Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Table in Walnut *PICS*

Posts

Table in Walnut *PICS*

#1

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Table in Walnut *PICS*

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Made another one of these... this time in walnut. 36" diameter glass top, 17" tall.

Torus Knot Table

Close-up:

Torus Knot Table Close-up

The 30 pieces which dovetailed together end-to-end:

Torus Knot Table Parts

Mark

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#2

wow


Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#3

Re: Table in Walnut

Yonak

Very interesting, Mark. Nice fit on the dovetails. Any special reason why you chose to put an extra twist on the pieces in the center ? Would it be extra hard to design and mill the twist to be incorporated in all the pieces, like in a Möbius strip concept, maybe ?

How would you gauge the time spent on design compared to the rest ? All your stuff is very impressive. Thanks for sharing.

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#4

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: Table in Walnut

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Thanks, Yonak.

I get asked frequently about the twist in the middle piece. Where it "threads the loop" they twist. This keeps the dovetails so that they are always on the top surface as viewed from the top. So if you prefer you can flip the table over and the dovetails will always be down towards the floor so you never see them.

It would be possible to smooth out the twist so it occurred over the entire length. Or to eliminate the twist altogether (some people really don't like the twist). Both would be interesting to try.

It took a while to design because I had to write the computer program to generate the parts. Now that I have it done it's easier to generate new tables. This one was 30% smaller than the original. It also took a while to work out the toolpath programming so they cut cleanly.

Parts

Mark

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#5

Re: Table in Walnut

Lars Parrington

What machine are you using to make these pieces? Some kind of cnc router with more than 3 axis?

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#7

Re: Table in Walnut

Brian Roberts

Very interesting!

That's a whole big pile of machine time.......how many hours into fixturing and cutting?

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#8

Re: Table in Walnut

Lars Parrington

Thanks! Great blog, btw. Interesting to see that big machine in action. I built a 4 axis cnc this winter/spring which I've been enjoying using. Although, now that I've seen your video, I'll just be thinking about how puny, weak, and slow it is :-)


Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#9

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: Table in Walnut

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Thanks for the picture. Very cool. I can't visualize how the 4th axis works.

What software drives it?

Mark

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#10

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: Table in Walnut

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

The non-twisty parts (27 of them) are about 25 minutes each between the two cutting phases. The three twisty ones are slooooow. Those are 37 minutes each. If the parts didn't have to cantilever into space to be cut, LOL, it could go much faster! Chip load, feed rate and spindle speed are all slave to vibration management.

Mark

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#11

Re: Table in Walnut

Brian Roberts

Very cool!

Is the 4th axis a pivot for the router?

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#12

Re: Table in Walnut

Brian Roberts

I "feel your pain"!

We cut aluminum at work and fixturing, tool length, feeds and speeds are an art to be sure.

We hang some small cutters way out there to cut some of the risers (archery) but I don't think any individual cutters cost close to $500. What is the reason for that high cost? We did some pretty aggressive cuts in the guitar (wood) area too. In many respects wood is tougher to program because of the varying grain direction and density.

Making a profit on your table wasn't a concern I'm guessing? Or a very generous patron.....

Very nice work!

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#13

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

Sgian Dubh

Mark, you join a growing band of furniture designer makers, some of which I know, utilising the power of digital technology and CNC production to realise interesting 'craft' work. How long, I wonder, would it take to achieve something like that using more traditional techniques, e.g., entirely handwork, or with machines, including spindle moulders and perhaps routers and a mass of jigs, formers and fixtures? As I understand it, something like 90%+ of CNC work in the furniture industry consists primarily of creating panels from sheet goods and boring holes for dowels, shelf pins, Euro hinges and the like. In other words, the technology focuses primarily on utilitarian end results, end results that I'm criticising.

