Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Repairing a split tree questions.

Posts

Repairing a split tree questions.

#1

Repairing a split tree questions.

Barry Irby

I have a Redbud tree that has red leaves. (Cercis Forest Pansy) It is aobut 25 years old and is the largest one I know of. It has split at a branch union. The two branches are about 7 or maybe 8" in diameter. It has been split for several years. Today I got a piece of stainless steel All-Thread rod to use to make the brace or repair. I plan to drill through the two branches and counter pore just enough to make a flat for the washer and then snug up the nuts.

Any guidance? How high above the split should the rod be? Any advice on sealing or filing the split?

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#2

An arborist could help


Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#3

What My Guy Did

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

We had a smallish maple do that after a storm, so I called in my tree guy to attempt a save. Went 5' above the split and put a stainless I-bolt through each lead.

He then winched the leads together to close the split with a heavy come-along.

Next he drilled through the split and bolted the two halves together with a 3/4" all-thread rod with nuts and heavy washers.

Lastly he put cable between the I-bolts and swedged the ends, then removed the winch to put the tension on the cable.

He explained that the cable will position the two leads but will channel any wind force right to the split so the bolt was there to take that stress off the remaining good wood in the crotch.

Also said that as the tree get heavier a new cable will be needed higher up.

As the tree has continued to grow and put on wood, the split has appeared to blend a bit, but I have no doubt that if the cable fails the two leads will split open at the join again.

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#4

Re: What My Guy Did

Tom Dunlap

I'm an arborist. Right now I'm thumb typing so wait until I get home with a keyboard to give a proper reply

Hold off on doing any work for now

Tom

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#5

Will Do, thanks


Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#6

While You Wait

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Wouldn't be a bad idea to post (or email tom direct) a photo of the tree and the split UC&P so he's got a better idea of your issues.

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#7

A WC search *LINK*

mdclor

yielded the the below link. As I recall, William also posted a follow up message detailing the fix after it was completed.


Tree Surgery

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#8

Re: A WC search

William Duffield

Here's the link to the folllow-up thread. The advise I got here was greatly appreciated, especially with a little analysis, and thinking about the repairs that Longwood Gardens has done to their trees and vines over the years.

http://longwoodgardens.org

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=1182TrncnV25yS69f9m1437172409;spage=1;sanc=482055;sbid=1001;md=read;id=482055#m_482055

Tom Dunlap and Keith Newton's advise, at the link are also very useful. Per Tom's advise, I replaced the fender washers I show in the pictures in that post.

Ten months later, the repair is still holding, the bark has grown over the stainless screws I put in the split, the tree is healthy, and neither branch appears to have suffered from the wound. This spring, it put on its best show ever, first totally covered in blooms and then producing a bountiful crop of apricots, or ume as they are called in Japan.

Note that my apricot tree is a lot smaller than your redbud, which will make a difference in the scale of the hardware you use. We need to compare redbuds. The two I have are also huge, but not fancy varieties.

Somewhere, I might have some photos of some of Longwood's repairs, if you need them.

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#9

Re: What My Guy Did

Ernie Miller Topeka

I dd that to a red bud 20 years ago however I used 3 bolts one at the top of the split and another a couple feet up however winch the tree together several feet above the top bolt first. it would have been best to do it immediately after the sllit. My tree is strong and healthy

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#10

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

Tony-Memphis

I am NOT an arborist, nor do I play one on TV. I repaired a small dogwood using stainless bolts. Still holding after a year or so. I immediately clamped the break after the storm and tied it up with string. Then covered it up with plastic on top only to keep water from entering the wound and freezing. Both halves leafed and flowered this spring (yay!). I did not seal the wound with anything. Thought about wax, but never tried it. Good luck with yours. Trees are amazingly tough.

Tony

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#11

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

Tom Dunlap

Water will get in no matter what you do.

In the profession we haven't put any sort of wound dressing on for close to 40 years. The exception is for disease issues...which is unrelated to cracks and wounds.

The important thing is the mechanical support and holding the broken pieces in place so that the annual growth increments can flow over the wound and create a new sheet of tissue. Think of a volcano or dripping candles.

