Replacement Led Bulbs
Larry
This may have been asked befor but has anyone used the Replacement Led Bulbs, to replace the fluorescent bulbs? What do you think?
Thanks
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Replacement Led Bulbs
Larry
This may have been asked befor but has anyone used the Replacement Led Bulbs, to replace the fluorescent bulbs? What do you think?
Thanks
why?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
When one buys a lamp there are only three things of relevance, unless you live in CA and your electric rates are 2X more than average.
1. Light output Looking at the lamp is a poor indication. Reading the rated output on the lamp box is a good indication. Fluorescent wins.
2. Color temperature - Fluorescent available in anything from 3000 to 6000 depending on your preference. Fluorescent wins again.
3. Color accuracy. (CRI value) Fluorescents can be as high as 90. LED unknown to me.
Better lighting, that's why.
R. Payne
LEDs can beat fluorescent in all of the categories you list. But not generally if you only look at what is on the shelf from a big box store. Add to that a generally longer life and less electricity used per lumen, if you have access to a real light store or are willing to wade though the results of an internet search then LEDs win.
(A couple months back I spent a few week researching lighting for work.)
ron
Re: why?
Larry
I live in Calif. Also I would like to know if they a better than Fluorescent,and I don't have the money to replace the fixtures.
Re: Better lighting, that's why. *LINK*
walta
I tested a pair of these LEDs in my shop I was impressed. To my eyes much brighter than new T12 and slightly brighter than T8.
No rewiring required just remove the old bulb and insert the LEDs and you are done.
If you want to this setup allows you to aim the Led in any direction regardless of the sockets orientation.
After my real world test I no longer believe the lumens number printed on the boxes as the 1700 lumen LEDs appear to my eyes much brighter than ever one of the20 T12 some new some old that should range from 2300 to 1900 lumens.
At this point I have a few lamps in my stash when they are gone or should ballast fail I think the LEDs are at a point where they make sense.
I encourage the doubters to buy a pair put in a fixture in a room with several T12 or T8 If you are unimpressed Home Depot will gladly give you a full refund.
Walta
Home Depot
looking can be misleading
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
In either case the primary light generated is ultraviolet. This light generated internal to the lamp impinges on the inner surface of the lamp which is coated with a phosphor that turns UV light into visible light. To take an example, the lamp surface of a T8 will always look brighter than a T12. The cross sectional area of the T12 is pi times 1.5 inches, the T8 is 1 pi. If each lamp is producing the same lumens of UV light the surface of the T12 will be 1/1.5 less bright. However, the total light from each will be identical.
Then there is the perception of brightness as a function of wavelength (color temperature) Comparisons need to be made at the same color temperature and CRI.
If one wantst to know what gives off more light you either need to believe the data on the package or get a light meter. Looking at the lamp won't do it.
Re: Better lighting, that's why.
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Any quality fluorescent will be at least 2200 lumens and the GE SPX lamps I use are 2950 lumens. the bottom line is that one is going to have to install more 1700 lumen LED lamps to get the same light you can get from a fluorescent fixture that may already be in your shop.
The energy we use in our shops for light is so piddly compared to the 5HP motor on our SawStop that lighting operating cost is no factor. But, for those that want what is newest they are an option. Note that for those in the cold climates the energy to light the shop is free energy to heat it.
Re: Depends what you mean by "bulbs"......
Jesper, Denmark
I replaced all the incandescent bulbs and fluorescent power saving bulbs in the house lamps a couple of years ago. At the same time I split the fluorescent tube lights in the shop from just one switch into four groups, lighting different areas of my 1000 sq.ft. shop.
The house lights are much nicer with LED's, better color, instant on and no heat. There has been no bulb failures so far. The shop lights can now be just on where I work instead of having it all on. There is a total of 1 kW lights in the shop.
Annual power consumption went from a little over 5 megawatt to 3.8 megawatt. The solar voltaic panel produce 5 megawatt, so the excess is sold back to the power company.
