Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Trex decking OT

Posts

Trex decking OT

#1

Trex decking OT

Howardd

I have a concrete deck floor that has cedar two by fours nailed to two by four pressure treated sleepers. The sleepers are not fastened to the concrete. I would like to replace the cedar with Trex.

the Trex manual states that a floating installation is not permitted and that the sleepers must be fastened to the concrete. I called their customer service and they did not not know why the sleepers needed to be fastened to the concrete.

Anyone know what problem I will face if the sleepers are not fastened to the concrete.

Thanks

Howard

Re: Trex decking OT

#2

Re: Trex decking OT

Keith Newton

If you choose a sleeper that has doe reaction wood in it, it could bow up, is the only thing I can think of. And if that were to happen later, type could take care of it with Tapcon screws drilled and driven in the space between, if it became a problem later, unless you butted the tightly together.

Do you know how to spot reaction wood before it dries and warps? In treated SYP, it will have a slightly more yellow or orange cast, and maybe a closer ring spacing, but sometimes a wider one.

Re: Trex decking OT

#3

Re: Trex decking OT

Howardd

Thanks Keith

In this case bowing won't be a problem as I plan on using the old twenty year old sleepers. They seem as good as new.

Howard

Re: Trex decking OT

#4

Re: Trex decking OT

Keith Newton

Ummm, I wouldn't bet on that. While you may not need to worry about a catastrophic event if they fail to hold up, like one suspended high up. Unless you rare in an extremely arid area, they have been living in a really harsh atmosphere for those 20 years, and I've torn out enough decks around that age to know that the wood may look sound, or at least not punky, but the strength has greatly diminished, and I would suspect the chemicals have been slowly leaching out, so how much longer before it becomes mulch is anybody's guess.

How long do you expect the new deck to last? I don't think I would be very happy with myself, if I had to pull it up five years from now, if I chose to save a few bucks now. Also, if I recall correctly these new materials need a closer spacing than most wood decks.

Another thing to think about, is that all the old nail holes left in the old sleepers will slowly fill up with pollen, dust, catkins, leaves and anything else that settles out of the atmosphere, then washes down into them whenever it rains. It then becoms mulch or a great potting medium for all the bad things that eat wood cells.

Re: Trex decking OT

#5

Re: Trex decking OT

Bill Howatt

I agree. I have a Trex deck and given the cost of Trex and the work involved it makes good sense to not go cheap on the foundation.

Bill

Re: Trex decking OT

#6

Re: Trex decking OT

George Koch

If , for some reason, you did not want to secure the sleepers, new or used, to the concrete base with mechanical fasteners, I would suggest using a good quality construction adhesive to do so. George

Re: Trex decking OT

#7

I think the reason is...and a caution. *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

I think the reason the sleepers need to be fastened down is that Trex, despite all of its good attributes, has an issue with spanning distances while bearing loads.

Imagine if you don't fasten them down, and instead only fasten the Trex to the sleepers. Weight on the Trex over spaces between the sleepers will tend to pull the sleepers towards one another, allowing the Trex to deflect more than it otherwise would. Granted, as one walks across the deck, they'll likely be pulled in various directions, but it is still a structural issue.

Try this: lay a board across the joists and walk on it. It will deflect more between the joists than it would if it were fastened to the joist. So it follows that the sleepers not being fastened down will allow a similar excessive movement.

Also, there will then be more lateral stress placed on the deck screws, since they would be forced first one way, then another as the people walk across the deck. Over time, this can lead to screw failure, since most deck screws aren't rated for side loading.

In the end, follow the instructions.

Perhaps more importantly, educate yourself on the online reviews of Trex that hundreds of users have submitted, and consider another product. I like Ipe.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa


Trex at consumer affairs

Re: Trex decking OT

#8

Re: I think the reason is...and a caution.

Howardd

The reason I was thinking of using the old sleepers was that I was comcerned we with the quality of the pressure treated wood being sold. I am afraid of it warping?

Any comments regarding ensuring that the new sleepers would remain flat.

After reading the negative comments about Trex in the attachment to the previous note I think I will go with cedar decking.

Thanks

Howard

Re: Trex decking OT

#9

Re: Trex decking OT

don stephan

The recommendation may be because new pressure treated wood warps so much so often.

Re: Trex decking OT

#10

Idon't know where you are, but here,

Keith Newton

The HD store keeps 2 grades of treated pine deck boards. On the last deck I built, the clear grade cost about $100 more on a 16' x 16' deck, which made it a no-brainer for me.

There were no knots, nor heartwood which wouldn't take the treatment, that would be the first part to rot over time. That $100 may have added 10 years to the life expectancy of this deck, if the beauty factor alone wasn't enough.

Back in the seventies and eighties, I built a lot of decks using cedar and redwood, when it was so plentiful and cheap. However, I don't think you can expect the durability of the second growth cedar to be as good as old growth, from what I've read.