Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Finishing Ash

Posts

Finishing Ash

#1

Finishing Ash

Gordon

I have never worked with Ash and I wanted to know how hard is it to finish?

I was going to use a darker reddish Mahogany finish for this project.

What stain would be best for this wood.

I have always used Min-Wax in the past and would Min-Wax

be a good finish for Ash.

Thank you for your help.

Gordon

Re: Finishing Ash

#2

Re: Finishing Ash

Dick Coers

Not much different than finishing red oak. I rarely if ever stain wood these days. Ash can have such a beautiful shimmer to it, a shame to stain in my opinion.

Re: Finishing Ash

#3

Re: Finishing Ash

paul in AZ

Another vote for not staining. I hardly ever stain good wood.

I have several ash pieces I built maybe 30 years ago.

One chest finished with boiled linseed and waxed a few times over the years is a lovely honey color with grain pattern nicely visible.

Another is a coffee table simply varnished and the color is similar, if a hair lighter.

Ash will start out very light and will gradually mellow out. I have no idea of it's staining characteristics.

Re: Finishing Ash

#4

A contrary opionion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I find ash the most difficult wood to stain with the oil pigment stains I normally use. Ash just doesn't take up stain. While I stain most everything I don't stain ash, for this reason. I suspect a dye stain would work well.

As we always say, don't do chemistry experiments on the finished project. Practice on a test piece, what ever you do.

Re: Finishing Ash

#5

JL

Re: Finishing Ash

JL

Ash takes dye quite well. If you choose to use a dye stain.

Re: Finishing Ash

#6

Thank you.

Gordon

I would like to thank everyone for their input on staining Ash.

I will definitely do test pieces and I will try a dye, which I never

have used in the past. Recommendations to a brand of dye to use?

Gordon

Re: Finishing Ash

#7

Examples

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

TV cab in solid ash stained with Minwax medium walnut



finished in hand-applied oil poly.

compare

Ash trestle table stained with TransTint medium brown dye mixed thin and applied in several coats to "build" the color, then tinted with a mist coat of dewaxed shellac with a touch of TransTint Red Mahogony dye. Topped with General Enduro Clear Poly.


The dye is easier to control as a general color and is more forgiving than the pigmented oil which collects in the grain as well as any cross-grain scratch you may have missed. ;)

Re: Finishing Ash

#8

A Caution

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Oil stains (pigment or dye) are essentially self-sealing finishes. When dry/cured they can be top-coated with most anything.

NGR [non grain raising] dye stains in alcohol or water should be sealed before applying a top coat, especially waterbased coatings and very especially if hand-applied. Reason being the NGR stain dye particles can be "pulled" from an unsealed surface , making the top coat look muddy. Sealing them into the surface with a spit coat of shellac, lacquer, even artist's Fix-a-tif, will improve results significantly.

Re: Finishing Ash

#9

Alan Young

Ash Step Stools

Alan Young

No Stain-Minwax Antique Oil Finnish


Re: Finishing Ash

#11

Info on Staining Ash

Gordon

Thank you everyone once again for all of your responses about staining Ash.

I think that I will give dye a try. I need to color the Ash a darker reddish color to match

a piece of furniture in our bedroom.

I appreciate the pictures showing how the stain or dye came out on your Ash projects.

Like they say, " A picture is worth a thousand words".

Many, many thanks to everyone.

Gordon

Re: Finishing Ash

#12

Very Welcome

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Don't forget, practice on scrap ;)

Re: Finishing Ash

#13

Clint Searl

Another example

Clint Searl

Waterborne dye stain under CAB lacquer: https://www.flickr.com/photos/clintsearl/5212487437/in/album-72157625481271966/

Re: Finishing Ash

#14

Ellis Walentine

Not applicable here, but...

Ellis Walentine

...ash bleaches really well with two-part wood bleach. It goes to white-white, and if you seal it under a coat of water-white lacquer, it'll stay that way for a long long time.

For your purposes, I agree with the others regarding dye stains on ash and other open pore woods. Pigments just accentuate the grain contrast too much for my taste. OTOH, I've followed up a coat of dye stain with a thin coat of shellac, sanded lightly and wiped a bit of oil-based pigment stain on to add depth and complexity. The dye stains tend to look really uniform, maybe too much so, and they lack that glaing complexity that adds richness to the overall look. You just don't want to bring out the huge springwood rings of ash too much.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Finishing Ash

#15

Correction

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Water-dissolved dye stain is anything BUT "NGR"

duh! :\

Re: Finishing Ash

#16

Those are some nice ash stools! (nm)