Re: Better lighting, that's why.
walta
Bill do me a favor put 2 in your shop and take a look before you poopoo them based solely base on numbers printed on boxes.
My eyes may lie to me some times but the 6.5 horse power number printed on the shop vac box is a whopper.
Walta
horsepower and torque
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Walta, to be clear I don't care what you believe. But I do want to provide data and information to others that have these question. They too can believe what they want.
HP is torque times motor RPM. One can generate, and justifiably claim, a lot of HP from a piddly motor turning fast. Such a motor will not deliver the torque necessary to plow through 8/4 oak on a table saw at lower rpm, but it may move a lot of air at high velocity through a fan. If you think your 6.5 HP motor is not in fact a 6.5 HP motor hire a trial lawyer and file a class action suit against the seller. The payoff could be millions. As a check, find out how many watts the motor is drawing. You can then convert watts to HP as a double check.
And you can double check light output with a light meter, as a double check of the specifications on the lamp.
What is important is how much light is on the task. How many lamps it takes to get there and how to best locate these lamps is a decision to be made, and best made with the aid of a light meter. A full service lighting store may loan a meter. It takes a lot of lamps to get a third of the way to the light of a sunny day in the shade. And that is about how much light is needed for detailed tasks, if you do them.
Re: Replacement Led Bulbs
Barry Irby
I am struggling with this also.
In my shop I have a number of decrepit old fluorescent fixtures I scavenged over the years. Most are four foot T-12 fixtures. A few are 8' t-12's. I have two 8' ones that are failing.
So, On the 4' ones, do I put in two LED bulbs at a cost of $44 or buy a LED fixture from Costco for about $38? The fixture is more work because I have to remove the old fixture and install the new one. But, Does the use of the LED bulbs rely on the ballast? They are aging, you know. ( I have heard there are similar bulbs where you remove the ballast.) But if you remove the ballast, you are back to about the same amount of work to replace the fixture.
On the question of light output.....if the fixture seems brighter, is it really brighter? If your eyes work as well or better, does it matter what the meters or labels say?
And another question, All this UV light....Are we being exposed to something dangerous?
clarification
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"house lights are much nicer with LED's, better color, instant on "
what were you using for fluorescent lamps? Modern lamps have been instant on for decades.
As far as color both lamp types generate UV light that must be converted to visible light with a phosphor. They are both "fluorescent" lamps in practice. Technically, there is no reason for either lamp type to have an advantage but what may be available could differ substantially. Given that fluorescent lamps have been around for decades and have lighted every imaginable situation they are available from the manufacturer in every color temperature and wavelength distribution (CRI) imaginable, attained by diddling with the chemical composition of the phosphor. The phosphors that provide better color cost more. People that object to fluorescent lighting often have bought cheap lamps.
Re: clarification
Jesper, Denmark
Bill,
Note my differentiation between "bulbs" and "tubes".
Energy saving bulbs (as in the shape of the old incandenscent bulbs) have generally been in the warmer colors and with a rather narrow spectrum, giving an artificial look to the light. They do come on almost immediately, but tend to take some time to reach full light output and designed color. For the same lumen output, they do use more power than LED bulbs.
The shop lights are still fluorescent tubes, as LED Tube ligths are not yet available easily here.
LED bulbs can be specified in a range of color balances to suit the application - from far too warm to far too cold light. In the house, I use 4300 Kelvin LED bulbs and for spots on the lathe 6000 Kelvin.
we agree
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The fluorescent lamps (generic name for the device that makes the light) that were replacement lamps for incandescent lamps (light bulbs) suffered many disadvantages. Not the least was short life when used in a situation where the base was warm, like upside down.
Most of my house is lit with fluorescent tubes concealed behind various arrangements commercially made and home made. I like to simulate incandescent lighting for the living area so I use a high output 3000K lamp (GE SPX30). They crank out nearly 3000 lumens per lamp and have a nice spectral distribution.
For the shop I like the sun. It's high output 5000K lamps there.
this isn't complicated
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
".....if the fixture seems brighter, is it really brighter?"
