Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

How would you "Hinge" this?

Posts

How would you "Hinge" this?

#1

Alan Young

How would you "Hinge" this?

Alan Young

I am finishing up the design for a cabinet that will incorporate a large Stained Glass window already owned by the client. The window will be set into a frame(Recessed lip back side of the Frame) as the only door on the upper part-Two doors on the lower section will have overlay details that mimics the design from the stained glass. All three doors will be flush mounted to the front of the cabinet- not inset and no partial overlay.

I am trying to figure out if the hinges should be hidden as much as possible or be made part of the visual presentation.




Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#2

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

William Duffield

Have you considered knife hinges? You can make them as large and robust as you want (as required by the heavy glass panel) and they wouldn't be any more intrusive than small ones. With your machining skills, you shouldn't have any trouble making them.

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#3

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

Keith Newton

Knife hinges for the glass door, and full overlay European for the lower ones.

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#4

Exactly


Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#5

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

Barry Irby

I agree. The only second thought I had was perhaps a piano Hinge at the top, but then I don't have the ability to make knife hinges. If I could make knife hinges, I might use them in all three places.

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#6

Alan Young

Knife hinges

Alan Young

aren't knife hinges usually used for inset applications? Due to many requirements not discussed in my original post-The doors must be attached to the full face of the cabinet. I searched and looked at a bunch of knife hinges-They all seemed to work with inset doors as they would attach to the upper section of the frame and to the top of the door then the lower section of the frame and bottom of each door..


Am I missing and overlay application of knife hinges?

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#7

Re: Knife hinges

walta

If the goal of this piece is to show off your wood working skills then go with the knife hinges.

If the goal is fast efficient and adjustable alter the design to make room for European hinges.

You did not ask but let me suggest the frame for the glass door is very delicate and that looks great. But this door must live in a world where wood want to twist and cup and people hang on doors. You are asking a lot from a joint that is maybe 1.25 inches wide.

If a hidden steel frame is the thing that makes your design work it is no crime to use one.

Walta

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#8

Re: Knife hinges

Keith Newton

While the cranked hinge that you show will work, a straight will also work, only the center of pivot would be off the end, rather than in front.

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#9

Durability

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Foremost I would worry about a durable hinge for what I suppose will be a heavy upper door. Personally I would have no objection to owning this cabinet with traditional hinges, but better in some subdued kind of brass finish, not bright.

Traditional hinges last for centuries of use. Will knife hinges...I really don't know?

While common in studio furniture that I see in my limited gallery furniture exposure, I recoil at the sight of all that hardware when I open a door on a cabinet and encounter a "kitchen cabinet hinge" (I suppose they have a name). My first impression is , doesn't this maker know how to install a butt hinge ?

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#10

Clarification if needed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are two kinds of knife hinges. You illustrated the kind for inset doors. There is a straight variety that will work in principal, if it is durable enough.

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#11

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

William Duffield

In one of James Krenov's books, he described how he made knife hinges. They're supposedly a lot easier to make from brass than you might think.

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#12

Ellis Walentine

Either way would work

Ellis Walentine

This cabinet is traditional enough in its design that antique brass or bronze butt hinges would look just fine. If cleanliness of line is paramount, knife hinges would work for the bottom doors, although they're a heck of a lot fussier to install than butts. The space under the top door, which I assume is to allow for sagging -- not a bad idea considering the relative pliability of this construction as shown -- would mean you'd need some kind of riser block or a spacer washer between the door and the cabinet below.

Regarding the upper door frame, the diminutive size of the stiles and rails will add to the flexibility of the door, which isn't an issue unless it is mishandled. In defense of thin frames, I've made cabinet doors where the glass itself provides the rack resistance in the X-Y plane, and the frame, per se, is more of a border than a support system. Again, design for the way you expect the client to use and care for the cabinet; or don't take any chances, and beef up the frame.

Ellis

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#13

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

BobS

Straight knife hinges would work well for the bottom doors and they aren't overly difficult to install except that you need to route for them before assembling the cabinet.

Make it easy on yourself and just buy your hinges from Brusso, they have a variety of sizes and I would bet you can't make them for $20 a pair.

The upper door looks like it would benefit from butt hinges and you could patina them to match the wood color fairly well if you can't find a color you like. Whitechapel sells a variety in several colors.

Bob

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#14

Alan Young

Thanks for all the comments

Alan Young

Lots of good information here for me to ponder-I am reminded-I hope not too late of a quote I heard from Richard Jones aka Sgian Dubh "Design from the hardware"...In a sense I have a done this so far as the clients have the stained glass window and bun feet that they want used in the piece-as well as space requirements that control outer dimensions. In my original post I had asked whether hinges that were very visible-aka part of the design effect would be appropriate for this piece-like wrap around strap hinges for example-No one seemed to think that was a viable direction-I am not inclined at all towards the European hinges-we have a set on some cabinets at work that are always coming dislodged and as Bill T suggested I just don't like seeing that mass of metal when I open a cabinet. The knife hinge is definitely a candidate- especially for the bottom doors- I have only used these once in my ww'king experience and they were a technical challenge-probably worth the effort for this piece. The frame for the upper stained glass window is 1 5/8 in full width with a 3/8 rabbet on the back side-I think that will be enough for two to four butt hinges that I will recess into mortises both on the door frame and the case frame. I may come up with some sort of devise that will counter balance the door when it is shut-some spring loaded button on the base of the opening side etc... So thanks again for the discussions--Alan

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#15

Same here...

John in NM

Though I have fewer reservations about knife hinges, Euro hinges I wouldn't even use on a kitchen. In my experience (being asked about problems with ~10 year old stuff) they sag with use. Perhaps this is brand specific, perhaps this can be adjusted out as needed - but I'm always left wondering why they didn't simply use a decent butt hinge instead. Easy to install and durable.

Re: How would you "Hinge" this?

#16

Button on the base

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For knife hinges Krenox often (always?) put a button under the door to support it when closed. This addition would not be necessary with 2-3 butt hinges supporting the door.

Butt barrels are typically partially buried. In some dull finish they will hardly be noticed. The glass is such a focal point I think the partially exposed barrels with not be noticed at all.

I am comforted that someone else is put off by masses of metal when opening an otherwise fine cabinet and encountering kitchen cabinet hinges.