Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

Posts

Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#1

Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Zinsser SealCoat is a 2 cut cut of shellac, right?

How much alcohol should I add to say 1 ounce of SealCoat to end up with a 1 pound cut? Would it be 1 to 1?

What if I wanted a 1-1/2 pound cut?

Never too good with math and chemistry, so type slowly so I understand... :)

Also, I've done some thread searches here and some reading, I guess Denatured Alcohol is pretty nasty stuff (methanol?). I am going to pick up a bottle of 190 Everclear ($18/750ml) tonight. Would that have an affect on the cut?

Thanks in advance.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#2

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

William Duffield

Yes, Seal-Coat is a 2 lb. cut of dewaxed shellac.

Most days, doing the math is too hard for me too, so I look it up.

http://www.finewoodworking.com/how-to/article/mixing-shellac.aspx

To dilute 1 oz. of 2 lb. cut to a 1 lb. cut, add 2/3 oz. of DNA.

To convert 1 oz. of 2 lb. cut to a 1-1/2 lb. cut, add 1/4 oz. of DNA.

It will only have an affect if you drink some of it. :D

The drying rate of the shellac-alcohol mixture does depend to a small extent on the denaturant. Methanol evaporates faster than ethanol, while propanol and isobutanol (the denaturants in Seal-Coat and Behcol, respectively) evaporate more slowly than ethanol. Water ( a minor component of Everclear) evaporates even more slowly. So, adding Everclear or DNA denatured with methanol

to Seal-Coat will cause a very minor decrease in drying time, while adding Behcol will cause a very minor increase in drying time, since butanol has a higher molecular weight than propanol. Note that it is not the molecular weight specifically that you would use to calculate the change in drying time, but the partial pressures of the various components. It's been way too long since I studied chemistry, and now I have a headache just thinking about it.

Your application tool and method and the temperature and humidity in your shop will have a lot more effect on drying time and smoothness of the finish than any small adjustments to the denaturant you will make.

That's about what it costs in NJ, too. It's quite a bit cheaper in Kentucky.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#3

Cuts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

1. Right

2. Not weight, measure. The "cut" means how much dry shellac is mixed into a gallon of solvent. 2 lbs flakes to the gallon = 2lb. cut.

Once the shellac is mixed you adjust the cut by solvent measure. Thus if you dilute 1/4 cup of 2lb. shellac with 1/4 cup of alcohol, you have 1/2 cup of 1lb cut shellac. :) Think: If you put 2 lbs of dry shellac into a gallon of alcohol, you've got a gallon of 2lb. cut. If you add another gallon of alcohol, you've got that same 2 lbs of shellac now in 2 gallons of alcohol ie 2 gallons of 1 lb cut product.

3. Alcohol. Many DNA brands use high amounts of methanol to "denature" the base ethanol; some as high as 50%. You can, of course use Everclear which is as close as you're likely to get in the way of pure ethanol without a special license (or your own still ;) ) but you will be fine if you use a DNA like the Parks brand which uses only 10% methanol. Remember, the alcohol used does not render your shellac finish toxic. All of the alcohol evaporates during the full drying process. Proper ventilation of the area is required regardless of what you use as the solvent, and a good organic vapor mask is required if you're spraying the stuff anywhere except out in the driveway.

HTH

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#4

what?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"To dilute 1 oz. of 2 lb. cut to a 1 lb. cut, add 2/3 oz. of DNA. " ?

It would be grand if this archaic means of expressing the solids content of shellac vanished to obscurity or at the very least was quarantined to the Hand Toll Forum .

The Zinser stuff is about 25% solids, that is to say if you evaporated a kg of the stuff 250 grams would remain as a shellac film. If you want to dilute it to 12.5% solids add one part to one part solvent.

If you want to "feel better" about diluting it, then drink the ethanol and dilute with something cheaper. I would become concerned about the diluting alcohol composition's health effects if I was brushing in a confined area. But then I would be more concerned about the fire hazard.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#5

Re: Cuts

John Jardin

A fine article on shellac by Mario Rodriguez: Fine Woodworking #234, pp. 38-43 June 6 2013

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#6

Re: what?

joe in a Cleveland suburb

Not too sure what you are saying. I think you are saying 1:1.

Also, it sounds like you arent too concerned about the hazards of using DNA.

Thanks.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#7

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thank you.

I need to print that chart.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#8

Re: Cuts

joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for the info.

I didn't get to the store last night so no everclear.

Before I get it, maybe I'll see if anybody has Parks near by.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Your chemistry is a bit off, Mark... *LINK*

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

"If you put 2 lbs of dry shellac into a gallon of alcohol, you've got a gallon of 2lb. cut. If you add another gallon of alcohol, you've got that same 2 lbs of shellac now in 2 gallons of alcohol ie 2 gallons of 1 lb cut product."

This is where the error is. When you dissolve 2 lb of shellac into a gallon of shellac, the result is MORE than one gallon of 2 lb-cut shellac.

Here a 'splanation:

http://lumberjocks.com/pjones46/blog/22129

The link says the volume of the solution is 1.2 gallons (1 gallon alcohol plus 2 lb shellac flakes), so 1 gallon of 2 lb cut contains 1 2/3 lb of dry shellac. So if you add a gallon of alcohol to that gallon of 2 lb, you would get 2 gallons of a 5/6 lb cut (which is pretty close to a 1 lb cut).

Jason


Shellac cuts link above

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#10

If we are going to split hairs.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We have not made it easier for Joe to get some finish on his clock, or understand shellac dilution.