What matters is how much light is on the scribe line on the dovetailed drawer side. This light comes from the surface of the fluorescent lamp. A T12 has 50% more surface area than a T8 so if each is equally bright the T12 is providing 50% more illumination. The surface area of a LED is tiny. They must be dazzling bright to equal the illumination from the large area of a tube.
It takes a bunch of fluorescent fixtures to equal a third of the light in a shady spot on a sunny day, the amount needed for detailed work. But the absolute amount of light being generated by the lamp is part of the success in seeing your scribe line. Lamp placement and intensity of background are also important and some claim wavelength distribution is also significant. Demanding lighting situations keeps lighting engineers employed, or the technical staff of a full service lighting shop. A light meter is an important tool for their work.
Brother in law the lighting engineer tells me there is indeed a psychological component too. So if you think you see improvement from the latest LED lighting you may in fact see better from it. For those more data driven read the specification on the box. More lumens means more light on the scribe line. Optimum color temperature and high CRI may make you feel better working under this light, what ever the source.
Lumens vs lux, light meters
John K Jordan
As mentioned, it can be difficult to compare light sources. It is best to compare them side-by-side. Second best, use a light meter. However, even with a meter the numbers can be confusing.
A light meter measures the light intensity at a particular point at a certain distance, typically reported in "lux.". Move the meter closer and the numbers go up. Move the meter around to the other side of the light and the reading may be different.
Light bulb intensity is typically advertised as a number of "lumens." The luminous flux is a measure of the total amount of visible light emitted by the source. Since light intensity is different at different points (e.g. the side vs the front) the lumen value is measured in the laboratory by inserting the light into a calibrated "integrating sphere", a hollow, opaque sphere painted flat white inside. These are very expensive - we had a small one, maybe 18" diameter, when I worked in a lighting research laboratory. (We were developing solar light collectors which brought light into a building through fiber optic cables.) I suspect some companies who make light bulbs don't even have an integrating sphere. It is difficult or impossible to measure lumens accurately any other way.
You cannot compare the lumen value on the package to the lux value from a meter. In addition, the seller often lies and estimates or calculates the "theoretical" total lumen output.
Since the lumen value is the total output in all directions, the fixture a bulb is mounted in makes a huge difference. The best will reflect and redirect light with mirrored surfaces.
In addition, the wide dynamic range of the human eye makes it nearly impossible to evaluate light intensity without instruments or side-by-side comparison.
If going for the maximum intensity, I would use a light meter held at the same distance from each. It is important the bulb is mounted in the fixture that would be used in the shop. Turn off all other lights and measure at points directly below and at recorded distances around the fixture. This is a pain. Far better to buy one of each and temporarily mount on the ceiling. Return the loser or use it elsewhere.
If going for the best shop lighting per buck, you of course have to consider the expected lifetime, energy costs, color temperature, and effective spread.
Re: Replacement Led Bulbs *LINK*
Grant in Iowa
Barry,
As a facility manager, I feel qualified to answer at least some of your questions.
First thing I would suggest is for you to determine what, if any, rebates are available from your electric company. Rebates for LED lighting are somewhat common, and so you may find they will help defray the cost of new energy star LED fixtures.
On the wisdom of using your existing fixtures, I would say "if" they look good and can house the LED retrofit, then sure...use them. On the other hand, I would probably avoid using the cylindrical LED "tube replacements", because some of the light energy that Bill aptly points out is emitted radially from the tubes, might not make it efficiently towards the work surface. Kind of depends on the fixture. One might observe that some diffuse lighting is useful, but it does end up being less light on the work surface.
I would definitely NOT use a solution that keeps the existing ballast in place, because there is likely a second device in the retrofit bulb that converts it back to something the LED's can actually use, thereby wasting energy in conversion twice via heat. Bill is right that in the winter, this is actually not as wasteful, however, you will then be paying electric rates for heat, when you'd probably be better off not doing so year round, and instead using natural gas in winter where it is available to create heat.
