Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

A "Cheap" question....

Posts

A "Cheap" question....

#1

A "Cheap" question....

Edward in Vancouver

Need to replace our kitchen cabinets, rather than rip out everything we discussed just replacing the doors. Wife loves the look of white glossy laminate, and I talked her into a plain maple edging aprox 3/16" thick around the door edges.

Current doors are mdf with a "frame and panel" pattern routed into it. I could toss out all the doors and start with fresh 3/4" ply, but I was thinking of reusing the existing doors.

-Option 1 would be to plug the hinge pockets on the backs of the doors and use this as the "show" face. After all, I'll be glueing down laminate on the surface.

-Option 2 would be to plug the routed channels as best as possible with spruce, and fill in the remaining gaps with drywall compound or similar, and use this as the show face.

What I'm concerned about is that I might get lines from the gaps telegraphing through the laminate in a few years time.

-Option 3 is to toss out the doors, and buy in a couple sheets of 3/4 ply. Getting rid of the existing doors will have some problems, and breaking down sheets will also have problems giving my space constraints.

Talking to a laminate supplier, I understand there are two thicknesses of laminate, and it is best to use the thicker, as any surface imperfections will telegraph through. I also understand that I need to laminate the backs of the doors or I will incur cupping.

Suggestions?

Edward

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#2

Re: A "Cheap" question....

Barry Irby

I suspect the doors you have now are some sort of high density particle board Or fiber board. The grooves were routed in and a sheet of melamine (plastic) was vacuum formed over them. (I see then often on home Inspections with the plastic layer coming loose/failing.) While they don't last forever they generally last well. The plastic layer is very thin and the edge is solid white, thus does not show much or at all.

Plastic laminate sheets have a backer layer that is dark brown. The thinner Vertical grade will have less of and edge, but it will still show. Even more so on the standard thickness, especially on the white version.

I would investigate buying a new set of vacuum formed doors. It will be a lot easier. There are many sources on the Internet.

(I actually don't "like" this piece of advice. I am a do it yourself guy and woudl rather work hours to save a nickle.) At the very least make a practice door to see how you like it.

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#3

Re: A "Cheap" question....

Dick Coers

Does the maple edging go on before or after the laminate? Before is good, after is bad. With after, you have a crack all around the face of the door for any moisture to possible leak through. Also the clear finish is really tough to apply. A couple of sheets of plywood is also not a good idea. Buying flat plywood is a near impossibility these days. You'll be fighting twist and warp with that option. Like Barry said, price out replacement doors. Gloss laminate takes critical care while working and trimming. Have you priced contact cement lately? It's expensive, as is the laminate. You might be able to buy doors for not much more than materials.

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#4

Re: A "Cheap" question....

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Edward,

You'll find lots of cheapo laminate doors in most any size you need. Since SWMBO wants them edge banded, that will present you with problems for ready-mades. You can, however do well on your own. A suggestion:

1 Decide on your edge banding (say 1/2" oak, cherry, etc.)

2 Figure your plywood needs and cut you door blanks to allow for the extra 1/2" all around

3 Cut your ply blanks

4 Laminate the backs only

5 Put on your edge banding to it's flush with the back surface

6 When the glue dries, use a belt sander to get the edge banding flush with the front surface.

7 Laminate the fronts covering the edge banding.

8 Now use a chamfering bit to trim back the front edges, putting a nice bevel on the front edges of the doors and revealing 1/4-3/8" of your banding. You can also use a round over bit, but the chamfer looks more contemporary. Carefully apply finish to the exposed wood. Drill your hinge cups, etc.

Suggestion 2:

a - Fill the current front details with bondo and wood strips and belt sand to get off any ridges.

b - "laminate" the fronts with 1/4 plywood to give you a smooth front surface.

c - trim the doors to allow for the thickness of the edge banding

d - Do 5-8 above (omitting the new hinges)

Vertical grade laminate is fine for doors

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#5

Clint Searl

Re: A "Cheap" question....

Clint Searl

Sounds like a career opportunity with lots of chances for expensive screw-ups. Buy finished replacements, and be done with it.