As I recall from looking it up the Zinser stuff is described in terms of the more modern, and useful, metric of per cent solids. So if we are going to split hairs on how much to dilute it to get what was defined to be a 1 pound cut in 1720, or when ever this archaic measure of per cent solids was invented, we need to do an accurate conversion of the Zinser information to "pound cut" and then do the dilution taking into account the unnecessarily complicated change in volume upon dissolution, the wt/wt to wt/volume conversion and we might as well worry about a volume temperature correction as well to get accuracy to a tenth percent for a 1.000 pound cut.

In the end Joe is not going to detect any difference in applying a 10% solids solution vs 12%.

Try the Zinser stuff out of the can. If it leaves brush marks that don't level add some solvent. If it still dries too quick and doesn' t level add some more solvent. Personally for a first coat I pour about one volume of the 30% solids Zinser product(has wax) into the brushing container and add about that much more of what ever alcohol I conveniently find is some paint store.

I use the 30% solids product because I am cheap and I get more shellac for my dollar than if I buy the 20% stuff.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#11

Re: Chemistry

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

was never my best subject.

But I mix my own shellac 6 dry oz. to the quart and then either cut that in half (by volume) for sanding sealer / tinting coat or use it straight as sealer or tie coat. Whether it's 1-1/2 or 3/4 lb in accord with approved nomenclature makes no difference in my shop.

Unified standards I will gladly leave to the chemists. ;)

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#12

Re: Cuts

William Duffield

If you were mixing your own shellac, you could adopt the much more sensible method of using a gram scale and a graduated cylinder and measuring grams per milliliter, but as long as you are working with an arcane system, you are stuck doing the arcane math (or just experimenting until you get a dilution that works well for you. Precision is not important. Its just dilution and evaporation rate, not chemical reactions).

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#13

not claimed by Chemistry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Any formula conceived in 1720, or when ever shellac "cut" was invented is not to be claimed by the relatively modern field of chemistry. Nobody in modern times would come up with such an empirical description of concentration. See if the Alchemists will embrace the concept of "cut".

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#14

Cuts- too much fretting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Zinser is not using an arcane description. They use the widely accepted % solids. It was someone else that translated their % solids to a calculated, or estimated, or guessed, pound cut (who knows?). Accepting all these assumptions as fact one can then use an Internet Table, presumably accurately prepared, to achieve exactly a 1 pound cut upon dilution.

Alternatively one can dilute it by half and see if it works ok. Personally, I would dilute 1 part solvent to 2 parts Zinser and see if this more concentrated solution worked and if it did the finish would build faster. And if you are worried whether the result is a 1 pound cut or a 0.95 pound cut you are on the wrong forum.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#15

Now Now . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Bill, there are many among us who prefer precision in all aspects of what we do. They insist on it.

They are not to be disparaged for their preferences.

For instance, I know that adding 2 pounds of shellac to an even gallon of alcohol will result in a volume of liquid greater than one actual gallon. Those 2 pounds of dry resin do not somehow get transported into another dimension magically leaving behind this amber-colored liquid. It may matter to others to know the precise volumetric value of the resulting solution, but for me . . .

Meaning no disrespect . . I don't give a R-A.

Minute differences in drying time are also irrelevant for me; I'm not standing around watching paint dry, except when I need the stuff to dry more slowly (as stated, I have a remedy for that).

The stuff I mix up does exactly what I want and need it to do so . . . . "done."

No doubt this is why, when the Chemistry teacher jolted me awake to explain some reaction involving valences (window treatments?) and ion exchange to the rest of the class I answered, "Black Magic?"

He was not pleased.

Class loved it.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#16

Re: what?

Alexandre Grigoriev

But 1lb cut doesn't have 1/2 of solids of 2 lb.

Suppose your 2 lb cut has 25% solids by weight. Which means to dilute it to 1 lb cut, you need to add 750g of solvent, not 1 kg.

That said, the difference between 1# cut and 1:1 diluted 2# cut is not worth arguing over.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#17

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for the replies.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

It may be archaic...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...but it's useful.

How is dry shellac typically purchased? By weight of flakes. Measuring them by volume would be inconsistent, depending on the size of the flakes, which would affect the volume. Easy to visually divide up a purchased weight into a smaller measure if mixing a smaller batch.

How is denatured alcohol purchased? By liquid volume. Easiest to measure a liquid by volume usually, though it could be weighed, too.

But, whatever "cut" you want--you could probably buy the appropriate weight of flakes and volume of alcohol, not have to mess with any measurement whatsoever, and end up with a shellac solution that is "good enough".

Jason

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#19

We have lost how this all started

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Joe didn't purchase a pound of shellac and a gallon of alcohol. He purchased a gallon of Zinser shellac that somewhere in its literature says that it is XX% solids. Joe wanted to know how to turn what he bought into 1 pound cut shellac, more or less.

Somebody by some calculation has calculated, or guessed, or looked up on the Internet where someone else calculated or guessed, that the shellac he bought is a 2 pound cut, or maybe estimated to be a two pound cut.

Joe was already somewhat boggled as to how much to dilute what he got to brush it, with a target of about 1 pound cut because someone used this arcane description to describe what they brushed. I hope he wound up less boggled and got something to brush.

I think what he bought is 20% solids. At about 8 pounds a gallon that's about 2 pounds of shellac in a gallon. Not exactly the archaic definition of pound cut but close enough and given all the assumptions, dilute it 1:1 and try it.

If some brushing guru had said to brush 10% solids the discussion would have been more straightforward.

Re: Zinsser SealCoat Question(s)

#20

Thank You!