Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT tube filler

Posts

OT tube filler

#1

OT tube filler

Gary Smyth

I have a thought to fill 1/2" EMT conduit permanently with some sort of inexpensive filler that will make the tube more rigid. I was thinking of epoxy, some sort of liquid rubber or expanding foam or something like it. Weight is not much of a consideration but something like lead is not in the plan. Expansion and splitting the thin walled tube if the filler expands is. The item's end use is as a "handle" that was bent into a wide "U" shape. I think that it will hold up in light use, but a filler of some sort would make me feel better as it is pulled/yanked over time. Filling the tube will also prevent kinking. Is there some sort liquid that can flow into the tube, and solidify to make the tube handle act more solid in use? Would play sand work? Whatever comes to mind will be considered.

Re: OT tube filler

#2

Re: OT tube filler

Keith Newton

Packing a pipe or tube with sand is a trick to keep it from kinking whenever doing a bend, but I wouldn't count on it doing much to make it stiffer afterwards. You would probably be better off going up in diameter, or wall thickness for that.

Also, round tube is not really the best for stiffness when it comes to X amount of metal, due to it's tendency to flatten in section under load. You might do better to think of square or rectangular tube, or I-beam, but both of those are harder to bend without distortion, if you are not equipped to work it.

Re: OT tube filler

#3

Re: OT tube filler

John in NM

Urethane resin perhaps? From the sound of it, even polyester resin would do, even though it doesn't pour as well and is more brittle than urethane (at least the one's I've used, there are probably far more resin varieties under the sun than I've ever imagined).

The advantage of polyester is it's cheap and readily available at the auto parts store - it's the bonder in bondo, also available as a kinda liquid substance that you can dip fiberglass sheeting in for layering. The urethane I've used is more expensive, generates more heat, but is nicely not viscous and sets really fast.

Re: OT tube filler

#4

Pitch

Ray Thompson

Horn makers fill their tubes with pitch before bending, then heat and pour out. Wax will work also.

Ray

Re: OT tube filler

#5

Re: OT tube filler

John K Jordan

The way I read your note is the tube is already bent into the shape desired and you want to add something to stiffen it. Is that right? Can you slide another tube inside that just fits? That's how I strengthen or repair thin-wall tubing, tack welded for steel and soldered for brass. This would only reinforce the straight section but the bent handle could possibly be filled with epoxy. The hardest thing about the doubled tubing method is finding the right size! So far I've been lucky each time.

If you lived in East TN I'd say stop by and I'll give you a piece of titanium thin wall tubing. We found a stack of new 10'+ pieces (1/2 or 5/8" dia, can't remember) at a scrap yard and bought a bunch for a couple of bucks each. I think the crook could be formed with the packed sand technique and a plywood guide. Very strong and light weight.

Curious, what is the use?

Re: OT tube filler

#6

polyester resin shrinks when it dries

Dick Coers

so will pull away from the tube.

Re: OT tube filler

#8

It is terrible for shrinking....

John in NM

Most curing reactions are exothermic and there will be some shrinking, but polyester resin is pretty bad. I'd forgotten that.

Whether it pulls away from the tubing wall or not depends on how well it adheres and the geometry - going to shrink more the long way. Still a problem if it pulls away of course, but one might be able to manage it by successive pours, keeping the length to cross section reasonable.

Re: OT tube filler

#9

Kneale Brownson

Re: OT tube filler

Kneale Brownson

I'd try to stiffen it with that spray foam insulation stuff.

Re: OT tube filler

#10

Re: OT tube filler

Hank Knight

+1

Spray foam sealer/insulation was my thought too. Comes in a pressurized tube at the BORG. Sticks to everything and is difficult to remove.

Re: OT tube filler

#11

Dowel and epoxy?

Tom Dunlap

Rather than filling completely with epoxy. Could you use a dowel as a plug and surround it with epoxy? Make the plug a little shorter than the tube so the end isn't exposed

Re: OT tube filler

#12

Re: OT tube filler

George Koch

Spray foam insulation would be by choice too. I used it in cheaper kayak paddles to make them buoyant. I used a small diameter plastic tubing taped over the straw that came with it to insure the foam got all the way to the bottom then slowly pulled it out as the foam filled the pipe/handle.

Re: OT tube filler

#13

From the mouths of babes.

Gary Smyth

Last evening while trying to explain the above problem to the Father, his nine year old daughter popped in suggesting CASTING RESIN like she uses at camp to make her "jewelry". Goes in liquid and comes out solid. Total 16 oz. for $11-$12. Part A&B, mix 1 to 1. Available at craft stores, art suppliers and some Walmarts. Consistency of syrup. poured down the inside of one side of the "U" tube handle and rises to the level of the other side. 20 minutes work time. Warm, but nothing troublesome. If I had a vacuum pump to degas it would have been better so it probably has pin hole trapped bubbles, but SO FAR seems to do what I wanted. Once cured, 24-48 hours solid I expect it to be easily drilled for screw anchors without kinking the tube. TA DA !