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#6

Sheesh . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

What happened to that Yankee-Doodle Work Ethic, dedicated self-sufficient DIY- red-meat-eating, beer-drinkin', born in the USA, SPIRIT?!!!!

Buy them doors made in some sub-Asian sweatshop payin' coolie wages to kids? Not this mother's son!

No Sir-r-r-ree! These doors is gon-be all-American, even though they might cost 3 times the price o' them others. Even though there might be a few gets trashed durin' trainin', this job'll be done an finished with no beholdin' to no-o-o-o body.

Oh, almost for-got, how much was thet bridge y'all were sellin'?

:D :D :D :D :D

{Edward, do whatever it takes to make her happy. Those nickels will come back to you dressed up like dollars} ;)

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#7

Re: A "Cheap" question....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Are we talking about Formica type laminate? This stuff is stiff and hard. I can't imagine anything telegraphing through it even if the routed pattern was not filled. I would think you could reduce the size of the existing door, add the maple with a prefinished edge, slap on the laminate, route off the overhanging edge and be ready to reinstall the hinge.

I never worked with MDF. Can you glue a maple strip to it?

Alternatively get the local source of MDF to break the sheets down to a smaller size and make new doors.

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#8

Re: A "Cheap" answer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I never worked with MDF. Can you glue a maple strip to it?

The edge of MDF is a sponge; it'll suck glue away from the joint like a . . . .

Putting wood on it for a glue joint means preparing the MDF face with several applications of glue before trying to fix the edge. Biscuits or a spline will help a good deal toward a solid joint.

Yeah, I know they built a bridge out of that stuff, but I'm not about to drive across it! :D

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#9

Re: A "Cheap" question....

Edward in Vancouver

O.K. thanks for the replies

The existing doors are 3/4 mdf with a pattern routed into it, there is no laminate or covering, just paint.

All the cabinets plus the bath vanity equal to about 3 sheets of surface area. It will be hard for me to dispose of all those doors, but I can figure out something. Then again, why should I throw the doors out if I'm going to cover them with laminate?

I could get some 1/8 luan door skins or hardboard to glue on to the doors, or I could go whole hog and get some 3/4" ply and do the deed. I think I'm going to experiment with glueing on some maple strips onto mdf scrap and see how well it holds on.

I can also get contact cement by the gallon at the laminate shop at reasonable prices compared to quarts at the borg. Then again, I've had great success glueing 4x8' laminate sheets to commercial kitchen walls with construction adhesitive several years ago, and also have glued laminate to ply with regular yellow glue with good success.

Yes, I can get the doors from a cabinet place, but then I have to come up with good arguements on why I need a tablesaw and other tools in the garage.....

The laminate in question is a glossy white formica brand.

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#10

TOOLS? . . .  Dude

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

She WILL buy the TOOLS. You just have to use them!

BTW. In case you're in Vancouver BC, (Rather that Vancouver, WA) please excuse the red-neck jingoistic faux philippic. Canadians are entitled to be self-reliant as well :D :D

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#11

paint a problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The best contact cement is solvent based. It is formulated in a very strong solvent that I expect will attach paint, well, like paint stripper. The paint may be a deal breaker for using the existing doors.

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#12

Ellis Walentine

More to think about

Ellis Walentine

Edward, if it were me, I'd have someone make the doors for me. They aren't that expensive, and making them yourself is going to be a nightmare, regardless of how you do it. The main deal breaker is the solid wood edging around the HPL/MDF doors. You certainly can glue solid wood to MDF (prime coat with glue first, as Mark suggested), but it is fussy work and you'd almost want to prefinish the edgebanding and glue it flush with the face laminate, otherwise you'd have to scrape it flush, which would quickly ruin the gloss finish on the laminate. Even if you could glue them dead flush, you'd have glue squeeze-out to deal with. Industrial setups use super-accurate edgebanding equipment and hot melt glue to apply solid wood edging to panels. The banders can be set up to trim the edges and ends automatically, so you get a relatively perfect job with none of the home-shop headaches.