I am a fan of the new LED edge lit panels. Commonly available as 2x2 and 2x4 troffer models, these units use a panel not unlike modern flat panel televisions, or computer monitors. They produce their light in a near linear fashion across the panel, thereby creating an efficient directional light source that is uniformly bright across its width. If you look around, you can find the 2x2 versions under $100 each. With the rebate available at my energy supplier, these can be had for $50 each. I think the more desirable variety is known as an "Edge lit LED panel". I have linked to a few options from one vendor at the bottom of the page.
Read the fine print for qualifying for rebates BEFORE you buy anything. They usually require an energy star rating on eligible fixtures to qualify.
"So, On the 4' ones, do I put in two LED bulbs at a cost of $44 or buy a LED fixture from Costco for about $38? The fixture is more work because I have to remove the old fixture and install the new one. But, Does the use of the LED bulbs rely on the ballast? They are aging, you know. ( I have heard there are similar bulbs where you remove the ballast.) But if you remove the ballast, you are back to about the same amount of work to replace the fixture." The end result is probably not as efficient as a new fixture designed to reflect the light that the LED lamps are creating towards the work surface, so I would not likely do the retrofit, and would instead opt for an entirely new fixture.
"On the question of light output.....if the fixture seems brighter, is it really brighter? If your eyes work as well or better, does it matter what the meters or labels say?" I can say that LED's do have a bit of a flaw. They are very good at producing a narrow frequency range of light, which is part of why they are so efficient. This means that they don't do "daylight replication" as well as plain old incandescent light bulbs. Nor do fluorescents, however, for that matter. The technology does improve constantly for both, however.
"And another question, All this UV light....Are we being exposed to something dangerous?" Again, LED's are good at having a tight bandwidth, and as such can be had that create a minimum UV index. Most LED's don't make much UV, unless you want them to. Here's a link to more on the subject
http://www.leapfroglighting.com/lighting_and_uv_radiation/
With a 50,000 hour MTB(mean time between failure), these fixtures would last 17 years operating 8 hours per day, 365 days per year, on average. And they tend to have a 5 year warranty. By contrast, I have changed over 250 T-8 and T5 fluorescent bulbs in three years in our 50,000 square foot facility at a cost of $4-$7 per bulb. None of the bulbs were under warranty, whereas the LED fixtures often have a 5 year warranty as I've said. Choose your color temperature the same as Fluorescents, be happy, lower your energy bills.
Have I done this in my shop? Not yet. It is on my short list after doing the math for work enough times to know that the payback can be as little as nine months (for fixtures in 24/7 and self installed), and usually around four or five years. Heck, the fixtures are warranted that long. And those numbers are comparing them to T-5 fluorescent fixtures (again, 24/7).
Do your own homework, your mileage will vary. There's no such thing as a free lunch, yadayadayada.
Regards,
Grant in Iowa
drop in LED panels
question
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
At some point in your woodworking life one is going to be way more concerned about getting enough light on a scribe line to split it with a saw and a lot less whether it costs 30 or 50 cents to light the shop for a woodworking session. A 2 x 4 toffer can deliver 8000 to 12000 lumens over a bench depending on the lamp, or twice that for T5HO fixtures. How much light does the edge lit 2 x4 put out?
After some years or working at it I finally got about a third the light of a sunny day in the shade on my bench surface (it took 8 T5HO lamps to get there which replaced twice that of T8's.) Visitors to the shop marvel at how bright the bench area is illuminated. It is easy to see detail.
The bottom line of all this is if you can see fine for what you do then factors other than light output drives the decision. If you need more light to see what you need to do, or the shop is not pleasant to work in because it is poorly lit either in intensity or color, then worry about the cheapest way to buy lumens of a desirable wavelength.
Re: Better lighting, that's why.
R. Payne
So are you trying to mis-lead people by comparing a "quality fluorescent" bulb at 2200 lumens to a standard LED at 1700?