I'm not well versed in this way of working, although I do use AutoCAD, and I've sometimes translated this through AlphCam to produce items on a CNC machine. I find the possibilities of using this technology for technically challenging and visually interesting end results an exciting and developing field for the craft worker to explore. I continue to develop my digital skills (AutoCAD, etc) because I think the possibilities offered by the technology adds something beneficial to the traditional design and craft skills I was taught something like four decades ago! Here in the UK Waywood Furniture (link below) is one example of a small furniture designer maker similarly using such technology in interesting ways. Slainte.

http://www.waywood.co.uk/

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#14

Re: 4th axis *LINK*

Lars Parrington

Sorry, actually the 4th axis isn't in that picture. But, here (link below) is a video showing it. It is just a rotary stage, and the tailstock shown is borrowed from my lathe.

The cnc controller software is TinyG2 running on an Arduino Due. Mostly I generate G-code using Cambam. Except if the 4th axis is being used, In which case I just write the G-code by hand.

I have been using the cnc to make a small batch of yarn winders. Here are some example parts:




https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UOTN6yGimjc

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#15

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

Sgian Dubh

Oops. As I was reading Lars's latest contribution to the thread I spotted a typo in my earlier post that inadvertently reverses what I meant to say, and conveys the wrong impression entirely.

The first paragraph in that post ends: "In other words, the technology focuses primarily on utilitarian end results, end results that I'm criticising". It should read 'In other words, the technology focuses primarily on utilitarian end results, end results that I'm not criticising'.

Sorry about that, and I hope people will note my correction. Slainte.

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#16

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: Table in Walnut

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

The table pictured on the blog was done when I was a student and I didn't have to pay for the machine time. The current table I did have to pay although I traded programming time for machine time so it was not an out of pocket cost. In any case if someone wants to buy one it's an expensive table :)

The >$500 cutter was a solid carbide Onsrud 3/4" 3-flute chipbreaker endmill with a cutter length of over 5". When I made the second table that first bit wasn't around so I bought a HSS endmill with a 4" cutter length. It was just over $100. So it is possible to get much cheaper tools (thank goodness).

Mark

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#17

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: 4th axis

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

I watched a bunch of your videos, Lars. I like the leg vise. And that winder is really nifty.

I would love to build my own machine. I've been talking about that for a few years. I need to get off my ass and do it :)

Mark

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#18

Re: 4th axis

Lars Parrington

Thx. If you're interested, there's more of my projects documented on lllars.com, though I've been really lazy about putting up new projects there lately.

It will be interesting to see what you come up with when you do get around to building your own machine, since you clearly have so much experience using them.

The design of my machine was guided by the linear slides I had on hand, and also the idea that the whole machine could be pickup up and clamped on top of a larger workpiece. I suppose it was inspired by the handibot), but I wanted a bigger work area. Haven't had a chance to make use of that portability yet.

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#19

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Yes, there is a great deal of very basic work done on CNC machines. I do it myself when the design has orthogonal parts and I simply want to cut them accurately and quickly. It took a little while but I now feel I can use a 3-axis CNC as easily as I can a table saw. It's just another tool which happens to be good at certain operations. But I feel it's much more interesting when you try to push the limits of what's possible. What really exciting to me is combining programming with geometry generation.

Even with all the machinery there's still a role for hand work. When I was a kid I did everything with hand tools - saws and rasps mostly. As an adult I wanted to make furniture. So I switched to doing nearly everything with power tools. But I grew tired of the dust and noise and switched for a few years to being really into hand tools again. I love wood and I feel so much more connected to it when working by hand. Then I discovered CNC machines and I started to incorporate them.

I'm fortunate because I have access to all the machines where I teach at the University of Michigan. There is an unbelievable amount of potential in these machines and I intend to spend the remainder of my working career exploring what I can make with them.

Thanks for the link - I had a look around Waywood's site. They have some very refined work!

Mark

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

#20

Re: Table in Walnut *PICS*

Lars Parrington

Reiterating what Mark wrote, I've caught myself lately debating whether to use the cnc or the drill press to make a hole. The cnc won, but only because I was making the same hole in 20-something identical parts.

My eggbeater drills and bit braces don't get used any less. And, most parts get a few swipes of the #4 plane after coming off the cnc machine, towards getting the flat surfaces ready for finishing, and taking off any raggedy edges left by the cutting.

In my shop, the conventional power and hand tools are still much faster for one-off parts, unless the part is very complicated or needs to be very accurate.