I think it might be worthwhile to mention the design tip again, which reads simply "Design from the handles back". In essence, this exhorts the designer to consider, right at the outset of the design process, what the viewer sees when first sighting a piece. In many cases this will be the front, although there are exceptions: for example, dining chairs might be approached from any angle, and beds may be seen from the side first. It's really just a mnemonic to help avoid the design gaffe of the pulls or handles being an afterthought rather than a considered and integral part of the whole.

Your consideration of all the hardware in a piece at the design stage is an excellent logical extension of the basic guide. Bill's admission to perhaps missing a trick is a bit unfortunate, but I suspect the screws he's forced to use will be adequate for the job, and I trust he won't beat himself up too much over it - we all make mistakes, and I've made plenty of them, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#6

One must be wary.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have shortened many nails and screws to arrive at a custom length. In the case of screws one has to be certain that the pilot hole is adequate in diameter and length. If too short the screw can force a dimple on the reverse side....now how do you think I happen to know that :) .

I commonly get into this custom screw length situation when fastening on tops. My longer screws are in 1/4' length increments and it is common for the optimum size to be some increment other than 1/4".

Another thing to be wary about is grinding hardened screws. If the gap between tool rest and wheel surface is too great one can loose control of the screw and it will wedge between the wheel and rest with alarming rapidity.

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#7

Re: I don't remember...

William Duffield

There are a couple of other hardware issues that are most often encountered when building spice boxes.

Since the drawers have knobs and are behind a door, there needs to be clearance between the drawer front and the door panel for the knobs.

Traditionally, spice boxes were locked, because they held valuables. The bolt on the lock has to engage a strike plate. The easiest lock configuration to find has the bolt extending out the edge of the door. Therefore, the front of the door is inset into the frame.

The screws of the hinges also must be covered when the door is closed, again for security. If the hinge side of the door is also inset into the frame, the rightmost drawers won't clear the hinge barrels. One way to avoid this problem is to make the drawers a little narrower and insert a spacer in the case on the right side. Also, the screws on the carcass side of the hinge must be short and can easily split out the the front edge of the carcass if the door is opened too emphatically.

The more usual method is to set the right side of the carcass back by the thickness of the door, and screw the hinges to the front of the carcass and the back of the door stile.

Since the scale of spice boxes, and especially small ones intended for jewelry often use thin stock for carcasses and doors, often 1/2" thick, the hinges and locks must also be narrow.

Hidden compartments may also involve hardware planning, but usually do not use metal hardware.

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#8

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor plan

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"The finishing drags on. While I can spray on shellac in less than a minute it takes a half hour to rub out the coating for the next coat. Stain. Sealer coat. sand. First build coat, sand. Apply glaze. Seal glaze and sand. Apply thinned final coat to get a very smooth surface...."

Hmmm. You make spraying sound as bad as brushing/wiping/padding/peeing on shellac, varnish, poly, cow dung or what ever...

Maybe I don't want to learn spraying after all.

:D

(just kidding)

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#9

go learn wipe on varnish

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Some recent issue of Fine Woodowrking has a review of products. Nothing is easier that looks as good as it gets. These spice boxes would be varnished were it not for the holly.

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#10

Ellis Walentine

Exactly


Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#11

That's what I'm going back to

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

It's what I used to do. That or just brush on poly. It works.

Just thought I'd try something new with brushing shellac. It's something I should be able to do. FWW makes it look so simple... :\

Mr.Duffield provided a great deal of help to me via emails (which I am very appreciative of). He provided to me a great deal of info and help. It just didn't click in my head. One thing he pointed out to me (with this clock) is I could have done a better job with some of my saw cuts and surface prep prior to finishing. I could have done better with that. Should have. Not sure how I got sloppy with it.

I'll try again some day.

Thanks.

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#12

Question for Bill

Jesse Cloud

I do some stringing as well, and agree that shellac is the appropriate finish for the holly. I remember you saying earlier that you put a glaze between layers of the shellac.

Do you put the glaze on the holly? If not, how you do avoid doing that?

I'm adding a slight red tint to my cherry that I would prefer not having on the string. Hope you have a clever way to do that!

Re: Spice box- hinges, locks, screws and poor planing

#13

Nope.......more problems!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The decorated door panel is oiled and then blond shellac. The rest is stained, shellac, glaze , shellac.

Sprayed the (hoped for) final coat this morning. I like to finish up with a wet coat of about 10% solids shellac. It levels out and leaves a glass smooth surface.......except. As I was spraying a cloud drifted over the sun, the humidity soared (it rained last night) and when the solvent flashed a layer of liquid water condensed on the surface. I've been here before. Let it dry and then sprayed a wet film of 100% isopropanol. It is slow to evaporate and heals the cloudy result of the water condensing.

I post picture of completed box when I get the door on. I like to wait a day or two to fully harden the shellac before handling much.