Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Polycrylic?

Posts

Polycrylic?

#1

Polycrylic?

Gary Smyth

What is polycrylic? For home utility use over wood, when compared to paint, shellac, and polyurethane the advantage seems ahead of the others. It's quick to dry, fully cures in 48 hours, it is uncolored, and water based. As far as I can experience it goes on smoothly, sands down nicely, it comes in satin, semi gloss, and gloss, and while it may need more coats, protects as well (short term at least) as the other options. It can be brushed, sprayed, wiped, and padded AND it can be used on top of other (dry) finishes.

It's a bit more expensive, but convenient. For speed alone in the summer climate it works. There must be drawbacks. For recent projects it has saved days of time and for applications inside or under cover I have no complaints. I've read some reviews but nothing too awful. Before I buy more as a "go to" coating, am I missing something?

Re: Polycrylic?

#2

Added to my own question

Gary Smyth

Can polycrylic be tinted with dyes?

Re: Polycrylic?

#3

have you used it on walnut or cherry?

Dick Coers

I think it looks horrible on those woods. I seldom buy my finishes at a big box store. I don't consider them premium products. I buy General Finishes or Sherwin Williams commercial. I've never used your product, can't answer to the question of dye.

Re: Polycrylic?

#4

Not walnut. Yes on

Gary Smyth

oak and birch - solid and ply, pine, poplar, maple. and I believe, ash. All are light color woods to begin. Nothing exotic. Some items were previously painted. All are repair or replacement sections of existing stuff. Part of my asking is to consider use with old pine and cherry in a repair project. All are important at the time, but only one is a piece worth pouring heart and soul into.

Re: Polycrylic?

#5

Tried It, Dumped It

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Whatever the formula used now, I gave it a go some years ago and found its refractive quality (how it internally handles light) to be objectionable; had a distinctive blue cast to the cured coating. Did not flow particularly well, being prone to orange peel.

For waterborne finishes, go with General's pro line or Target's stuff. Far and away better.

Note on water based finishes: I've learned the hard way to never apply them to bare wood (regardless of what the label says). Being water based, they will all tend to pucker the wood grain which kills the potential depth of a finish film. Always use a dewaxed shellac or solvent lacquer as a sanding sealer and then sealer coat before applying the waterbornes. You will be pleased with the result


Pictured: White Oak with General Enduro Clear Poly over 2 light applications of Ultra Pale shellac "off the gun" no rub-out


Same on Maple


Same on Walnut

Re: Polycrylic?

#6

Did I mention

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Cherry?


Shellac use was Dark Garnet with a drop of Transtint Red added to a quart.

Re: Polycrylic?

#7

Re: Polycrylic?

Walt

I agree that it's not a good finish used alone. I've used it for a quick 'n' dirty protective layer over 'latex' paints or over water based or shellac color coats. More cabinetry or utility pieces rather than fine furniture. It doesn't seem to get tacky like latex paint can once dry. I imagine it could be tinted with transtint but I've never tried it.

Re: Polycrylic?

#8

Yeah-but

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You can tint water based finishes, however it's very tough to do anything other than spray because of the lap marks. I usually use the shellac later as a tinting medium because it's so easy to correct with a rag wet with alcohol. In the acrylic finish, you've got some sanding to do to reverse mistakes, laps, etc.

Re: Polycrylic?

#9

ebd

Re: Polycrylic?

ebd

I've used it intensively. Primarily on wood trim (mostly pine) and some birch, beech, oak, and poplar (shoe racks, shelving, small tables, etc.). I've never had any problems with it. I don't know about tinting because if I'm going to color I use a penetrating stain on the raw wood. That gives me pretty much complete control over the final color.

I guess it depends on what the finished object will be used for and how elegant the finish needs to be. It certainly is a lot easier to use & clean up than other finishes.

Re: Polycrylic?

#10

Re: Polycrylic?

Steve Schoene

You speak of it as if it were a separate category from other finishes. It is just one brand of a large group of waterborne finishes. The waterborne finishes largely use acrylic resin with or without an additional resin such as polyurethane or alkyd.

Only modest differences between brands based on which particular solvents are used, the specific form of acrylic or other resins and whether other additives do things like prevent foaming, etc.