Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT: Brake Replacement

Posts

OT: Brake Replacement

#1

OT: Brake Replacement

Stuart Johnson

I've got a '98 Dodge Ram that sees less than 500 miles a year. When I last had it in for some service I was told the brakes needed to be replaced and they were starting to score(?) the rotors. So they would need to be turned.

My question, is there considering the miles driven any need to do anything other than getting new pads?

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

#2

Depends

Nat Robison

Depends if there's enough material left on the rotor so they can machine them flat. If not, you'll be in for new rotors. For me, rotors are fairly cheap insurance for helping make sure your truck stops when and how you want it to.

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

#3

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

Chuck in Mtl.

no need to turn the rotors as new rotors are quite inexpensive as are the brake pads. A complete brake job should be an hour of labor plus parts. unless the wheel cylinder has seized then add the time to replace this part, bleed the air from the lines.

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

#4

Does it sit outside?

Dick Coers

The rotors on my Astro van actually had chunks come out from excess rust. Cast rotors can really get messed up with little use. As mentioned, new can be reasonable.

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

#5

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

Bill Howatt

Cheap? Maybe, maybe not. My friend had a '96 (IIRC) Dodge pickup and the front rotors and hubs were one piece which made replacing very expensive. Check out the cost before proceeding just in case yours is like this.

Personally, for a vehicle that is so infrequently used, a bit of scoring wouldn't be a big deal. It just means the pads will need to wear in a bit.

Bill

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

#6

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

John K Jordan

If it's like my '99 Ram (2500 diesel) the rotors may be a royal pain to remove. I would probably examine the rotors myself (or get a second opinion) to decide if the rotors really need surfacing or replacing or if that shop was trying to drum up some business. I've found that minor scratches make no difference in pad wear or stopping power; major gouging is a different story.

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

#7

Re: OT: Brake Replacement thanks everyone

Stuart Johnson

I was at the dealer for a cheap oil change when they said I needed the complete brake job. I'm sure a dealership wouldn't try to drum up business ;)

I'm going to take it to one of the backyard type shops and have new pads installed. No more than it's driven I don't care if they only last 1/4 of the normal pad life.

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

#8

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

TomD

Just did my brakes after they started making a terrific amount of noise on Friday last. I got the parts at delco, and the premium pads (there are two levels above that) and the cheap rotors were over 250. If I lived in the US I would have ordered from Amazon where the price is much lower.

I was big into buying lathes a few years back and brake lathes (not my deal) were all over the web. The art of brake turning seems a lost one, and the reason is all the cheap parts from out of the country. The last time I did an F-150 brake job it was 39 dollars to replace the rotors. that was about 10 years ago, and I didn't like doing the rotors because one had to repack the bearings and all that jazz, plus on some vehicles one needs a huge honking torque wrench though given the axis of swing, that ought to be something one could figure.

On the new truck the rotors come off with the wheels, so no biggie. But I still didn't want to mess with them if I didn't have to. In the end, despite being just over 5 years old the rotor was crumbling with rust in the cooling fins. I opted to replace them, and off course the one that was screaching was all scored up. Interesting to say that the toss line was less than 1/16 in wear.

My feeling is that in the last ten years the parts folk have bounced back to the point where the home job is a lot easier, but the cost of parts from china is now higher than the cost of getting your dealership to do them (though that cost will have gone up too I guess).

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

#9

Re: OT: Brake Replacement thanks everyone

john lucas

The local chevy dealer tried to rip off my new bride when she had an oil change. They told her that the tired needed rotating so she did it. Then they told her one of the tire sensors was bad and had to be replaced at $160. I told her bullshit. Sensors don't just go bad conveniently when you rotate tires. On her car you can do a relearn when you rotate the tires by going into the program mode and clicking on relearn and then deflate each tire as necessary when the turn signal on that tire blinks. After doing that, which took about 15 minutes you re inflate the tires and now the car was back to normal. I've written that dealership several times with no response.

Re: OT: Brake Replacement

#10

Re: OT: Brake Replacement thanks everyone

Bill Howatt

That is either dishonesty or incompetence!

I would write to GM about it; I'm sure they don't want either condition at their dealerships.

Bill