Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Tool question - circular and jig saws

Posts

Tool question - circular and jig saws

#1

JL

Tool question - circular and jig saws

JL

I have a birthday coming up. The LOML has asked me what I want. I can't really think of anything new - so I was thinking about replacing something.

I have an old (REALLY old) Craftsman jig saw. It works - but it has seen better days. I have two old circular saws (one a Craftsman and one a Skil).

The Bosch jig saw gets good reviews. Thoughts?

The DeWalt DWE575 gets good reviews. Thoughts?

I mostly crosscut lumber and rip plywood with a circular saw.

I would cut a variety of things with a jig saw - plywood to hardwoods (8/4).

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#2

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

Bill Howatt

Can't help much but to say I had an old 2 speed Craftsman jig saw. Replaced it with a Makita and couldn't believe how much nicer it was to use. What I'm not so sure of though, is what part of the improvement came from just using better blades.

Bosch jigsaws were rated very highly when I got the Makita but I didn't want to spend the extra for a tool I don't really use too much.

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#3

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

Dick Coers

I prefer Bosch to Dewalt. If you rip plywood, maybe consider a track saw? That's one of the Festool I did buy. Can't justify them for much else, so far.

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#4

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I have a Bosch barrel grip jig saw and I really love it. Had two others over the years and could not believe the difference. Use their "Progressor" blades for straight cuts and you will be amazed.

Also have a Milwaukee Tilt-Lok circular saw that I use for construction lumber field cuts and sizing sheet goods. Make yourself a zero clearance saw guide and you will wonder why you ever cut sheet goods any other way. See PICS.

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#5

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

Jesse Cloud

Just wanted to emphasize Dick's compliment on the track saw was for ripping plywood.

If you are looking for a circular saw for cutting 2x4's, the track saws are probably not the best option. And I am a big fan of the Festool tracksaw.

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#6

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

Virgil Johnson

I bought a Bosch barrel grip jig saw in 2002 and it has been a great replacement for the old Craftsman saw I had before. I've used it on 2" oak and maple and it does not bog. Used it to cut the exhaust off the old Camry and saw 1/2" dia drill rod. The list of abuse could go on.

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#7

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

William Duffield

I also have a Festool tracksaw, and can recommend them highly. I will note that I have the larger saw, the TS-75. Unless you also need it to rip through multiple sheets of plywood at the same time or 8/4 hardwood, I would recommend the TS-55REQ. The smaller, lighter size is easier to handle, and the rail you need for the same length rips is shorter. The best thing about track saws, especially with quality Festool blades is that measurement and layout are trivial, and your first cut is your final cut.

I used to rough dimension plywood using a circular saw and "track" Tim shows. It's a kludge––There's just no comparison.

I also have a Festool Carvex jigsaw. Mine is a barrel handle, with a cord. You also have the choice of a D-handle, and also a rechargeable LiIon battery. It is a very nice machine, with lots of flexibility due to the accessories. I replaced a Bosch with it, and I wouldn't go back. Note that my Bosch had the older blade holding and release system, which was a PITA. The newer ones are a lot more convenient, but still not as easy to use or as precise as the Festool.

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#8

Re: Tool question - Bosch

TomD

I have a Bosch jig saw goes back to a year or so before they fielded the instant blade change. I am very happy with mine, it is one of my most used tools. Saw blades is certainly part of it, but then back then you couldn't get good saw blades for all the other saw. I am very partial to the barrel grip and would never get anything else. I fit Large gloves, even though I am well over 6 feet. I have no problem with the grip size, but some say they do. Mine being so old indicates that they held up at one time, but I don't have experience with the current crop.

I have a Bosch jelly bean circular saw, it may have been the first 15 amp circular saw with direct drive. It's a fine tool but not one that has me heart and soul and currently there must be many new variations, like battery driven ones.

I saw I like a lot is my Dewalt hypoid. I am not a production framer, but I play one whenever I get a chance, the Dewalt is enough like a worm drive to play at it without having to handle the weight of the SS77, which some say isn't what it once was anyway.

Having both a left and right circular saw is useful for timber framing, and I find the different saw styles are also useful.

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#9

Re: Tool question - Bosch

John K Jordan

Bosch is one of my first choices for tools (their 12" non-sliding SCMS is incredible!) and their jig saw is doubtless excellent. But I bought a Makita jig saw and after 3years of use I still love it. Things I like: Very solidly made, instant blade change, LED light, variable speed, and a "soft start". I've used it a LOT with wood while building my new shop and it worked well cutting a propane tank to make a "Hank" drum.

(As an aside, I wonder if anyone makes a jig saw now with the very useful feature on an ancient Craftsman I still use occasionally in a tight spot - a big knob on the top lets the blade rotate to cut at any angle, sideways, backwards, etc.)

As for circular saws I have several but my go-to saw (for around the farm, construction, and to rough crosscut dimensional lumber at the stack rather than carry it to a better saw) is a battery operated Dewalt. Light weight, great of course for where there is no power! Nearly instant stop too. When building my shop I used it from a ladder to notch sixteen PT 6x6 posts to inset 2x10s for to build up the beams to support the trusses.

If you do any construction, you might also consider a good reciprocating saw. I keep four here and get a lot of use from these for wood and steel (with Milwaulkee "the torch" blades - it is amazing how well these work on steel, even 1/2 thick!). The battery powered ones are great for trimming branches too, with a long pruning blade.

JKJ

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#10

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

John E in SC

After using cheap, crappy jig saws for 20-30 years, I finally broke down and spent the money for a Bosch. It's AMAZING how much better it cuts! I still don't use a jig saw all that often either, but when I use it, I'm sure glad I bought it!

Re: Tool question - circular and jig saws

#11

Late to the Party . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

but I have only good to say about the PC 7549 jig/bayonet saw I've used for years. Orbital cutting and VS with a fixed base (no angle cuts) with choice of blade styles. With a sharp blade I've cut accurately in 4" thick stock. Sadly, they ain't made any more.

In the circ department I have a "monster" 7-1/4 worm drive but only haul it out when material exceeds 1-5/8" and is wet. For sheet goods and ANYthing up to "2x" I grab the PC SawBoss 6". At 6,000 rpm it literally glides through 5/4 cherry, walnut, framing lumber, and sheet stuff.