I have just completed installing over 600 sq./ft. of 3/4 inch red oak flooring in my living room and dining room. It is unfinished wood. When I see "DIY" shows on tv, and unfinished oak flooring has been installed, there is always someone down on their knees with a 6 inch putty knife spreading wood filler. There in lies
my problem. I have done the rest of my house and I used a red oak filler from "big box stories" and I am not happy with the results. Does anyone know of a better red oak wood filler that does not dry so fast that you waste as much as you use. Any and all advise is welcome and appreciated..
First off, and please don't take this wrong, but red oak would have been my last choice. I greatly prefer white oak flooring. Around here when this house was built, red oak flooring cost more than white oak.
Now, are you asking about a wood putty or a wood filler? The putty would be used for filling voids like tear-out and the filler would normally be used to fill the open grain of such woods before applying a stain and topcoat.
If you are asking about a putty, I like Timbermate. If you're talking about a filler I can't help. It seems to me you shouldn't need to fill the grain of a hardwood floor. If so, there are better choices of wood that don't need it to have a polished look.
If so, then it would not work well. If the edges are tight, then I would use a solvent based paste wood filler. I think Mylands still makes it. Tons of work, and a bale of cotton rags will be needed.
Unfortunately you might not get the same resulting finished look if you use a different product now. Would the manufacturer be able to offer some suggestions to reduce the amount of waste?
I have already put over 1500 sq./ft. of red oak down in the rest of the house. This may be your last pick of wood but it is my first and only pick that I want. The wood filler is used to fill any void there. Small cracks between boards and a joint that is off. The filler I have used, I am not happy with. Dries too quick and there is too much waste. Water based filler seems to be the pick of all who write in so we will do a test spot and see how it works out. Thanks for your answer...
I had pretty much the same scenario when I constructed a room addition to my existing red oak floored house. I hired a hardwood flooring professional (as I didn't have the time to install the flooring myself) and I saw that he used the following product. I had used this same product on a remodel I did on another house (also red oak floors). The big box stores don't carry this stuff. It might be difficult to find locally as, only vendors that supply to pros seem to offer this product.
I'm sure there may be some other brands. But to fill in any open grain and gaps, this stuff needs to be spread all around the entire floor. The key word to look for is "trowelable". I guess that accurately describes the process of apply this stuff. I trowelled/spread this stuff with a trowel, making sure to press the stuff in perpendicular to the grain and gaps as to avoid pulling the stuff as would happen if you scrape off excess putty with the grain. The wood filler woodworkers typically use on furniture as purchased at the big box stores don't really work. Any extra dried putty will be sanded off when you prep you floors before applying your finish. I've seen the stuff work in person and it works.
I have installed and finished several floors and I have seen many more installed, all red oak, which was by far the most popular wood flooring for decades. I have never seen or heard of troweling on something before applying the finish. In my experience if the floor has gaps it wasn't put down properly.
What is this stuff supposed to do? Is the use of this stuff something to do with the crummy quality of today's oak strip flooring or the use of water based finishes? Or is it some regional thing I have never encountered. What ever the case it was not something necessary in the past.
I can only speak to what I've seen. I guess this serves as a grain filler and gap filler (if there are any). I definitely can see a difference in the finish product-after the finish is applied, the floor reflects light evenly. I'm guessing the grain filling quality and subsequent sanding makes the surface uniform. I'm sure any floor would be fine without this extra step, but my OCD wife definitely likes how no dirt can get lodged in the wood grain since it's all filled up and sanded flat.
I have lived on hardwood floors for most of 60 years and never had anything lodge in pores. Three coats of durable varnish fills them.
If this stuff prevents cracks that would be a miracle.....but don't count on it. Calculate how much a floor expands and contracts in a season of humidity and the cracks that open in the winter will come as an expected event.
But for those looking for a plastic floor effect the extra work of applying it should pay off.
The hardwood floor guys use a mix of laquer & fine, 150 grit cut or so, saw dust. Works like a charm. They would have a 5 gallon bucket of laquer they would dump sawdust into till it was thick enough & trowel it in the cracks, splits, occasional knot, & then it would sand off without a problem. Sets fast too, doesn't swell or stain the wood. Use a respirator if you do a lot of it.