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#12

Industry standards

Tom Dunlap

Like anything there are lots of ways to cable/brace a tree. In the US there is an industry approved ANSI standard for cabling and bracing:

https://www.treecaresupplies.com/BV-1030-Tree-Support-Systems-cabling.html

Here's a pdf of a good portion of the ANSI standard:

http://www.sherrilltree.com/site/ZTV_Tree_Cabling_SherrillB.pdf

Read Section 3.3 about cracks.

A Powerpoint from a retired Purdue professor, lots of pics but little dialog. Lots to learn even so:

https://www.agriculture.purdue.edu/fnr/urbanforestry/pdf/06CablingBracing.pdf

http://www.stltreecare.com/images/stories/support-systems2.jpg

The location of the brace/rod is based on the diameter of the branch above the branch union. Put it between one and two times the diameter. So, in your case, between 8-16". In essence you're creating a scarf joint. If you're lucky, in time, the tree will grow over the wound and the cambium sheet will be whole again. Think of volcano flows or dipping candles.

Here's what I started doing years ago to make a stronger installation. If you look at the Purdue slide show you'll see dissections of old cabling/bracing. See the decay? Now look at each ensuing year...no decay. Put the washer on against the trunk. DO NOT CUT AWAY ANY LIVE BARK!!! Just seat it on the bark. Install nut. Now...another washer and nut. The tree will grow and envelop the inner washer which is seated against a decay pocket. Then, as the tree grows, the second washer is seated on sound wood. Not unlike a spline I guess.

YOu might need a flexible support up higher too. If you use eye bolts don't use the weak ones from the borg. Mild steel eye bolts/screws will likely open up. Find solid eyes.

The best place to install the cable is about 2/3 of the distance from the branch union to the tips of the branches. Get close...this isn't heart surgery.

If you have any more questions ask away.

In my lifetime of being an arborist I've seen lots of really bad cabling/bracing systems and lots of proper ones too. After storms I've seen a LOT of trees with bad systems still standing and right next door a tree with the same structure, but NO support...broken and ready for removal. Some is better than none.

Tom

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#13

Thanks Tom and everybody else.

Barry Irby

I have been out thee trying to stare the crack into submission. Its not as bad as I thought. It has sealed the crack. I have been trying to ignore this for about two years. I went out and strapped it with a nylon strap and cranked up tight as soon as I spotted the split. The strap has come loose/failed, but the crack is sealed. So as soon as I can free up my ladder I am going to bolt it.

On additional question. I have a six foot long stainless steel piece of all thread a half inch in diameter. My question is, Would a cable be better? I occurs to me that the rod may tend to flex when the wind blows and wallow out the holes, preventing it from sealing. so, Use the rod or go get Eye bolts and cable?

PS: Tom, that was some really good stuff you posted. Thanks.

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#14

More...

Tom Dunlap

Your staring has given you some good insights about the dynamics of bracing and cabling as well as how trees move.

Without a picture here is what I usually do:

-Use wide straps and a come-along installed just above or below where the cable will go. Pull the branch back into the best position.

-Bolt the trunk below the branch union. My guess is that you'll only need one.

-Install a cable above.

Sometimes I'll brace above the crack too. It takes luck or a long bit to drill all of the way through.

There isn't much of a concern about the wallowing...good term!...wearing out the hole.

The use of 'aircraft' cable isn't allowed in our standards for limbs above about 4" diameter. The cable will bend at the swages and break. Also, using u-clips, even the right number, isn't good because they're not rated for the movement and impact loads that might happen in trees.

Take a look here for non-metal cabling systems and cable stops.

http://www.treestuff.com/store/start.asp?category_id=52

Tom

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#15

Re: A WC search

William Duffield

According to Tom's instructions and attached documents, there are several things I could have done better. So, follow Tom's advise elsewhere in this thread, instead of following my photos.

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#16

Correction

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I looked up at our cable and the ends are not swedged but rather are run around an I-splice loop and then reverse-wrapped exactly as shown in the link Tom posted.

Re: Repairing a split tree questions.

#17

Ellis Walentine

Great info, Tom. Thanks!