The other perils here include ripping and crosscutting the doors to size. Laminate, especially gloss laminate, is very unforgiving of anything but the best, sharpest, most appropriate saw blades and tablesaw tuning. In industry, these kinds of cuts are done with traveling beam saws with sophisticated blades -- hi ATB, TC and sometimes ceramics. You can do it yourself, but I'd expect some chips in the edges here and there, and white gloss laminate will show them off more than other colors and sheens will.

If I haven't dissuaded you from trying this yourself, then do get the appropriate blade(s). I'd use standard HPL, as a high-gloss vertical grade laminate will have specular effects that will show up the slightest variations in flatness of your substrate. You can use vertical grade or cabinet liner laminate to balance the construction.

The ideal way to lay up the laminate is not to cut the doors to size and then laminate with contact cement, but to lay them up in sheets using PVA glue and a cold veneer press. Since you probably don't have one of those, consider getting the cabient shop down the street to lay up the sheets for you, so all you have to do is rip them on your tablesaw to make the door blanks.

Sorry to rain on this parade, but I do think you'll get a better job with a lot less aggravation if you farm it out.

Ellis

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#13

Like the song says...

David Yoho

... "You gotta know when to hold 'em and know when to fold 'em"

Sometimes being cheap is good when it saves money. I think in a case like yours with the information given, it could mean attempting to save money but with a cheap looking outcome.

As Barry pointed out, a lot of laminate has a dark backer layer that will show when trimmed. I don't know about the specific type you mentioned but the egg shell colored Formica brand laminate I've used was like that.

Also, as already mentioned, if you are not equipped to fabricate new doors or rehab the old ones, the process gets harder, which usually leads to higher cost.

I'm in agreement with the replies that say buy new by ordering pre-made or having a local shop make them. I think this is the time to "fold 'em" for the sake of saving you some grief and insuring a good outcome. After all, this is for your kitchen and possibly bathroom. These are the two rooms in a house that return the best on investment and are likely to be seen and scrutinized by your guests.

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#14

A Note on Laminates *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

While Barry is correct about the dark line reveal on the edges of most HP laminates, Formica makes a line of material that eliminates that called ColorCore where the material is the same color all the way through. In use there may still be a hair-line at the edge.

You won't find the stuff at the BORG however. Shop for a fabricator supply house

link for information


http://www.formica.com/en/us/products/colorcore2#swatchesTab

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#15

Re: A Note on Laminates

Barry Irby

I knew about the ColorCore stuff, but never used any. The Old Fuddy Duddy in me is skeptical. I don't like the idea that they changed "everything" about the backing and I'm supposed to believe its fine. I suspect its significantly more expensive.

I am pretty sure the horizontal grade (thicker stuff) will work for this, but show an edge, and not telegraph the sub-straight. The vertical grade might, probably would.

Re: A "Cheap" question....

#16

Re: A Note on Laminates

Edward in Vancouver

Thanks all.

For all that its worth, it would make sense to buy in the doors, and I'll probably end up doing this.

That being said, I have had success with laminate covered doors with wood edging for other projects--which is why I choose this project.

Typically, I cut the laminate with a carbide knife oversized, glue it down, and trim it flush with a router. I prepare the edging strips to size, put roundovers on the edges, finish them with a film finish, and scrape the backs clean. Then I glue them. The glue won't stick to the finished areas of the prepared banding, nor will it stick to laminate, so squeeze out isn't much of an issue. In the past I've done this by laying the door down on a flat table and using a few C clamps to make sure the edging is flush with the laminate, then clamp the top and bottom edges of the door first. A day later I trim the ends of this flush, and clamp up the sides. Only the corners of the doors need a touch up with varnish. The edges of the laminate are not visible

In any case, I haven't bought in any materials, but I do have a lot of scraps of mdf and "junk" glossy laminate handy, so I will be experimenting a bit before I make any decisions.

It is a lot of work doing it myself, but then again, the wife wants to buy new appliances.

Anyone envy my position?

By the way, I glued up some soft maple edging to both mdf and particle board scraps yesterday. Today I tried removing the banding with a chisel. Got mostly wood failure from the edging not the mdf. This was the LV 2001 stuff. The edging on my previous projects has not come off either, and I'm pretty sure I used generic yellow glue for that.