I am putting metal roofing on a shed. I always screwed metal roofing through the top of the ribs. Any leak here is of little to no consequence. Some Internet sites shows screwing next to the ribs on the flat part where water runs. I could not find any discussion of the choices.
For what it is worth, we just had a pro crew install metal roofing on our 12/12 pitch roof. All the screws were on top of the ribs. Metal roofing is popular here in the mountains of western NC, and what I see here is all screwed in from the top of the ribs as well
Bill, I grew up on a farm and installed a bunch of 5-Vee tin many years ago. As a Home Inspector I have researched the installation of the product for court cases.
I just went on line and looked it up again. It matches my recollection.
Generally, You nail or screw through the ribs, just as you thought. Also, "nest" both ribs along the edges and nail through the one closer to the center of the sheet. There is some science behind the double ribs that helps the roofing resist wind driven rain. The fasteners need a washer (rubber or lead) under the head to help seal the hole.
There are cases where you nail in the field between the ribs, but generally in wide open spaces, you do not. On gables and in very high wind climates you may have to.
This one is brand specific, and there are ones that reflect the industry and are non-specific, but this one is close enough. You could also look up the one for the brand you bought.
To start the hole through the ribs I lay a nail set on its side and whack it to create a little dimple in the top of the rib and then drive or drill through it. You may be able to find tech screws designed for this that have a drill bit point, threads, a washer and a washer head.
and my Dad had to get the nails started at the multi sheet overlap. I can't remember ever nailing down a new sheet of "tin". My Dad was a hoarder for building materials like that. He once had me on the roof of a two story corn crib with Bondo filling nail holes in the used tin. I was just over the grain bins over the center alley, but man he had me do some rough jobs!
Sure, if you are using corrugated tin, you would nail through the top of the ridge.
If you are using something like R-channel, the screws through the top of the rib, is only to join one sheet to the one next to it. Those screws are the self drilling type, usually 5/16" hex head, Tek,,,, I think.
The ones used to fasten the metal down to the framing will be out in the flat between ribs, and need to be suitable for whatever you are fastening down to. All of them will have a neoprene ring under a washer
The hardest thing about screwing any of these down, is getting the screws to penetrate the metal. It is easy after you punch through. I discovered late into the last one that I put down, that I could really save a lot of time and effort, by taking either a finish nail gun, or even a brad gun, empty of fasteners, to just shoot a starting hole, that I could then quickly with much less effort zip the screws through.
If you are getting the metal from a steel building supplier, they can advise you on the placement, and number of fasteners required.
Do be sure to get the drivers with the magnet inside to keep the screw from dropping out so easily.
Starting screws: A roofer here drills the holes in a whole stack of panels while they are still on the ground. Another friend prefers a hammer and nail to punch each hole while on the roof.
BTW, a cordless impact driver is hands-down the quickest way to drive these screws. Be sure to not over-compress the washer.
For my last building (one story) I fastened a piece of plywood to forks on the front-end loader of my tractor to lift stacks of roofing panels to the roof - this saved a LOT of time and effort. A length of 2x4 fastened to the plywood protected the edges from dings. A big c-clamp will keep the stack from sliding.
What is the rational for screwing the flat next to the ribs?
I am screwing through the ribs. Any sealing washer leak here will be of no consequence in the future. I am not having any problem starting the screws and I am not in agreement with the impact driver preference. If the screw is properly manufactured with a sharp self drilling point, a slow start with steady pressure drills the pilot hole quickly and reliably. A fast spin at the start can harden the metal under the point. Because I am screwing the ribs I need to be precise on the stopping point and I am not precise with an impact driver capable of driving a screw in seasoned oak.
You just need some more practice with that impact driver. I've found since I finally got an impact driver a year and a half ago that I can be a whole lot more accurate driving screws with good trigger control (feathering and/or pulsing the trigger on an 18V Bosch impact driver). After a while, you'll be driving screws to the correct depth automatically--I do it somewhat by ear.
Why is it recommended by some, maybe most, to screw through the flats next to the ribs and not through the top of the ribs? I can not figure out an advantage.
Probably gives you better wind resistance or some such thing - more surface area for the screw to bear on and putting holes in a structural rib is going to make the panel more likely to fold if the wind starts to take it off.... but I'm just making a WAG here.
Most of the metal roofs I've put on were a concealed fastener type, but the one I did with exposed screws the manufacturer said to put them in the field so that's what I did. I remember metal roofs when I was a kid in Maine that were done they way you describe - forgot all about that until this thread
I don't understand why the wider outside rib goes underneath the narrower outside rib.
