Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Screw holding plywood or solid wood

Posts

Screw holding plywood or solid wood

#1

Screw holding plywood or solid wood

Larry

What has better screw holding plywood or solid wood?

Re: Screw holding plywood or solid wood

#2

Depends

David Yoho

That's a bit of a loaded question. Variables like screw type, plywood thickness and type, or softwood versus hardwood could factor in to the right response. While "solid" wood would seem to have the advantage, any one of those variables could matter in changing that.

Care to be more specific?

Re: Screw holding plywood or solid wood

#3

Re: Depends

Larry

I'm thinking Hardware Screws, Like hinges .

Re: Screw holding plywood or solid wood

#4

Re: Screw holding plywood or solid wood

BrianMonumentCO

If you are mounting hardware that enters the edge of a board, I would prefer solid wood.

As screws entering the edge of plywood tend to split the plywood.

Your mileage may differ.

But splitting plywood is not good.

Re: Screw holding plywood or solid wood

#5

Re: Depends

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Generally speaking hardwood will give more holding power for a given screw than softwood or construction grade ply wood. Baltic type plywood with screws in face grain will have nearly the same holding power as hardwood. Edge grain plywood doesn't have good holding power nor does end grain hard wood or softwood.

However the type of screw and how it is installed can vary the results significantly.

Lee

Re: Screw holding plywood or solid wood

#6

Well then...

David Yoho

Generally the screws that come with hinges are tapered just like a regular wood screw is. If these are small screws in the range of #3 - #4 for small hinges they usually don't have enough thread area to have a lot of holding power. But this size shouldn't see a lot of stress that would rip them out of the wood. On larger screws the threaded area is generally larger and deeper allowing the screw to bite into the wood to hold better.

That said, no tapered wood screw will hold effectively in plywood or solid wood in a pilot hole drilled using a standard bit. Since a full-length pilot hole cut with a standard bit is round, the front end of the screw down near the point isn't contacting the wood. You either need to limit the depth of the pilot hole to avoid this issue or use the proper size tapered drill bit.

If the screws are going into the edge of the wood then solid wood holds better than plywood. If they're going into the face of the wood, construction grade plywood loses to solid wood. If the plywood is a Baltic type multi-ply or a hardwood veneered plywood with a wood core (not MDF core), then your screws would hold as well as they would in a soft solid wood but probably not as good as in solid hardwood.

Re: Screw holding plywood or solid wood

#7

hinger holding

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There should be little withdrawing force on the screws of a properly mounted butt hinge in a hinge mortise. As an example I have worked on factory hinged house entry doors where the hinges were secured with 3/4" screws in soft pine. The screws eventually failed from loosening not pulling out.

Re: Screw holding plywood or solid wood

#8

Re: Screw holding plywood or solid wood

TomD

In general screws hold best in side grain, if you insert screws into ply where the screw is entirely contained in a sidegrain ply you will get good strength. There are many ways to play with fasteners in plywood that yield excellent results, and plywood has the stability to take advantage of these methods. In general screws and hinges are technologies invented to work with solid wood, so one would expect better results therein on average. But there are many products designed to provide good results in plywood.