Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

motor speed contol

Posts

motor speed contol

#1

motor speed contol

howardd

Motor speed control

I’m looking at a mill that has a three phase motor running at 3450 rpm at 60 HZ. I would like to increase speed by increasing input frequency using a DRO.

How much could I safely increase frequency or speed without damaging the motor?

Thanks

Howard

Re: motor speed contol

#2

Re: motor speed contol

Keith Newton

I'm no expert at this, but before you get any meaningful answer, you ought to give a bit more information. For instant, what kind of mill, sawmill, or milling machine. How much boost, 20,000 rpm's, or heck lets go for 100,000?

You can do it with VFD, but there are always tradeoffs, like lower torque among other things.

Re: motor speed contol

#3

Re: motor speed contol

howardd

its a Rong Fu mill drill, 3 phase 1 hp motor, runs at 1500 rpm at 60 HZ. Gear drive so no pulleys that I can change.

Re: motor speed contol

#4

There's no answer really...

John in NM

It depends on too many factors -

-Rated RPM of the bearings in the system (not just the motor bearings)

-Heat tolerance of the system

-Torque required

-Your tolerance for purchasing new motors/parts :D

That said, I have heard of running up to 6,000 rpm, though that could also be internet bravado. If the mill is a geared head type, I would be more concerned about the gearbox overheating than the motor itself.

I used to cut wood parts on a vertical mill at work - stuff for which the DRO was handier than making up a template, or stuff for which I had to have a lead screw to control the cut (large ball cutters). I used to run it at it's designed top speed - 4,000 rpm at the spindle - and that worked fine.

Re: motor speed contol

#5

Re: There's no answer really...

Howardd

I was hoping to double speed to 3000 rpm. I know that the gears can operate at that speed.

Howard

Re: motor speed contol

#6

Re: There's no answer really...

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Doubling the RPM should be no problem. Three phase motors controlled with VFDs do much better running at speeds higher than rated than they do running slower- you don't have to worry about loss of hp or overheating due to poor cooling air. The biggest issue is bearing wear and possible overheating of bearings. It will be noisier as well.

Re: motor speed contol

#7

Re: motor speed contol

Brian Roberts

DRO...?

Re: motor speed contol

#8

Re: motor speed contol

John K Jordan

Switch or change gears?

Re: motor speed contol

#9

That should work...

John in NM

3,000 is a pretty reasonable RPM. I'm actually a little surprised the mill won't do that already, but then I've only used a few mills so maybe that is my ignorance more than an unusual specification. There are some discussions on this subject at the Practical Machinist forum.

Re: motor speed contol

#10

Re: motor speed contol

John in NM

Digital read out. Makes a lot of stuff super easy.

EDIT:

Re-reading the OP, I think he meant to say VFD instead.

Re: motor speed contol

#11

Re: motor speed contol

Brian Roberts

Yup.....we have DRO's on all our machines....just wasn't sure how he was gonna use one to vary motor speed.......