Quality LEDs can put out as much or more light than a fluorescent. A better LED strip can put out over 400 lumen per linear foot meaning an 8' strip would create 3200 lumens and that output is directional so nothing is lost by being bounced off the reflective back as in a fluorescent fixture (which means a lower lumen output LED puts more light on the workbench where it counts, this measurement is either in lux or footcandles).
As I said I recently spent several hours a day for a couple of week researching lighting for work (illuminating signage so it had to be right) and at the same quality level LEDs blew flourescents out of the water.
Re: Better lighting, that's why.
TomD
I don't know where I read it but it went like this: "people hate fluorescents and love LEDs". That is pretty much it. It is a generalization though, there are some Fluros I like such as daylight colour for certain kinds of work, as with fabric or fly tying.
LEDs and UV
Walt
Near the top of a google search:
http://www.leapfroglighting.com/lighting_and_uv_radiation
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lighting and UV radiation: where do LEDs fit in?
September 12, 2012 | Stephen Naor | 2 Comments
Some industry sources claim that LEDs produce no UV radiation. This actually isn’t true. LEDs do produce a small amount of UV, but they emit even less. That’s because the amount that is produced is converted to white light by the phosphors inside the lamp.
So, why care about UV emissions?
Mostly because UV radiation occupies that part of the electromagnetic spectrum that forces us to slather on sunscreen in periods of peak sunlight. In high doses, UV causes sunburns, cataracts, and skin cancer. You’re not likely to suffer such effects from most artificial light sources, although a recent move to phase out incandescent lamps in Canada led one federal government department to assess whether UV radiation from CFLs exceeded current exposure guidelines. While the Natural Resources Canada study found that “at a distance of 30 cm, (and by extension greater distances), the bulbs do not pose a significant risk of acute injury to the eyes or skin, as compared to traditional incandescent lamps”, the study also recommends “…that single envelope CFLs not be used at distances less than 30 cm to avoid any long-term health effects in the general population.”
Unless you’re lighting your home, office, or factory with tanning-bed lamps, the main concern with certain lighting types—including CFLs and high-intensity discharge (HID) lamps—is that they emit enough UV to damage artwork and fabrics over time. High quality LEDs—thanks to their low UV emissions—are now the lighting type of choice for museums striving to protect treasured artifacts and maintain their original colors and patina. In commercial and residential applications, LEDs save carpets, window coverings, and painted surfaces from the degrading effects of UV radiation.
LEDs offer relief from another pesky problem—insects. UV light attracts insects. If you’ve ever seen—and heard—a black-light bug zapper at work, you know the strange command UV radiation seems to hold over insects. With virtually no UV emissions, LEDs do not attract bugs, and that’s made them popular in commercial food-service applications, residential kitchens, and exterior installations where it’s important to minimize the attraction of small flying pests.
Do you consider your application prior to selecting a lighting technology? Has UV radiation of various lighting technologies made an impact on your purchase?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't know LEDs produced any UV. It seems they can emit a little.
Re: LEDs and UV
John K Jordan
>I didn't know LEDs produced any UV. It seems they can emit a little.
It depends on the design of the specific LED. They can be manufactured to put out UV wavelengths, a little or a lot.
I bought several portable LED lights JUST for the UV. Light in the 365 nm range is perfect for fluorescence testing to identify or eliminate certain wood species. For example, Black Locust glows brightly. Unfortunately, the people selling these lamps often apparently don't even know the wavelengths or are prone to lie about it. Several I bought advertised at 365 nm were evidently centered closer to 400 nm, overlapping the blue end of the visible spectrum and drowning out the fluorescence. (I don't have an instrument to measure the wavelength; just going on comparisons with other UV emitters.)
My experience makes me believe any LED light you buy could indeed have a strong UV component. I might wonder about those with a bluish tint. I have no idea how much UV light is in a typical high quality or cheap overhead LED light fixture.
JKJ
Re: LEDs and UV
John McGaw
In reality, a properly-designed 'white' LED will produce only a minute amount of any UV since the phosphors are there to convert any UV to visible light. Any leakage is a matter of the conversion efficiency. Some of these LEDs have a yellowish casting resin which will further limit UV radiation while tuning the visible emissions.