Everywhere I look it tells me it goes that way but it doesn't look right to me. When I built my shop I put them on wrong (didn't know any better) and it was about 20yrs ago and I still haven't had a problem. I am just trying to learn can somebody help me out? Earl
>I am screwing through the ribs. Any sealing washer leak here will
>be of no consequence in the future. I am not having any problem
>starting the screws and I am not in agreement with the impact driver
>preference. If the screw is properly manufactured with a sharp self
>drilling point, a slow start with steady pressure drills the pilot hole
>quickly and reliably. A fast spin at the start can harden the metal
>under the point. Because I am screwing the ribs I need to be precise
>on the stopping point and I am not precise with an impact driver
>capable of driving a screw in seasoned oak.
Starting the screw in the cheaper roofing was far easier than in the thicker metal that I always use now. I'll remember to consider the speed the next time.
Water can still leak in under a screw in the top of the rib if screwed in loosely or too tight, but not as easily as if it is on the flat. From one manufacturer:
" Use galvanized nails or plated self-drilling wood screws to fasten the 5V crimp roofing panels.
To correctly fasten the 5V crimp roofing sheets down, you should drive the nail through the steel so the nail washer is packed in tightly against the metal. Make sure not to drive the nail in too much since this could dimple the metal, which could lead to water collecting in the area and seeping through.
The nails should be two inches long so they can penetrate about 1-1/4 inches into the purlin if you’re driving them through the 5V crimp panel rib."
As for putting screws in the flats or ribs I suspect either way will work if the nails/screws are installed correctly. When we removed very old galvanized 5-V that was nailed in the flats on my old barn, I found no sign of water damage on the perlins.
Control of the impact driver is mastered with some practice and easier with a quality driver with variable speed, power, and impact control (i.e. choice of single or repeated impacts). I have several brands of drivers and use them for all construction screws, roofing, studs, paneling, door/window frames, etc. All of the roofers I know switched to impact drivers for metal roofing a few years ago - after working with one on one of my buildings I couldn't go back. However, some suppliers do not recommend using impact drivers - we assume due to the ease of overdriving if not careful.
BTW, I also find the impact driver amazingly efficient for drilling 3/4 and 1" holes in 2-by and thicker lumber to route wiring, air lines, and pipes. I use those aggressive 3-fluted spiral bits that have a screw tip that pulls the bit onto the wood. Effortless and SO much quicker than either non-impact drills or spade bits.
I found that when putting the screws through the rib ,if the screw is tightened too much it can distort the panel. Also if you're not dead center you may not get a good seal with the washer.The metal I use is recommended by the manufacturer to be screwed on the flats so I do it that way.McElroy Metals.---Jack
There is a lot of science going on with the roofing that is not obvious.
One thing is the Rain Screen. We use rain screens often in building without realizing it. A rain screen includes several components. One is the Screen and the other is the Back Stop. The screen is loose and open and allows the wind to pass through freely. The back stop is tight and does not allow the wind to pass through. Visualize a double hung window on a rainy day. There is an ordinary window screen in place, the window is closed. Even on a windy day not very much rain passes through the screen. The wind is the Driving Force that pushes the drops toward the window. The wind passes through the screen and deposits the water on the screen, but is back stopped by the window and it velocity drops to Zero and it fails to carry much rain past the screen. Open with window and you get wet.
Vinyl siding is an example few the screen. The Tyvek or felt behind it is the backstop. The vinyl is loose on purpose and it has drain holes in the bottom edge. What rain gets driven through the siding drools out the bottom edges of the siding pieces and or out the bottom of the Wall.
Brick veneer is also a rain screen. The reason for the weep holes at the bottom is to allow the wind to enter the wall and equalize the pressure across the brick.
There are many more applications for rain screens.
On 5-Vee tin the double Vee on each edge is a rain screen. The first Vee is the screen and the second one is the back stop. The outer one is looser then the inner one. The channel serves to let the driven ran drool out the bottom.
In areas with very high wind roofing develops "lift" like an airplane wind. Lightweight materials will billow up and get sucked off the roof. This would be a reason to nail or screw in the flats, to help it resist the lift.
Another topic is the nails should be driven through the purlins. Nail Pops are caused by the tip of the nail being buried in the wood and the expansion and contraction of the wood over time with changes in humidity "squirts" the nail back out. (A huge problem with drywall in the early days) The roofing industry solved the problem by using nails that pass all the way through the sheeting. If you see a nail backing out of the roof, in almost every case it will have been driven into the rafter and not THROUGH the sheeting or purlin. Ring shank nails help and screws are even better.