I have a tile shower floor that leaks. It's not a great flowing leak but it does leak a few drops after each use. I believe it leaks at the corner where the floor meets the walls.
My plan is to cut some angled tiles to fit into the corners at a 45° angle, glue in the tile and grout. There will be a small space behind these patch tiles, maybe 1/2 sq.in., and some people have suggested I attach the tiles with silicone caulk.
My concern is that this type of non-rigid caulk will allow the grout to break out over time. Are my concerns valid ? If not caulk, what can I use to fill and seal the space that I can adhere the tile to and still provide a water seal ? Mortar would certainly be rigid enough but would it provide an adequate seal ?
Additionally, I have read a do-it-yourselfer article (link below) that recommends treating the floor with 2 coats clear masonry sealant. Does anyone have a sealant they can recommend ? I found one called Amteco Cure n Seal and another one called V-Seal Phase II. Is anyone familiar with either ?
Neither the grout or the thinset used to adhere tile will (and are not designed to) "waterproof" a tile installation.....period.
The prep work prior to setting tile is what waterproofs an installation.
Sorry to have to say.....but your plan is most likely doomed to failure.
Not unlike a roof leak...it is nearly impossible to tell where the leak originates based on where it actually drips...or runs...etc..
A properly installed pan and waterproofed walls are a must to contain the water that WILL migrate thru the grout and thinset.
Sadly there are MANY tile setters (and big box stores) that believe simply putting "green board" or cement board up will do the job......and by the time the homeowner discovers the leak the installer is long gone....or blames it on something or someone else.
It is the tile-setters responsibility to KNOW that the prep work was done correctly and either fix it or walk away from the job.
There MUST be an absolutely waterproof envelope in place .......that will direct any moisture that migrates thru the "tile envelope" to the drain.....which must ALSO be properly installed to allow for proper draining.
Brian is spot on here, your best option is to pull it all out and do it over properly.
Unfortunately my limited experience is that if the pan is leaking odds are good the rest of it wasn't done right either so you'll end up going up the walls as well. Its also hard to get the drainage properly done between the walls and the pan unless its all done as a unit as well.. so.. yeah... no envy of your position from my point *at all*.
What started at as a 2 day re-grout job on a bathroom at a previous house ended up as a month long (doing everything in the evenings and decision point delays) rip it down to the studs and start over project once I started to see what was underneath.
I am a retired plumber/pipefitter, and the guys are correct....remove the pan down to the cement, and up the walls about a foot to the studs. Go to HD or Lowes and buy a heavy plastic pan sheet which can be folded to match the pan and up the walls with NO leakage possible. Reinstall the drain and slope the floor towards it with a mortar used for that purpose. They also have a mold which would assist you in doing it correctly. Reinstall the green board on the walls and retile as you need to and grout with a fine sanded grout...not the heavy stuff. Then cover the grout with a good sealing solution to prevent any leakage.
Green board is no longer considered acceptable for wet areas.....by code in most places...and by experience....it does NOT stand up to long term wet conditions....period.
I should have said cement board. Whatever, The plastic sheeting(10mm) is readily folded to make the corners and then nailed in the upper ends above any water line. Cover with the cement board and reapply the tile and grout with a fine grout and then sealer.
As a Home Inspector I see leaking showers regularly or maybe irregularly is closer.
Tile showers are difficult to inspect because they are almost always enclosed by finished walls. If they are on the second floor there is a ceiling below. Repairs are difficult and expensive, so the stakes are high for the Inspector. I am wondering how the OP knows it only leaks a couple of teaspoons of water?
The view I get most often is from the crawl space. Older units have a lead pan with cement in it to form the sloping floor of the shower. One type of leak I catch is a leak around the drain. Water drools out and brings part of the cement out with it in solution. I see a white crusty residue and sometimes stalactites. Since this is centered around the drain, I assume the connection between the drain and pan is leaking.
Other times I see stains and sometimes rot at the perimeter of the shower. Again, I assume that it might be the supply piping or valves leaking. Another possibility is water is seeping through the grout and drooling down and going over the pan, not into it.
Without a look at the exterior of the shower, this is mostly speculation.
The "latest thing" seems to be the Schluter liner. Appears to be polyethylene with a fuzzy face similar to the felt part of hook and loop. You put the material on the walls, bedding it into the appropriate glue/thinset. Then you apply thinset to the face side and tile over it. It cvan be applied over ordinary drywall, not even the green board. The Old Fuddy Duddy in me is skeptical.
Incidentally, I have tub surrounds on green board that are 35 years old and they seem fine.
I don't get to tear out the ones I find on inspections and do a real investigation. The sad part is they just get ripped out and done over, hopefully better.
Water most definitely travels uphill due to wicking action in the drywall.
When you're REALLY lucky you'll find that they didn't even use drywall behind the tile (and no vapor barrier like redguard or the newer film stuff either) and then you get to find out how effectively water really is at wicking up the wall. Personal experience says to goes to about 2 feet, but that was in a dry climate so you might see it go a bit further.
I wouldn't use greenboard anymore in a shower either, the alternatives are cost competitive and less risky so there's not really a good reason anymore imho.
Barry, when I say it only leaks a few drops of water per shower, I mean what comes through the OSB below. This bathroom is above my shop and I have placed a bowl where it drips.
This is the worst kind of leak, well almost. It woudl be worse if it did not leak enough to drip through. The drip is your warning. If your ideas abut caulking reduce it to the point is does not drip then you will be in real trouble because the few remaining drop will slowly soak into the OSB and surrounding framing and either diamante the OSB or rot it slowly while you live in ignorance.
It does seem a shame that the "fix" for a little leak is the same as for a big leak. Tear the whole thing out and do it over correctly. Somehow does not seem fair.
You could ask yourself some questions. Does the shower get regular use? (Sounds like it does since you have a bowl below to catch the water.) Wood has to stay wet for a somewhat extended period of time to rot. If this were under the guest bathroom and it got wet twice a year its not the same as daily.
Are you getting any younger? Do you want to fix this now or when you are older? Do you have the money to pay for a repair or will you have it in the future?
This is a design opportunity. Ready for a fancy new shower or even a fancy new bathroom?
You could do some tests or experiments. You could either stop up the drain and floor the base of the shower with and inch or two of water and let it stand for a day or two to see if it the pan leaking. Or you could temporarily cover the walls with plastic sheeting (shower curtain liners?) and shower to see if that stops the leaks.
If the pan is leaking the only cure I know of is to tear it out and do it over. If the walls are leaking you MIGHT caulk and grout your way to temporary success. The problem is that you might just reduce it to the really sneaky leak that does not show up for a long time. But, at that point your choice is to tear it out and start all over. The repair might involve some extra carpentry to replace rotten parts, but that small potatoes compared to the plumbing and tile work.
I see people live with the stupid shower liner until they sell the house to some poor unsuspecting sucker. (shame on them)
You could also drill some holes into the cavity around the shower and use a bore scope type tool (HD sells one made by Milwaukee for about $250) to see whats going on, but that only confirms what you already know.
The fact that your house has OSB tells me it not really old.