Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Butt hinge installation question

Posts

Butt hinge installation question

#1

Butt hinge installation question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Early in my woodworking when I knew little I had a time centering hinge screws in the hinge holes. I discovered the Vix-bit crutch and moved on to other concerns. Hence, I remain inexperienced centering screws in hinge holes. I am now faced with centering a #3 screw for which there is no Vix-bit crutch.

In detail, how do you all ensure the pilot holes for butt hinges are accurately centered in the hinge holes?

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#2

Re: Butt hinge installation question

mdclor

Bill, I secure the hinge in place with double stick tape and carefully center a pointed punch in place by eye then tap it gently to make a mark in the tape. If I am happy with that, I place the punch in the mark and tap it hard enough to mark the wood. I will be interested to see the better options others suggest.

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#3

For 3/4/6 screws

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I take a 20p nail and grind a "blunt" point on it that will fit the bevel on the hinge holes but project beyond the hinge a tad. I then locate the hinge with tape and a combo square. Tap the nail into the hole and you have a center mark on which to put your 1/16" drill. I do one hole at each end of the hinge, then recheck the other end with the square , then do the 2nd. When set on the ends, I do the middle hole(s).

Haven't sprung one yet.

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#4

Screw punch, or

Dick Coers

You can also use the Vix bit if it will still center up in the hinge. I drill just deep enough to mark the wood, the use the proper size pilot drill.

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#5

Re: Butt hinge installation question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

...how do you all ensure the pilot holes for butt hinges are accurately centered in the hinge holes?

Hi Bill

Actually, you really do not want this.

I've used self-centering punches and drills, but find that they may still drill and off-centre hole. The problem is that this hole may end up on the wrong side of the centre.

Ideally, one wants a hole that is very slightly off the centre so that the screw pulls the butt hinge tightly against the back edge of the mortice. To do this I locate the mark with an awl.

On a related note, I recently attended a short workshop run by a local very high-end furnituremaker. It was interesting the lengths he goes to when installing butt hinges.

In addition to also marking the screw position with an awl, he will only drill the holes on the drill press (which means that the mortices are planned beforehand), pointing out that it is the off-vertical alignment that causes problems. He will also test-fit the screw in the hinge beforehand, and use a chamfer bit to improve the fit where necessary. All hinges are filed square and parallel beforehand, as he finds that even high quality brass hinges are usually out. And at the end, he will polish the tops of the screws to remove machine marks. Yes, his work wins awards.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#6

Re: Butt hinge installation question

William Duffield

I use one of these:

http://www.starrett.com/metrology/product-detail/819

However, it does not work for #3 screws. The tapered sleeve is too big to fit in the countersink.

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#7

Re: Butt hinge installation question

BrianMonumentCO

1. attach the hinge to the wood with ds tape.

2. Drill and install screw TWO methods.

Method A

2a. Then center the holes for the screws.

2b Then drill the holes with a progression of bits (if doing it freehand)

accuracy/completeness can be checked after each bit...... And then adjusted if necessary.

2c install screws

Method B

2a. use the vix type bit or any bit that has a "jig" that matches my hinge.

ie something that matches the recess for the head of the screw.

2b. install screws

3. with hinge attached by screws layout for mortice (except depth).

4. mortice for the hinge.

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#8

comments....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I've used self-centering punches and drills, but find that they may still drill an off-center :) hole. The problem is that this hole may end up on the wrong side of the centre......Indeed, if the Vix-bit is not perpendicular to the work it drills an off-center hole. On the other hand I have successfully drilled hundreds of holes with the Vix-bit for architectural hinges and furniture.

Ideally, one wants a hole that is very slightly off the centre so that the screw pulls the butt hinge tightly against the back edge of the mortice. To do this I locate the mark with an awl.....the problem is if the wood is grainy either the awl or drill can run off center.

In addition to also marking the screw position with an awl, he will only drill the holes on the drill press (which means that the mortices are planned beforehand), pointing out that it is the off-vertical alignment that causes problems........An indisputable fact.

He will also test-fit the screw in the hinge beforehand, and use a chamfer bit to improve the fit where necessary.....given the crappy quality of hinges now days they often must be adjusted. I number them when marking the mortises to account for lack of uniform orthogonal shape and don't bother to file square.

And don't forget driving in a steel screw to cut threads for the soft brass screw.

And at the end, he will polish the tops of the screws to remove machine marks. I usually cam out the screw driver and make new scratches :)

Yes, his work wins awards......no chance of that on for my work

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#9

Re: Butt hinge installation question

Ralph Lipeles

I first mark the holes using a pencil to mark the circles. I then punch the centers locating by eye. To do the punching I use either a machinist's automatic punch or a long tapered machinist's tool that I have. It is almost a foot long and tapers from a sharp point to 1/8" by 3/8" at the other end. It's easy to align and you have leverage to just use your hands or tap the end with a small hammer.

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#10

Re: Butt hinge installation question

Barry Irby

I also use Vixbits and for architectural work I just stick them into the hole and slam them home. for fine work I use the vixbit, the smallest on I have and angle it so the screw is slightly off center to the rear and the screw pulls the hinge tight into the mortise.

I had a project that required about sixty hinges and had not discovered Vixbits. I made a steel plate the same size as the hinge plate and carefully centered the holes in it. Then I used it as a template and it worked great. It was really quick. I did learn to check it against the hinge plates. There was some variation but I just matched them up and did not use the hinges that had wandering holes. The steel guide plate helped the bit to resist sliding off the harder grain. Now that I think about this, its a better idea than it sounds, even for a few hinges.

Forty some years ago I bought doors for a house that were not pre-hung. The carpenters agreed to hang them for $7 a door. I stopped in to watch and was horrified to see they were driving the hinge screws with a hammer. The lead carpenter explained "hammer's for putting them in, screwdriver is for taking them out!" The house and doors are still there.

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#11

Ellis Walentine

Make a little template

Ellis Walentine

Take a little block of diffuse-porous hardwood that is the exact size of the hinge leaf and accurately drill the holes with a drill press. (I know, this whole exercise is about drilling them accurately. Well, somehow make the template accurate.)

Then use this template as a drill bushing. It has the further advantage of guiding the drill exactly perpendicular to the wood, so the flat heads of the screws are flush with the hinge.

Ellis

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#12

Re: Butt hinge installation question

David Yoho

You're talking #3 screws here. They're really small for sure. I think in this case getting the holes close enough by eye should work. Think about it - how much will they move the hinge given their small size and the fact that you are putting a tapered screw into a round hole (threads don't bite all the way down)?

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#13

transfer punches

Jerry Gibbs

I have a set of HF transfer punches in many sizes. They should allow you to at least get a center marked. The transfer punches cost about $10 at HF.

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#15

Re: BTW - Bill

joe mohnike

double stick tape your hinge in place, then use a counter sink in the screw holes, this will center the screwto the hinge.

Has worked for me, without fail, for many years

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#16

Eyeball

John in NM

I usually eyeball it with a tapered twist bit. Tapered bits seem to stay centered more easily, and if one is watching closely it is possible to correct problem holes before they get too deep - the mess from the correction is drilled out by the fatter part of the bit.

Usually, that is sufficient, and when it's not I'm not fully convinced any other technique (within reason) would do much better.

Re: Butt hinge installation question

#17

Re: Eyeball

Barry Irby

I have a friend that set up the machinery to make aluminum cans. Some of it had to within a few thousands of an inch. He said you can "see" 5 thousandths. In other words, if your hole is within 5 thousandths of and inch of being centered, it will appear "close enough".