You will find that the same problem, if it is a problem, exists at a larger scale in fluorescent lamps. Their sole source of radiation is ionized gas inside which emits strong UV ('bare' fluorescent tubes have been used for decades for sterilization) which is converted by the white powder coating the internal surface to visible light. I used to have a PROM eraser which used the UV from a bare fluorescent tube to provide the necessary high-flux radiation to erase the chips. This was back in the 70s when a 1K memory chip was considered a minor miracle of technology.
Re: question *LINK*
Grant in Iowa
Hi Bill,
As usual, I respect your wisdom and perspective, as it appears you have, as usual, a well thought out lighting solution in place and working nicely for you. At 47, I am only beginning to find vision can be a limiting factor, and can only imagine the problems I will face as age creeps up. I can't profess to know what it will take at that point, but I am confident that a solution will be available.
To answer your question about lumens output, GE offers edge lit 2x2 drop in troffer light panels that put out as much as 4500 lumens. There are other vendors offering a 2x4 with as much as 9000 lumens output, but we'll consider them an outlier for now and focus on the GE line. They offer a 2x4, which seems to have only the same light output (4500 at most). Presumably, they decided it either wasn't possible, necessary, or that it would be difficult to market a higher rating. If one was so inclined, one could put 2 each 2x2 edge lit LED troffers in place of a single 2x4 for a combined 9000 lumens. That said, I think a better approach would be to space the 2x2 troffers out, rather than place them next to one another. They do also offer two light distribution patterns for a wider or a narrower pattern.
I had privilege of standing in a small retail store in Chicago where these panels were installed, and I recall thinking that it was like being outside on an overcast day. Everything in the space was very well lit. And that was two years ago when the technology was just hitting the market. We are a couple generations from that now (yeah, it is moving that fast).
There's perhaps more here than meets the eye to think about, and I don't claim to have all of the answers, but some thoughts on the subject:
1. I'm not sure the lumens measuring tools were designed to measure the tight bandwidth that LED's tend to create, so perception may not equal the measured output. I know that our curator has had to purchase a special light meter to test whether the installed LED's exceed the recommended light dosage for a given artifact. Apparently they type of light is different than incandescent, and thus requires an equipment change. I am admittedly ignorant on exactly why.
2. I believe that LED edge lit panels tend to produce an evenly diffuse light, while simultaneously directing ALL of that light in one general direction. The evenly diffuse feature is a significant positive (in my opinion) when thinking about task lighting and the negative effects of shadowing. The directive nature of the panels also lends itself well to task lighting, me thinks. Of course my experience is based on being on one space (a retail store) with such lighting and noticing how well it was lit overall.
3. Good color rendering is important to adequate shop lighting, especially for staining and finishing. This is an area where LED lighting may or may not excel. I simply don't know, as I haven't tried them in that environment. I would postulate, however, that if LED's fall short in this area, they will continue to improve at a rapid rate until they are satisfactory.
I approach every day with immense curiosity, and a dose of skepticism. I don't believe I am a premature bandwagon jumper with LED edge lit lighting. Many of the various versions of LED lights we each have seen to date are less than ideal. They can be harsh and somewhat monochromatic, but they are improving rapidly. What is new today is considered obsolete in a year or so due to the rate of progress being made in the sector. One thing you can take to the bank and consider a "quote from Grant" is that they *will* outperform fluorescent lighting in every way within a few years, if not already. We might not be there just yet, but we are moving along the path quickly. As more vendors compete and offer options, pricing will come down to where you and I can afford them easily. The rebates also help make the technology affordable.
In closing, I'd like to say we each make the best decision we can at decision time. That doesn't mean that it will still be the best decision for everyone down the road. My objective in sharing what I know today is to help arm others with viable options so they too make the best decision at their decision time. I am not so arrogant as to think that my best decision today will be such eternally.
FWIW,